2 ms·
Okay, but then they're selling a product, not volunteering. And the law is that people who sell software can be liable for that software. Which makes sense. Thi
by immibis 2y ago
Okay, but then they're selling a product, not volunteering. And the law is that people who sell software can be liable for that software. Which makes sense. This is how every other product on the market works.
Note that "can be liable" does not mean "will pay so much money they go bankrupt". It just means that normal liability rules will apply and that person is not shielded from liability. If I sold you a broken car saying it was in perfect order, I may be liable, but if I can prove a mechanic told me it was in perfect order and I didn't break it after that, I may be able to transfer my liability to them. Now, if because the car was faulty, you crashed into a children's picnic, your car exploded into flames and and killed an entire orphanage, I or the mechanic may still go bankrupt paying their medical bills...
- x0x0 2y ago"selling" a product for $0 is an insane twisting of english and common sense. And something now that only idiots do. And the reason no physical world analogies apply in the slightest is even if you give away (not sell) a car or some other physical possession, you don't sell a million copies and incur liability across a million users. For that same $0 cost. While that free download incurs effectively unbounded liability.
- immibis 2y agoWait, so this paid support is $0 support? Then how is it paid?
- x0x0 2y agotaking $1 in support creates the obligation to anyone and everyone. Not the people who paid.
- immibis 2y agoIf I give away free cookies I baked just to feed people and they develop minor food poisoning, I may be shielded by the fact I was volunteering in good faith. If I give away free cookies with the logo of some big event to advertise that event, now it's commercial and I may be liable for the cookies because I'm backed by the money of that big event and should have been held to a higher standard.
- x0x0 2y agoThe idea that selling one thing, ever, creates a financial obligation to anyone, ever, who downloads something for free is abject nonsense. And again, would lead anyone rational to wholesale blocking the UK or EU.