3 ms·
(from a different article). > He was denied by: MIT, Carnegie Mellon, Stanford, UC Berkeley, UCLA, UCSD, UCSB, UC Davis, Cal Poly San Luis Obispo, Cornell Univ
by hn_user82179 2y ago
(from a different article).
> He was denied by: MIT, Carnegie Mellon, Stanford, UC Berkeley, UCLA, UCSD, UCSB, UC Davis, Cal Poly San Luis Obispo, Cornell University, University of Illinois, University of Michigan, Georgia Tech, Caltech, University of Washington and University of Wisconsin.
His only acceptances: University of Texas and University of Maryland.
Wild. I looked around for another few articles hypothesizing why he got rejected. It basically sounds like the relative measurement of being 'only' top 9% at the #1 public school in the US and applying for CS (a very competitive major) made his application a lot harder. It's been 12 years since I went through the undergrad application process and I don't think my application was anywhere as strong as his was. I am generally in favor of considering the opportunities an applicant has available to them relative to what they have accomplished (hard to take 20 AP classes if your school only offers 10 of them, and yes I'm aware you can take an exam even if you didn't take the class), but this seems taken to extremes.
I don't generally have a lot of empathy for people complaining about not being accepted to colleges but having a high GPA at a competitive school, and a high SAT score, as well as having an interesting-enough 'hook' like his own moderately successful startup should've at least gotten him into one in-state school. I'm not familiar enough with the application process now and nothing states that if he was denied from the CS department while being accepted into the university itself which was a common outcome for applicants when I was a student. I think the lawsuit is a good thing hopefully, I think there can be anti-Asian American-bias for things like this but that bias tends to be ignored and this is a good sample case to bring that bias to light.
See in comparison to Abby Fischer (sp?) who sued University of Texas for being denied with a rather underwhelming application.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y ago> I don't generally have a lot of empathy for people complaining about not being accepted to colleges but having a high GPA at a competitive school, and a high SAT score, as well as having an interesting-enough 'hook' like his own moderately successful startup should've at least gotten him into one in-state school. That’s the thing. It’s one thing for someone to be rejected from only the very best universities or to have a good-but-not-great resume and face rejection. But to have perfect grades, near-perfect test scores, multiple awards in coding competitions, a startup, and still get rejected by Cal Poly or UC Davis or Michigan or Wisconsin? It makes no sense and shows something is seriously wrong here.
- hn_user82179 2y agoMy only guess with Cal Poly/UC Davis (less certain about Michigan or Wisconsin) is that the many other extremely successful CS applicants from good Bay Area schools also applied there as their 'safeties' since they're in-state, and those schools had artificially high denials as a result? wild guess. I'd suspect there's some "I'm sure you're not going to go here"-denials coming from lower-ranked schools when they get applications from strong candidates. Given that he was accepted to UT and UM and he declined to attend either (I'm making the possibly wrong assumption that his family could've afforded the out-of-state tuition, but given his father's job I don't think that's an unreasonable assumption), I doubt he would've attended those "safeties" even given the opportunity.
- gamblor956 2y agoYeah, something is missing from the article and lawsuit. If he got rejected from SLO, the rejections weren't about merit.