4 ms·
There is no reason to think they don't have ill intent.
by watwut 2y ago
There is no reason to think they don't have ill intent.
- mandmandam 2y agoAnd many, many reasons to think that in fact they do. See my favorites for flagged stories about the DOGE staff. Even their stated reason - to fund trillions in tax cuts for the .1% [0] - is heinous. Inequality is already breaking the economy. 4.5 trillion dollars ($13k for each and every American) being transferred to the yacht class will inflict generational harm. 0 - https://www.usnews.com/news/us/articles/2025-01-10/trump-tax-cuts-if-made-permanent-stand-to-benefit-highest-income-earners-treasury-analysis-shows https://www.usnews.com/news/us/articles/2025-01-10/trump-tax...
- nprateem 2y agoThe Mump playbook relies on wild exaggeration. In this case Musk reckons he can save $2tn which some (better informed) analysts are saying is bollocks. In fact, it's cover to let him destroy/neuter agencies they don't like and get endless material to pressurise any opponents. One positive though: if there is any alien tech, Musky will find it. You can bet that's high on his list, as improbable as it may be.
- AnthonyMouse 2y ago> In this case Musk reckons he can save $2tn which some (better informed) analysts are saying is bollocks. A lot of this depends on how you measure. For example, there are a lot of social assistance programs that provide in-kind benefits (e.g. you get subsidized housing) and those programs both require a bureaucracy to administer them and are less efficient than cash transfer payments, so they could be converted into refundable tax credits. Then the program costs somewhat less (you eliminate the administrative bureaucracy) and is more efficient and with better outcomes, but you can count the entire cost of the program as a reduction because it's now a tax credit (i.e. a tax cut) instead of a government budget item. Do that with the entire social assistance system and you could get a sizable budget reduction before you even get into overpriced government contracts etc.
- dragonwriter 2y agoEven the theory that the executive can just not spend money it finds wasteful doesn't extend to the executive being able to unilaterally reconfigure an in-kind assistance program into a refundable tax credit. Admittedly, an even bigger grab of dictatorial power is not out of character for this administration, though.
- AnthonyMouse 2y agoOh, they couldn't reconfigure those programs by executive order. But they could reasonably be doing this to find ways to reduce the budget and then pass new legislation through Congress.
- NickC25 2y ago>One positive though: if there is any alien tech, Musky will find it. You can bet that's high on his list, as improbable as it may be. That tech has been handed over to the private sector as a precaution and also as a method of keeping the politicians' hands off it. Gives them cover to honestly say "I know nothing, I was briefed on nothing, we have nothing". Plausible deniability. Elon Musk is also quite possibly the last person I'd ever want to touch world-changing technology. let alone be the sole arbiter of who gets to get near it.
- Teever 2y agoMan it's pretty crazy seeing all those reasonable looking stories flagged and made dead. Also what's with the blue non-link links? Never seen that before on HN.
- mandmandam 2y ago> it's pretty crazy seeing all those reasonable looking stories flagged and made dead. It really is. There have always been 'third rail' topics that get rapidly flagged despite community interest, but I've never seen so many. > what's with the blue non-link links? Never seen that before on HN. No idea; all the links seem to work for me anyway.
- Teever 2y agoWhat's interesting to me is how what constitutes a 'third rail' topic changes over time. A quick search will show that it used to be fine to talk about Curtis Yarvin on here a decade ago but now that he's more relevant than ever it's suddenly taboo? Did Curtis Yarvin and the ideas he espouses suddenly become less interesting or are a group of people working together to prevent critical discussion of his ideas?
- AnthonyMouse 2y ago> to fund trillions in tax cuts for the .1% That isn't even what your link is saying. To begin with, it's citing a Treasury Department document requested by the Biden administration to do an analysis comparing the proposed tax cuts with a contrived alternative. If you do generic across-the-board tax cuts, not targeting any particular income group, everyone's taxes are reduced in proportion to how much they were paying to begin with. Obviously then the people who make more money and pay more taxes have them reduced by the given percentage and that is a larger absolute number. The same thing happens even if you target only the brackets for people who make less money. Suppose you lower the rates by 2% for every bracket below $400,000. That's not even enough to be in the 1% (for which you'd need to make ~$800,000), much less the 0.1%, but what happens in that case? Well, everyone's taxes go down by 2% of their income up to $400,000. If you make $40,000, they go down by $800. If you make $400,000, they go down by $8000. If you make $4,000,000, they also go down by $8000, from your first $400,000 in income. The absolute amount of the reduction is still highest for people who make more money, simply because it's a percentage of higher number. The analysis the Biden administration requested was to do the tax cuts for people making less than $400,000 and then raise the tax rates on people above $400,000 to make sure they didn't get any net reduction, and their contrived example would have people making $400,000 paying a higher tax rate than people making $500,000+. Basically the purpose of the analysis was to generate a large number to put in a headline rather than compare it to a real proposal to lower taxes in general. This is also why they announced the cumulative total over a decade rather than listing the annual number as you would when comparing it against an ordinary government budget. Because "~3.5% of the budget" sure sounds a lot less than "trillions of dollars".
