5 ms·
> The people radicalized to these actions are trying to destroy the government. The federal government, right? They are in favor of state and local government,
by andsoitis 2y ago
> The people radicalized to these actions are trying to destroy the government.
The federal government, right? They are in favor of state and local government, but object to federal, which they assert reduces the ability for states to have different rules and regulations that can drive competition amongst different legal frameworks.
- imbusy111 2y agoI thought this was already settled during the American Civil War, yet we're back at it again.
- andsoitis 2y agoApparently not! An opposite question is interesting: why not abolish state governments and only have the federal government? I haven’t thought about it deeply so don’t have a strong sense that it would be better than the status quo, though I suspect it might.
- fallingknife 2y agoCentralization and size comes with inefficiency and slow decision making. It also comes with economies of scale. For something like the Medicare, the economy of scale dominates and it makes much more sense to be federal. When it comes to running schools, there really isn't much economy of scale so it makes much more sense to run it locally.
- gottorf 2y agoEconomies (and diseconomies) of scale exist, of course, but aren't central to what is the responsibility of the federal government and what is the responsibility of the state governments. That, of course, is laid out rather plainly in the founding legal document of the country.
- int_19h 2y agoThe more people are ruled by a single government that is ostensibly a representative democracy, the less representative said democracy actually is. This should be rather evident - you can't grow parliament size indefinitely if you want it to continue functioning as a deliberative chamber, which in turn means that every parliamentarian represents more and more people, which in practice means that they don't represent them well.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ty6853 2y agoThe Civil War settled that the feds could rule over the explicitly authorized powers of the federal government. In the 30s the feds reneged and decided blatantly unconstitutional stuff like the (later passed) Civil rights act could hold if they just call everything interstate commerce. When the US falls apart this will be a likely central focus .
- andrekandre 2y agohow was the civil rights act not constitutional?
- ty6853 2y agoCRA under the 1875 version was found unconstitutional per the Civil Rights Cases of the Supreme court [0]. In the 1930s the executive threatened to pack the supreme court and many analogous private/intrastate commerce regulations were allowed federally by this bastardization of 'interstate commerce' by the court. Then they repassed the CRA with yet again stuff found unconstitutional, using their new version of 'interstate commerce' (everything). The CRA objectively has been found unconstitutional by the Supreme court, and I believe it may be again under the latest generation of the court. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_Rights_Cases https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_Rights_Cases
- andrekandre 2y agothank you for the reply so, probably restating what you said, if someone wanted to pass something like that, a constitutional amendment is the better way since relying on interstate commerce clause is shaky ground... is that right interpretation?
- int_19h 2y agoIndeed. It should be noted that the Commerce Clause underpins most federal powers at this point. This is one of the big reasons why it's such a sacred cow - its ridiculousness is rather obvious, but all players have important things that depend on it that they don't want to risk losing.
- cbsmith 2y ago> They are in favor of state and local government, but object to federal, which they assert reduces the ability for states to have different rules and regulations that can drive competition amongst different legal frameworks. As demonstrated by efforts to prevent state and local governments from acting independently...
- andsoitis 2y ago> As demonstrated by efforts to prevent state and local governments from acting independently... Ironically tempering states is an important function of the federal government (eg civil rights, environmental protections, etc). If the federal government is used to force states to make things worse, that is something to resist very strongly.
- cbsmith 2y ago> Ironically tempering states is an important function of the federal government (eg civil rights, environmental protections, etc). Right, like shutting down congestion pricing plans. ;-)
- cardamomo 2y agoThey seem to be in favor of state and local governments only so far as those governments agree with them.
- andsoitis 2y agoYes, and they have threatened action against those they disagree with. We’ll see if they can get away with it, but something to resist very strongly.
- andsoitis 2y agoWhat is harder to fight against, however, is when they make deals with corrupt officials (looking at you democratic NYC Mayor, Mr Adams) to get what they want: https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c80yrglnn79o https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c80yrglnn79o
- kevin_thibedeau 2y agoThe world's first volunteer slave.
- pstuart 2y agoThey to have just enough government for them to extract as much wealth as possible. States rights is about them doing whatever they want without interference. The US had a civil war that its defenders describe as being about "states' rights", with the most important right of all being the ability to literally own other people as property. Make America Great Again is a about returning to those glory days.
- andsoitis 2y ago> the ability to literally own other people as property. Make America Great Again is a about returning to those glory days. Are you suggesting they want to allow states to reinstate slavery? That sounds very conspiratorial.
- pstuart 2y ago> Are you suggesting they want to allow states to reinstate slavery? Not as an immediate goal, but they would be ok with it. > That sounds very conspiratorial On my part? I wish. I wish I was delusional and could be proven wrong with certainty. The real conspiracy is happening right before our eyes. Note the highlighted text from the wiki link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curtis_Yarvin#:~:text=He%20has%20defended%20the%20institution,consider%20himself%20a%20white%20nationalist. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curtis_Yarvin#:~:text=He%20has...
- kennyloginz 2y agoNot really, just look up RFK Jr’s “wellness farms”. https://www.salon.com/2025/02/19/rfk-s-plan-to-make-america-healthy-again-round-up-people-with-mental-health-conditions-in-camps/ https://www.salon.com/2025/02/19/rfk-s-plan-to-make-america-...
- ceejayoz 2y agoSlavery was never actually banned. The 13th Amendment leaves a Death Star sized loophole. > Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.
- comfysocks 2y agoState government? You mean states in the bible belt, right? Because they aren’t in favor of liberal coastal state government.
