3 ms·
Tesco are fundamentally in the business of selling meat and potatoes to everyone in the UK, not of making highly-secure websites. This does not excuse this lap
by SideburnsOfDoom 14y ago
Tesco are fundamentally in the business of selling meat and potatoes to everyone in the UK, not of making highly-secure websites.
This does not excuse this lapse, but it may help us understand why if a computer system seems to work fine, they have little motivation to replace, upgrade or fix it, even if it is running on an old version of the platform.
- ZoFreX 14y agoThey are a huge online retailer in the UK, that should automatically mean their website is highly secure. It has my address and credit card details in it!
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y ago> They are a huge online retailer in the UK, that should automatically mean their website is highly secure. You'd think so, but apparently that's not how it's working out.
- ZoFreX 14y agoWell, no, we all know it doesn't work like that. I just wanted to point out that Tesco are doing more than just selling "meat and potatoes", their online services are a huge offering, and they provide credit cards, insurance, phone plans... Tesco online isn't just there for people to "like" their favourite potatoes!
- DanBC 14y agoTesco are third or second largest retailers in the world (measuring by revenues or profits); they led the world in online sales for years; they were early entrants into online sales (being, I think, involved in the first ever online sale); they offer some financial services. They have the money to pay for expertise to do better. It is a shame that "it hasn't failed yet" is seen by them as an excuse to keep a broken system in place.
- dspillett 14y ago> Tesco are fundamentally in the business of selling meat and potatoes to everyone in the UK That is changing - it is getting to the point where their business angle is more "renting shelf space to brands" as much as selling what we want to buy (that is a general industry thing, not a Tesco specific comment). Even ignoring that cynicism, their business is far more than food and I suspect the food sales are dwarfed when you add everything else together. Food is just the product that gets us through the door to see the other stuff: meat, veg, bread and milk are the things that the rest of the occupants of large shopping centres tend to lack. > not [in the business] of making highly-secure websites. On the contrary: they are taking in and storing personal details and in some cases banking details (they sell banking services as well as physical products), and getting access to your account may give someone the ability to buy things on your credit card. It is my understanding that both by law and by the agreements they have in place with their chose credit card processing partners they are required to live up to certain security expectations, and if they do not live up to those expectations they should be investigated, fined, and stopped from trading in those ways until they are up to scratch. The claim that their password storage is "up to industry standards" is both unduly vague (though as the conversation was by tweet the length limitation there may be partly to blame for that) and simply wrong. They are not compliant with PCIDSS (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Payment_Card_Industry_Data_Security_Standard http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Payment_Card_Industry_Data_Secu...) which I believe is considered the industry standard for handling credit card data or accounts that are associated with it.
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y agoGood answer. The problem is the mismatch between the business that they think they're in and the business that they are becoming. However I am not finding anything about "you may not store passwords in plain text or using reversible encryption" in that PCIDSS wikipedia link. If it is part of the standard (as it should be) then it deserves to be in the wikipedia article.
- dspillett 14y agoI may be confusing it with other standards that we had to ensure we were compliant with on a project a couple of years ago. Even if it isn't in PCIDSS, not storing passwords securely is certainly not industry practice for any company that operates as a bank in any of its parts.
- mikeash 14y agoI can understand why they do this, sort of, but I can't understand how they have this mindset in the first place. Imagine if they let criminals run riot through their stores, on the theory that they're in the business of selling meat and potatoes to everyone in the UK, not of policing stores. Well, it's true, but putting their customers at risk is wrong and bad for business. No, this web site nonsense hasn't been bad for business... so far. I wouldn't be surprised if a major breach would change that in a hurry, though.