4 ms·
Yeah I was worried for a second jcs might have something interesting to say about backward- and forward- edge CFI, but then I remembered he's woke and closed th
by tptacek 2y ago
Yeah I was worried for a second jcs might have something interesting to say about backward- and forward- edge CFI, but then I remembered he's woke and closed the tab before the mind virus could get me.
- huang_chung 2y ago[flagged]
- dcow 2y agoNot to mention that in the general case it seems desirable that a community can exist without needing a CoC. Being disappointed that some community out there is doing just fine without CoC is a /really weird/ point to make in a marketing piece evangelizing how secure OpenBSD is as a technology. To the extent that it feels out of place and yes detracts. Some would even go so far as to argue that OpenBSD is second to none in security because they don’t give a shit about politics and tone in their community. They swiftly dismiss the wasted cycles spent on those in other communities, instead spending their precious time focusing on just being really good. The author sorta misses the plot point there.
- hackernoops 2y ago> /really weird/ That's only if you take CoC enjoyers at their word. It makes perfect sense when you realize it's not about advancing project or community, but rather controlfreak ideology.
- butter999 2y agoa.) They found it off-putting that OpenBSD was "proud" not to have a CoC, in the context of whether they would choose to work with them or to host the website themselves. Consider taking a moment to read the passage in question: https://isopenbsdsecu.re/about/ https://isopenbsdsecu.re/about/ This idea they were surprised a project succeeded without having a CoC is an artefact of this particular discussion, not something the author ever said or implied. It was in the same category as de Raadt swearing at people over email - they didn't anticipate a productive exchange if they reached out. That's it. If someone declares they reserve the right to treat people however they please, and then you observe them treating people in a way you don't want to be treated, and your conclusion is, "I don't think emailing this person is a good use of my time, I'm just going to host this website myself" - I find it hard to understand how anyone would find that objectionable, that seems simple, common sense, and largely neutral. b.) Whenever you have a large group of people collaborating for an extended period of time, you have incidents. There's drama. There's inappropriate behavior. It's just how it goes. It's a Murphy's Law thing. Eventually people sit down and say, "we've gotta set some ground rules." You probably signed a code of conduct at every school you attended and every job you've accepted. I know I have. You can disagree with that without viewing it as a conspiracy. It's a predictable result of being in a large community, and about as ideological as traffic lights.
- dcow 2y agoI did read the page in question… You talk like it would be any different with the linux kernel. A CoC doesn’t govern whether you’re entitled to a productive discussion with the big maintainer. Theo swearing at one person cannot be extrapolated to swearing at all people. And in linux’s case it apparently doesn’t prevent good contributions from getting stonewalled and shunned (to the point of turning contributors away) by righteous zealots in the community anyway.
- butter999 2y agoIf you read the page then I don't understand why you continue to mischaracterize what it says. Eg, the page offers multiple examples of de Raadt swearing at people, which you characterize as "swearing at one person." Frankly, it makes me doubt your candor.
- dcow 2y agoI was speaking rhetorically. I don't mean to imply there’s only one i stance of swearing. Anyway that’s not even the point. We know Theo is abrasive. It also makes good security. Weird to complain about “the community” on a page evangelizing the success of said community. If the author doesn't want to dive into the mailing list then good for them. Leave it at that.
- butter999 2y agoYou weren't speaking rhetorically, you were mischaracterizing what the author said to weaken their statement. That's the most charitable way to describe it without parting from the facts. > If the author doesn't want to dive into the mailing list then good for them. Leave it at that. They did leave it at that.
- dcow 2y agoI was not. You can believe me or not. And no, the author whined about how he doesn’t like the icky openbsd community very much arguably out of place. (There are multiple people who have mentioned they think it’s out of place, at least.) That’s not leaving it at that. Leaving it at that implies no further action.
- butter999 2y agoThe onus is always on you to figure out what information is and is not reliable. People who haven't stated their feelings still have them. They might still be pursuing an agenda other than being informative. If anything, someone stating their reservations should make you feel more comfortable, because it gives you a better lens to view their statements through and judge what parts you trust more or less. Personally, what makes me discount a source as unreliable is when they don't state clearly what their problems are but instead make it known through vague insinuations or by a litany of tangential complaints. When someone says "I'm uncomfortable with X" I respect their candor, regardless of how I feel about X.
- fc417fc802 2y agoSomeone stating their reservations when those are directly relevant to the subject at hand, sure. If they aren't directly relevant to the subject under discussion but are directly related to a negative impact on the person while they were performing the relevant work then I get that as well. But someone who isn't mature enough to separate their irrelevant personal views from the task at hand when communicating with an audience, not so much. It calls into question their ability to be objective. Note that I apply this equally, even to those who interject pet topics that I strongly support.
- butter999 2y agoGranted. However, the quote at issue doesn't come out of left field. It is natural to consider the internal politics of an open source project when writing a wide ranging, in depth critique of the project. Plenty of projects don't have a CoC, it is idiosyncratic to be "proud" not to have one, and that does reflect on the project (I leave it to you to decide if it's for better or worse).
- huang_chung 2y agoCoC are the homeowners associations of the free software world. Some think they're essential to keep undesirables out; others won't have anything to do with them. Both are often the source of petty disagreements.
- bentley 2y agoThis is “stein”: https://media.ccc.de/v/36c3-10519-a_systematic_evaluation_of_openbsd_s_mitigations https://media.ccc.de/v/36c3-10519-a_systematic_evaluation_of... Doesn’t look like jcs to me.
- tptacek 2y agoMight stein's first name be................
- bentley 2y agoIt might! But unless jcs changed his appearance and his accent since I last met up with him in Chicago, this is one of the millions of other people named Stein.
- tptacek 2y agoOK, no idea. I've been in the same room with him too, but I didn't look very carefully at the CCC presentation. An awfully big coincidence, given jcs's OpenBSD involvement! But totally possible. Neither here nor there to my point about this page as a resource, if you can, somehow, look past the code of conduct concerns.
- bentley 2y agoI don’t care one bit about the code of conduct conversation you’re having. Just found it funny that you’ve been attributing this site to jcs for years based just on a common surname.