6 ms·
Why does Tavis Ormandy (http://seclists.org/fulldisclosure/2012/Jul/375 http://seclists.org/fulldisclosure/2012/Jul/375) keep putting fully usable proof of conc
by kevingadd 14y ago
Why does Tavis Ormandy (http://seclists.org/fulldisclosure/2012/Jul/375 http://seclists.org/fulldisclosure/2012/Jul/375) keep putting fully usable proof of concept exploits out for widely deployed software without giving a vendor time to prepare a patch, or in this case, even notifying them? Off the top of my head, I remember he did this for the windows help center exploit and the java web start exploit. I can't understand why you would do this. You could at least give the vendor a couple weeks, and then if you're super worried, release the details as soon as an exploit is found in the wild.
As-is, he just seems like a raging hacker who loves attention and doesn't care if thousands of unsuspecting users get their credit card details stolen by malware authors. I must be misunderstanding something, yeah?
- kevingadd 14y agoI asked a question. If you're going to downvote me for having a wrong opinion, you should at least respond and tell me me the answer to my question, like 'this is proper behavior for a security researcher because X'.
- simias 14y agoThose games are pretty mainstream, I can't imagine how many gamers are getting rooted as we speak. I'm glad ubisoft are getting their asses kicked over this (especially with their history of aggressive DRM'ing) but for the users that's terrible. So no, I don't think that's very responsible. That being said, installing a "sudo" plugin in everybody's browser without any security validation (if I understand correctly what this is about) would be hilarious if it wasn't that tragic. But gamers are gamers, they forgave sony, they'll forgive ubisoft too, and they'll never learn.
- gizmo686 14y agoIf you could install a sudo plugin to my browser when I install your game would imply that I could have also installed a sudo plugin. If I (a non-root) user can do that, you already have a problem. (I am assuming you mean a sudo plugin that does not need a password to root)
- obtu 14y agoYou asked a very laden question. You have no doubt encountered discussions about full-disclosure to know the arguments against it; giving a one-sided rehash of that topic is a provocative way to invoke an old and tired discussion.
- Paul_S 14y agoBecause the company wasn't acting in good faith? IMHO they put that there on purpose and they deserve to be exposed as evil bastards that they are.
- simias 14y agoDo you have any evidence they put that here on purpose or are you just spreading rumors? It could as well be shoddy programming.
- Paul_S 14y agoI don't subscribe to "never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity". I'm not citing sources - hence it's just my opinion. Reminds me of google wifi slurping and hundreds of other cases where everyone plays dumb and swears it was all a misunderstanding. It never is. Until you get caught. And if not that it's a rogue trader, rogue reporter, rogue programmer, rogue scapegoat.
- wseymour 14y ago"I can't prove it through fact, but I feel it to be true."
- Bootvis 14y agoNot subscribing to malice what can explained by stupidity is just a feeling too. The question is: do you believe the perpetrator to be malicious or dumb?
- gigitrix 14y agoIt's not a "feeling" when all evidence points to the fact that, like every security vulnerability ever, a feature was added that had unintended consequences. There's no way it's malicious: Ubisoft can't do anything with this that they can't do everywhere else in the actual applications themselves!
- killyourheros 14y agoVery few comapnies will pay for this type of exploit, even fewer will offer a thanks. It's easier to get them fixed this way.
- kevingadd 14y agoThe question is whether it's easier for the security researcher or the users. I don't think it's easier for the users if they end up being exploited for weeks while the vendor rushes to fix it. If the vendor tries to delay you for months or ignores you, sure. But it doesn't even seem like he tested the exploit here to understand whether it was a serious threat.
- killyourheros 14y agoThey're not his users, and the company- who allowed these vulns. in the first place- isn't trying to pay him for his work; see Google, CCBill, Mozilla, ect.
- slackito 14y agoGiving a browser plugin the ability to run any program on the user machine without any kind of validation or prompting is so stupid/evil that they deserve the worst PR backlash they can get. Also, that's probably the quickest way to get them to release a fix.
- quadhome 14y agoThe full disclosure debate goes back a long time. I recommend doing some light Googling to understand some of the counterpoints. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Full_disclosure http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Full_disclosure As for your "raging hacker who ...," dig, consider the idea that malware authors already knew about the vulnerability and have been using it.
- nl 14y agoconsider the idea that malware authors already knew about the vulnerability and have been using it. Do you have any evidence that is the case? The original post didn't mention it. Otherwise it just sounds like excusing irresponsible disclosure.
- lawnchair_larry 14y agoThe term you are looking for is Coordinated Disclosure. http://www.theregister.co.uk/2010/07/22/microsoft_coordinated_disclosure/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2010/07/22/microsoft_coordinate... Many believe it is irresponsible to delay informing users that they have a major backdoor exposing them.
- Natsu 14y agoThis appears to be an exploit one can mitigate simply by removing that plug-in from one's browser. As such, exposing it to all is a good thing. It needs to be patched ASAP, not hidden. Ref: http://pc.gamespy.com/articles/122/1225585p1.html http://pc.gamespy.com/articles/122/1225585p1.html