- andsoitis 2y agoYou want to distinguish between favoring federalism VS favoring the policies/culture/etc. of specific states. So yeah; they are in favor of more state government in lieu of federal, even though they hate certain states’ policies. I think that’s obvious. Now, the question is whether or not they will succeed in handicapping states’ autonomy when they disagree with things. My take is they will try (and have tried), but it isn’t a foregone conclusion that they will succeed. There’s soft power and there’s violence, and I’m optimistic that it will be more the former.
- ceejayoz 2y ago> So yeah; they are in favor of more state government in lieu of federal, even though they hate certain states’ policies. They just nixed NYC’s congestion fee. They are gonna do plenty of meddling.
- _DeadFred_ 2y agoMore feudalism less federalism.
- UncleMeat 2y agoIf they were in favor of state and local government, why is the federal government threatening to sue California for admissions in the UC system and demanding that NYC's congestion pricing be ended or else lose federal funding? Why are faculty members at state universities being forced to change their research because it is on a verboten topic? The idea that Trump, Musk, or anybody involved in leadership of Trump's administration care about state and local government authority is, frankly, fucking ludicrous.
- denkmoon 2y agoWeak, divided governance, so that they can ignore it.
- atombender 2y agoThis seems unclear. For example, the Department of Transportation just told NY they have to shut down the new (and apparently relatively successful) congestion pricing [1] in NYC. (As with some other things being torn down by the administration, apparently the rules say the government cannot do this.) So it appears, at least, that the administration doesn't actually respect states' rights and is looking to take over everything. [1] https://www.cbsnews.com/newyork/news/nyc-congestion-pricing-trump-mta/ https://www.cbsnews.com/newyork/news/nyc-congestion-pricing-...
- ty6853 2y agoI'd be interested in understanding the property rights of the roads they were taxing. Were they taxing highways that had some covenants or contract ensuring toll free passage? I'm unfamiliar with the contract made for federally matched roads but it wouldn't surprise me if there's an agreement you can't just turn it into a toll road by calling it a new tax.
- andsoitis 2y ago“ In a letter to New York Gov. Kathy Hochul, Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said that the federal government has jurisdiction over highways leading to Manhattan and that the additional tolls posed an unfair burden for motorists outside the city.” However that seems like a dubious claim (Google results report the highways around Manhattan are operated by the state of NY, however New Jersey is adjacent). https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/trump-administration-terminates-approval-new-york-city-congestion-pric-rcna192847 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/trump-administration-te...
- ty6853 2y agoI wonder if they could get around that by making the prices balance to zero? Like charge fees to people during congestion times and pay those fees outdistributed equally amongst those who enter during non congestion. Then there would be no net revenue/toll. The optics would also be far better than green washing a net toll on people driving in from outside the city/state.
- intermerda 2y ago> Trump says he may withhold federal aid for Los Angeles if California doesn’t change water policies - https://apnews.com/article/donald-trump-republicans-taxes-eea4754a0f580d451aa0588f0639d52c https://apnews.com/article/donald-trump-republicans-taxes-ee.... Many conservatives agree including a sitting senator saying California should "change their ways". > https://www.wxxinews.org/2025-02-20/new-york-governor-rejects-louisiana-extradition-order-over-a-doctor-accused-of-providing-a-criminal-abortion-via-telemedicine https://www.wxxinews.org/2025-02-20/new-york-governor-reject... Louisiana wants to punish a New York doctor for prescribing medicine. Project 2025 in general wants to ban and criminalize medication abortion nationwide. If I kept a running list of all the ways conservatives preach states right but don't really practice it, I wouldn't have much time to do anything else. And "states rights" has been coded language anyway. Refer to Lee Atwater 1981 interview. Now the coded language has focused attention on "DEI", "trans", among other things.
- philistine 2y agoIndeed, you're a sucker if you ever did believe it really ever was about state rights.
- krapp 2y agoThe thing you always need to ask when you hear about "state rights" is "state rights to do what?" The answer is usually something Federal law or the Constitution would otherwise forbid, or that most people would consider morally reprehensible.
- gottorf 2y agoThat states' rights were claimed to keep slavery, or any other morally reprehensible thing, does not mean that the concept of states' rights is wrong. It means slavery and other morally reprehensible things are wrong. Of course, at any given time, there exist a number of issues facing the public over which there is no clear consensus on whether they constitute something morally reprehensible. You're making the argument that what the federal government decides is right is always or usually the right thing compared to what states are claiming. I challenge you to claim that this is the case for, say, federal law forbidding marijuana versus states allowing it, or as was the case until very recently, enthusiastic support for pediatric gender reassignment from the federal government versus states outlawing it.
- mikeocool 2y agoYesterday, Trump announced he was killing congestion pricing in New York City. A program set up by the state of New York, to help fund infrastructure in New York. Seems like an issue that should be left to the state, and yet here they are asserting federal authority over it.
- portaouflop 2y agoI’m not that familiar with US politics but I read that this was more a symbolic move and he actually can’t influence this law since as you pointed out it’s a matter of the New York state. He can announce things all day, which is exactly the strategy - do at least 5 ridiculous things every day and the media/people can’t react fast enough — bury them in shit
- ziml77 2y agoIf it was purely symbolic then it may be even worse because the Truth Social post he wrote to announce it ended with "LONG LIVE THE KING!"
- bavell 2y agoHe loves a good troll and the media + commentariat eats it up like candy and gives him all the free airtime he wants.
- watwut 2y agoHe means those things. And does those things. He is just a tell is how enablers made all these people sound innocent and their detractors crazy. At this point I believe it was often deliberate strategy. Plus crazy paranoid were actually 100% correct over years.
- int_19h 2y agoYou know, people used to say that about Putin, way back when he was originally elected fair and square. Funny how that worked out.