4 ms·
> If he lied about being "proficient" in skill #2, how did we know he wasn't lying about certain achievements or even jobs from the past? I think you can tell
by barrkel 14y ago
> If he lied about being "proficient" in skill #2, how did we know he wasn't lying about certain achievements or even jobs from the past?
I think you can tell if someone is lying about specific job experience in technical areas; when you drill down, the detail won't be there.
But there's a more general issue here (though I think you're only slightly guilty, because your leap is quite small). It's about a kind of intuition about dishonesty being an aspect of a person's character, rather than a mode of behaviour in a particular scenario. A lot of people make wild jumps from single actions to an inference about behaviour in lots of different situations. I think behaviour is heavily dependent on the situation, and much of what we think of as "character" is unwarranted.
People generalize from small incidents (of honorable or dishonorable behaviour) to a character classification, and then specialize these labels back down to predictions of behaviour elsewhere. But the guy who would never cheat a shopkeeper out of mistaken change may actually be a tax fraud, not because of "character", but because of wholly different frames of reference, possibly even resentment of government.
It's the same with people who judge "attention to detail" by spelling or grammar errors. I label them narrow-minded myself :)
- trefn 14y agoMore about this very human bias: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_attribution_error http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_attribution_error
- ajross 14y agoI'm with you 100% right up to your last point, which sounds just wrong to me. The whole idea of "attention to detail" is that it's a personality trait that allows a person to see small details and defects even in areas where they aren't expert. And most of us believe it exists. So yes: if you submit a resume with clear spelling errors (i.e. ones caught by a spel chkr) most of us would take that as evidence of a lack of attention to detail. And we'd generalize to you skipping a test case before pushing code, or making sure all your stock photos are licensed before deploying the site, or...
- barrkel 14y agoI'll agree with you on spelling errors on a CV, but not when generalizing from e.g. forum posts or random emails.
- rm999 14y agoThe mentality that lying is one of the worst things you can do in the workplace is either there or it's not. If I learn a candidate is casually dishonest in just an hour, the red flags are too obvious. Sure, it's a proxy for his character, but it's a really good one.
- barrkel 14y agoYou've framed the act in a way that justifies your position. But what if your experience of HR in companies is incompetence and buzzword bingo? In this frame, getting through the HR screen is a hurdle to getting an interview, not an action "in the workplace".
- rm999 14y agoI'm amazed my position is even remotely controversial here. Many people here, including yourself, are framing the debate from the perspective of their own experiences as candidates, which is a biased way to look at the perspective of an interviewer. The fact is interviewing it tough, and is inherently a flawed process (I agree with you that ideally the interviewer could get to know the candidate's character, but an hour or a day isn't the correct timeframe to do this). Good interviewers try to find the best fit for their teams, instead of lamenting the fact that the problem can't tractably be solved perfectly.
- barrkel 14y agoNo, actually I'm not. I've never had to embellish my CV and every interview I've done has resulted in a job offer. I'm actually attacking the notion of "character" itself. Yes, there is a set of habits and probabilities of certain responses to various scenarios, but I contend that the mental model of "character" (as it is normally understood in Western culture) is a poor predictor because it groups together certain situational responses with labels that have no necessary underlying correlation to validate them. My own judgement when interviewing job candidates mostly comes down to technical depth. I'm primarily interested in competence and demonstrated ability to deal with and get results in a complex technological system. I'm not really interested at all in CV buzzwords - and that's what most of those bullet lists end up being, tags to try and get through HR filters. But my experience is also coloured by working in relatively large companies, and being a technical guy, not a manager making the hire decision.