4 ms·

You're probably misinterpreting some. Like there is one that says NT is the best...or maybe 2000...but that person is not disagreeing with ranking but making t

You're probably misinterpreting some. Like there is one that says NT is the best...or maybe 2000...but that person is not disagreeing with ranking but making the point that subjectivity plays a part.

hnlmorg 2y ago
I disagree about misinterpreting them. But glad you're now identifying that others have also disagreed with your opinion about which was the best.
- kennysoona 2y ago
  You disagree about a lot of things even when the evidence isn't subjective or open to interpretation in the least. Fascinating. As previously stated, it's not merely an opinion that W7 is the best, but an objective argument supported by reasoning and evidence, also both objective. But by all means, let's keep discussing this despite your proclamations to want to be done.
  - hnlmorg 2y ago
    Others have disagreed with you too.
    - kennysoona 2y ago
      Sure, just not in a way that supports your claims. More people disagreed with your initial first comment to my point than with my ranking, which is pretty much considered the industry consensus as evidenced by search results.
      - hnlmorg 2y ago
        I disagree. Others have also disagreed with you. There were also those that did agree too. We had a situation where everyone shared different opinions. One might describe the conversation as "subjective". ;-)
        kennysoona 2y ago
        > I disagree. Others have also disagreed with you. Sure, just not in a way that supports your claims. > One might describe the conversation as "subjective". ;-) Only if one ignores the evidence that shows a point to be "objective". Again, it's industry consensus that W7 is the best version of Windows. That, at least, is indisputably objective.
        hnlmorg 2y ago
        When you and only you get to choose which opinions are "objective" then the outcome is still subjective
        kennysoona 2y ago
        Again, it's industry consensus that W7 is the best version of Windows. That, at least, is indisputably objective.
        hnlmorg 2y ago
        The parts of the industry that agrees with your opinion, you mean? Rather than the parts of the industry that disagreed. Such as the metrics offered by several other people on HN. Those people who also happen to be part of the industry too. edit: I noticed that you're not replying to my other question. Can i take it from that, that you're more interested in trolling than genuine discourse?
        kennysoona 2y ago
        > The parts of the industry that agrees with your opinion, you mean? I am referring to an industry consensus, not simply a random subset of industry professionals. You are free to dismiss that as irrelevant as you dismiss other evidence if you like. > I noticed that you're not replying to my other question. Can i take it from that, that you're more interested in trolling than genuine discourse? Given your behavior if you had the ability to be notified by replies I think it would be worse for discourse on HN, as you would get in more discussions like the one you are going out of your way to prolong here. I simply don't want to be the one to enable that. I was honestly thankful you asked a question I felt I could ignore so that particular discussion could end.

You're probably misinterpreting some. Like there is one that says NT is the best...or maybe 2000...but that person is not disagreeing with ranking but making the point that subjectivity plays a part.

hnlmorg 2y ago

I disagree about misinterpreting them. But glad you're now identifying that others have also disagreed with your opinion about which was the best.

kennysoona 2y ago
You disagree about a lot of things even when the evidence isn't subjective or open to interpretation in the least. Fascinating. As previously stated, it's not merely an opinion that W7 is the best, but an objective argument supported by reasoning and evidence, also both objective. But by all means, let's keep discussing this despite your proclamations to want to be done.
- hnlmorg 2y ago
  Others have disagreed with you too.
  - kennysoona 2y ago
    Sure, just not in a way that supports your claims. More people disagreed with your initial first comment to my point than with my ranking, which is pretty much considered the industry consensus as evidenced by search results.
    - hnlmorg 2y ago
      I disagree. Others have also disagreed with you. There were also those that did agree too. We had a situation where everyone shared different opinions. One might describe the conversation as "subjective". ;-)
      - kennysoona 2y ago
        > I disagree. Others have also disagreed with you. Sure, just not in a way that supports your claims. > One might describe the conversation as "subjective". ;-) Only if one ignores the evidence that shows a point to be "objective". Again, it's industry consensus that W7 is the best version of Windows. That, at least, is indisputably objective.
        hnlmorg 2y ago
        When you and only you get to choose which opinions are "objective" then the outcome is still subjective
        kennysoona 2y ago
        Again, it's industry consensus that W7 is the best version of Windows. That, at least, is indisputably objective.
        hnlmorg 2y ago
        The parts of the industry that agrees with your opinion, you mean? Rather than the parts of the industry that disagreed. Such as the metrics offered by several other people on HN. Those people who also happen to be part of the industry too. edit: I noticed that you're not replying to my other question. Can i take it from that, that you're more interested in trolling than genuine discourse?
        kennysoona 2y ago
        > The parts of the industry that agrees with your opinion, you mean? I am referring to an industry consensus, not simply a random subset of industry professionals. You are free to dismiss that as irrelevant as you dismiss other evidence if you like. > I noticed that you're not replying to my other question. Can i take it from that, that you're more interested in trolling than genuine discourse? Given your behavior if you had the ability to be notified by replies I think it would be worse for discourse on HN, as you would get in more discussions like the one you are going out of your way to prolong here. I simply don't want to be the one to enable that. I was honestly thankful you asked a question I felt I could ignore so that particular discussion could end.