3 ms·
> He thinks this is a feature, not a bug. Is he wrong? I don't think so. Twitter lost 84% of its revenue. Do you want the USA GDP to shrink that much over the
by ben_w 2y ago
> He thinks this is a feature, not a bug. Is he wrong? I don't think so.
Twitter lost 84% of its revenue.
Do you want the USA GDP to shrink that much over the next few years?
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoThe US's GDP isn't based on the amount of bloat in its government. Sure spending finds its way into the economy, but tax dollars saved also will. As for Twitter/X - the goal isn't revenue but profit, and Twitter was not in a good shape before Elon. Musk recently noted they are barely breaking even now, and the recent sale of X debt was just above original pricing. Considering big advertisers are coming back to X, that's probably only going to look better.
- _fizz_buzz_ 2y agoThe twitter deal kind of worked out for Musk because Trump won the presidency. It's a way to buy favors from the US government now. Basically a corruption vehicle. From a end user stand point, twitter is terrible now. Lots of bots, full of life hack and crypto scams and a lot of scientists and other interesting people completely abandoned the platform.
- cr125rider 2y agoControl the media, control the narrative. A tale as old as time.
- ben_w 2y ago> The US's GDP isn't based on the amount of bloat in its government. Sure spending finds its way into the economy, but tax dollars saved also will. "Bloat" presumes. "Tax dollars saved" would only be relevant — still incorrect, but relevant — if you were matching tax cuts with spending cuts, rather than trying to balance budgets. If the USA balances its budget in a way that *somehow* has no side-effects, the GDP shrinks 7% just from that cut alone — but these cuts do have side effects so it is worse than that. And doing using layoffs as a discovery mechanism is going to have Chesterton-fence type mistakes, where you only find what's wrong when the stuff you stop paying for is maintenance whose absence takes a while to become visible to non-domain experts. Dams will fail and flood valleys, bridges will fall into rivers, that kind of thing has gotten into the news in other countries when maintenance was forgotten. The infrastructure that your government is responsible for is the backbone upon which the wealth of the rest of your country is built. You can eliminate the entire Federal Highway Administration and Joe Average won't notice anything for nearly a year… but if and when you do hire them back, you may have to hire back a lot more than you fired just to catch up with the damage done. And so it goes for many other aspects of your country. CDC's also in the news now. OK, until you get your next pandemic… oh, wait, you're already having one. Nukes? You won't notice the problem until other governments no longer fear your nuclear deterrent. Armed forces in general? British didn't see any problem with shrinking their forces until the Russian invasion of Ukraine and realising how close they were to not being able to defend themselves if invaded. Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration? Getting rid of that means a lot of companies can get away with skipping safety processes, so it might even seem like the economy goes up… until you get some equivalent of the Union Carbide plant in Bhopal. > As for Twitter/X - the goal isn't revenue but profit, and Twitter was not in a good shape before Elon. They made a profit in two of the years before he took over; an 84% revenue decline means that the company cannot even service the debt he saddled the company with during the purchase, even if he fired all remaining staff and reduced server, utility, real estate, and insurance, and all other costs to zero. > Musk recently noted they are barely breaking even now, and the recent sale of X debt was just above original pricing. Do you trust him? According to this link, they sold more of their debt than they were expecting to, for more than expected to, but it was still less than they paid for it. Going from $1b to $5.5b and from 90¢/$ to 97¢/$ is less bad rather than good. https://www.business-standard.com/world-news/morgan-stanley-set-to-sell-3-billion-of-x-debt-without-any-discount-125021300179_1.html https://www.business-standard.com/world-news/morgan-stanley-...
- jimnotgym 2y ago>Sure spending finds its way into the economy, but tax dollars saved also will. Tax savings too a $40k a year person immediately find their way into the economy. Tax savings to multi-millionaires and billionaires tend to result in ever higher asset prices. They have too much spend effectively, so they hoard it.
- kelnos 2y agoSo essentially the process here is: 1. Buy Twitter. 2. Fire most of the staff. 3. Piss everyone off so all the advertisers shun you. 4. Barely get the company breaking even, mainly due to all the cuts, even though the platform itself is barely limping along. 5. Cozy up to a wannabe dictator that dupes (slightly less than) half the country to elect him as president again. 6. Make the advertisers realize that their continued prosperity depends on bending the knee to you, due to your political connections. Not to mention your platform is now a way for people to buy favors from the government. 7. Profit. (No need for a "???" step before "Profit", well done...) We truly live in the darkest timeline.
- NewJazz 2y agoThe good news is that GDP is positively correlated with greenhouse gas emissions from fossil fuels. Lower GDP, lower temp. I mean the famines will certainly "help"... I don't think the Senate will let it get that far, though. Only takes a few Rs in the House to impeach. 67 senators is a hard climb but 0% YoY GDP decline could do it... Or it could give Trump the stimulus he so badly craves.
- bagels 2y agoThey won't go hungry. I don't think famine will stop them. They don't want to lose their dictator that is willing to advance their agenda.
- NewJazz 2y agoBut they need to have a strong economy AND strong, consistent revenue to fund their defense budget. Don't forget that...
- ben_w 2y agoThey need it to seem like that. Russia mistook the illusion for a reality, and is now stuck in a war of attrition with an economy that, on paper, is only a tenth of their own, and which is being supported by the international equivalent of loose change. When Putin realised that, his body language changed: https://www.rferl.org/a/russia-ukraine-war-putin-neumann-interview/31966753.html https://www.rferl.org/a/russia-ukraine-war-putin-neumann-int... (Oh how hyperbolic headlines are…)
- TeMPOraL 2y ago> Twitter lost 84% of its revenue. How much of that is because of politics? Already at the point of takeover, Musk was so hated by half the US for various reasons that it became profitable for major publishing platforms to abandon Twitter/X "on principle". When you're in that situation, nothing on the object-level can help you - neither good management nor technical competence. Revenue depends indirectly on the public opinion, and half of it wants nothing to do with you. US nuclear arsenal is not in this situation.
- jimnotgym 2y agoIs it politics that people don't want to do business with shitty people? I'd call that being human. If I owned a bill board space, and set everything around it on fire, wouldn't you think it was my fault that advertisers didn't want to pay to use it any more?
- TeMPOraL 2y agoNo, but then burning everything around the billboard doesn't necessarily make you a shitty person, and also opinions of people siding with advertisers aren't somehow the definitive ones. I mean, why do people who hate what Twitter is now care about it's lost revenue? Especially given what it was, and where the revenue came from, this isn't exactly an argument that generalizes well.
- roenxi 2y agoThe real question is why people think Twitter's lost revenue is linked to Musk's management. There doesn't seem to be a theory about a causal link. If anything the argument is "Musk is a bad person -> Twitter lost revenue" which suggests his management practices had no effect on the company's operation.
- ben_w 2y agoFWIW, I absolutely blame his management of Twitter rather than his political alignment or questions of morality. Reason being, look at Tesla stock price: Musk's gaffes have a short term impact, but overall the price is way up since buying Twitter.