- mandmandam 2y ago> that isn't even what your link is saying. You can find any number of links talking about how unequal the tax cuts are. No one in the bottom 60% is going to be better off. The .1% are benefiting the most. That's an insane thing to do in an economy that's already breaking records for inequality. > If you do generic across-the-board tax cuts That's not what these are. The reaction of every billionaire to Trump's admin ought to tell you that on it's own. > Because "~3.5% of the budget" sure sounds a lot less than "trillions of dollars". Trillions of dollars are trillions of dollars. A million seconds = ~11.5 days A billion seconds = ~31.7 years A trillion seconds - 31,710 years. We're not talking about play money, or monopoly money. Musk bought the election for a fraction of a billion dollars, ffs. And again, America is already on record inequality, about the same or more as right before the French Revolution. Money IS a zero sum game, and when too much of it is going to the 0.1% it inflicts massive harm to millions of people. If you want to learn more about this, and what's about to happen to the US economy, you can listen to one of the world's best traders talk about it here [0]. 0 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XCnImxVWbvc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XCnImxVWbvc
- ckbishop 2y agoYour default assumption should be ill intent when it comes to information security, my friend.
- CyrsBel 2y agoIn this case, DOGE should be quarantined from making further changes until CAT can operate alongside DOGE for auditing purposes. Every change and access should be reviewed.
- doublerabbit 2y agoYes. But it's not. That's the issue. They have unlocked access to systems to which they can control how they desire, unmonitored.
- CyrsBel 2y agoIf this was the case at any point, or is still the case, DOGE should definitely be quarantined until CAT audits DOGE's accesses and changes. There should be two teams operating alongside each other on this. Not just DOGE. I do believe so far they were claimed to have received read-only access...but other reports were that they even had some admin access. Do we know for sure what access they had unmonitored?
- CyrsBel 2y agoMy nature is to give the benefit of the doubt, but after seeing that they are rushing and it manifests in laying off even teams of highly skilled and critical nuclear safety staff...that means someone there doesn't know what they're doing or the chaos could be the point as well. I would hope it's not to that extent, but this is why I maintain that CAT should be auditing DOGE's changes.
- palata 2y agoI generally try to assume that people are well intentioned. But when they start doing Nazi salutes...
- CyrsBel 2y agoI was shocked by the appearance of that aspect too but then a day or two later, the ADL and Netanyahu supported him on that. https://x.com/netanyahu/status/1882392668497756279 https://x.com/netanyahu/status/1882392668497756279 https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/5097676-elon-musk-defended-salute-criticism/ https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/5097676-elon-mus... Definitely good to keep a watch, though.
- hobs 2y agoSo, the guy who held off a genocide to get trump elected and the people who are in direct cahoots say its ok, big "All my black friends I can say the N word so its ok" energy there.
- Tubbe 2y agoAnd then he went to speak at an AFD rally so I guess we are back at the Nazi interpretation
- entropicdrifter 2y agoIf you believe right-wing-specific sources about Musk's intentions, then I've got a bridge to sell you.
- alxjrvs 2y ago
- NoMoreNicksLeft 2y agoIf they did have ill intent, towards what is that ill intent targeted, and why should I care? These aren't organizations or missions I much care about. This isn't my government, except by an accident of geography. I have little say in how it's managed or what it does, but I have a high burden for it. It's unclear that this government protects me in any substantial way (or even in indirect, insubstantial ways). Meaningful reform is impossible at the sociological level, it requires too much buy-in too slowly, and that will always be hijacked by those with influence or watered down to meaninglessness.
- watwut 2y agoOtherwise said, you want to destroy government, because you never cared about learning what various agencies do. And you want reform it, but without knowing what it does and without knowing what you want to improve other then "let it go away". If on DOGE, that is ill intent.