2 ms·
I think it's pretty complicated. You haven't addressed several issues: 1) Craigslist may own text in the ads, but they don't own facts. (Likewise, it's OK fo
by jessriedel 14y ago
I think it's pretty complicated. You haven't addressed several issues:
1) Craigslist may own text in the ads, but they don't own facts. (Likewise, it's OK for me to tell Alice that Bob posted a poem on his window about cats so that she can go read it, even though it would not be kosher for me to make her a copy, and even if Bob asked me not to tell her.) Padmapper don't use the full ad text, just the fact that the ad exists and discusses housing at a particular location.
2) Many (most?) would argue that, unlike physical property rights, intellectual property rights are only justified insofar as they are a net good for society. I have a Lockean right to the shirt on my back regardless of whether or not there are laws to protect me, but my ability to get 20-year patents (and not 1-year patents or 100-year patents) persists at the pleasure of the legislature. Likewise can be said for copyrights. So even if Craigslist is in the right under the current law, that doesn't mean this situation couldn't be catalyst for good change, and that discussion of crappy UI is important (i.e. not a red herring).
3) Craigslist has monopolistic powers in this market; in the presence of competition, their crappy UI might be forced out of business. One can justify open data requirements as an alternative way of reducing monopolistic powers to standard trust busting methods.
Not saying you're wrong, but I can't see why you'd want to put up a top-level comment with broad claims that doesn't address these and other issues raised in previous HN discussions.