3 ms·
>2012 - moores law basically ends - nand gates do t get smaller just more cleverly wrapped. Single threaded execution more or less stops at 2 GHz and has remain
by zahlman 2y ago
>2012 - moores law basically ends - nand gates do t get smaller just more cleverly wrapped. Single threaded execution more or less stops at 2 GHz and has remained there.
In 2012, 22nm architectures were new (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Intel_CPU_microarchitectures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Intel_CPU_microarchite...). Now we have 3nm architectures (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3_nm_process https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3_nm_process). In what sense have nand gates "not gotten smaller"?
My computer was initially built in 2014 and the CPU runs up to 3 GHz (and I don't think it was particularly new on the market). CPUs made today overclock to 5+ GHz. In what sense did "single threaded execution more or less stop at 2 GHz and remain there"?
We might not be seeing exponential increases in e.g. transistor count with the same doubling period as before, but there has demonstrably been considerable improvement to traditional CPUs in the last 12+ years.
- mwpmaybe 2y ago> In what sense have nand gates "not gotten smaller"? Because 22nm was not actually 22nm, and 3nm is not actually 3nm.
- lifeisstillgood 2y agoSo the size of nand gates is still roughly 28nm, but if you measure a car from above its size is fixed, if you stand the car on its nose you can measure it from above and it’s “smaller”, this is FinFet, then fold down the roof and the wheels and that’s roughly GAA. The car size stays the same - the parking density increases. It’s more marketing than reality but density is up … As for clock speeds, yes and no, basically thermal limits stop most CPUs running full time at full speed - the problem was obvious back in the day - I would build PCs and carefully apply thermal paste to the plastic casing of a chip - thus waiting for the heat of the transistors to heat up the plastic to remove the waste. Yes they are working on thermal something something directly on the layers of silicon.
- lifeisstillgood 2y agoI am still feeling my way through these ideas, but think perhaps of an alternative universe where instead of getting cleverer with instruction pipelining (guessing what the next CPU will ask for and using the silicon to work that out), hardware had just added more parallel cores - so it did not need to guess the next instructions, it just went faster because the instructions were in parallel because we magically solved software and developers. You could have a laptop with 1000 cores on it - simple 32/64 bit CPUs that just ran full pelt. The lack of parallelism drove decisions to take silicon and make it do stuff that was not run everything faster. But to focus on getting one instruction set through one core faster. AI has arrived and found a world of silicon that it by coincidence can use every transistor for going full pelt - and the CPUs we think of in our laptops are using only a fraction of their transistors for full pedal to the metal processing and the rest is … legacy??