4 ms·
What is it that you think this EO says? The first Trump administration went all the way to the Supreme Court to establish that he could coerce ALJs. There are a
by tptacek 2y ago
What is it that you think this EO says? The first Trump administration went all the way to the Supreme Court to establish that he could coerce ALJs. There are already extensive internal checks on FTC, SEC, and FCC --- places where to exercise independent power those agencies still need the cooperation of DOJ.
There's a clear norms violation happening here, but I don't see the power grab everybody else is seeing. These are powers the Presidency already had.
- mfkp 2y agoUncommon tptacek L. "extensive internal checks" that's laughable given what's been going on lately with the executive overreach.
- tptacek 2y agoYou misunderstand me. I'm not saying those internal checks are a good thing; I mean that the President already has extensive mechanisms to control what these agencies do.
- Jare 2y agoHe seems to be optimizing and polishing his ability to do so, which is very dangerous even if technically the reach is the same.
- rco8786 2y ago> These are powers the Presidency already had. Then what, in your mind, is the purpose of this EO?
- tptacek 2y agoTo serve notice to the FCC, FTC, SEC, and CFTC that Trump intends to override their internal legal interpretations.
- sanderjd 2y agoBut that ... is a power grab...
- tptacek 2y agoNo, the President already has that power. The norm of the previous institutions was, largely, to let the agencies do their thing. This administration is not going to do that. This was a live question in Trump's last administration, but I don't think it is anymore after cases like Lucia?
- intermerda 2y agoGreat analysis. By your logic you don’t think that the Enabling Act of 1933 was a power grab, correct?
- sanderjd 2y agoYou are dying on the hill of a pedantic point. A president also has the power to declare an emergency and deploy the military domestically. Doing so would still be a power grab. The term just doesn't have the precise narrow definition you seem to be arguing for. Its colloquial understanding encompasses the use of heretofore unused powers.
- tptacek 2y agoYes, because deploying the military domestically and overriding an FTC ALJ's legal interpretation are clearly comparable.
- grg0 2y agoThey are comparable in that they are both an increasing exercise of power wrt what had been previously done. I concur with GP; you are arriving at the conclusion through your own logic but somehow not seeing the conclusion. See intermerda's point below.
- intended 2y agoThe terrifying thin i learned recently is that norms are how laws work. This i learned from a discussion between a magistrate and legal scholar. This means that a norm violation, practically speaking, is a law violation. Which i guess is a crime. But that has to go to the courts to be judged.