2 ms·
Umm, ok, a UI is a fiction made up for the user by the programmer... And how exactly is a steering wheel not a fiction made up for the user by the engineer? J
by swombat 18y ago
Umm, ok, a UI is a fiction made up for the user by the programmer...
And how exactly is a steering wheel not a fiction made up for the user by the engineer?
Just because the steering wheel is physically connected to the car's wheels doesn't make it any more "real". It's still an abstraction on a complicated piece of machinery (in that case, a differential and power steering system for turning the wheels of the car). A browser is no different - it's an abstraction on a complicated piece of software.
- stcredzero 18y agoIn the case of something like rack and pinion steering, there is a direct physical connection between this steering wheel the driver is holding and the wheels. If done well, this kind of high fidelity connection can allow the driver to directly experience the physics of slinging their car around a turn. In this case the "user" has a very direct connection to those physics. (There's an actual physical linkage!) In many cases, an engineer can add something to this like power steering, but still maintain this high fidelity. In lots of software, the connection is very indirect. It's as if one were sitting on a hydraulic platform, watching rendered 3D models on screens, driving an actual car by remote control. If this were implemented well, it might feel great, but if it were implemented badly, it would absolutely suck -- just like a lot of UIs do. Heck, even something much simpler like badly implemented power steering can still suck. In essence, there are often too many layers of abstraction in lots of software. At each level, you can lose some fidelity, and the end result is discomfort for the user. There is no "physics" involved, but there are often underlying models which are not represented with high fidelity. (Relations are a prime example.) (I was watching an account by an Israeli Mirage pilot who also flew the F-16s. He felt there was some "immediacy" missing from the "fly by wire" F-16.)
- swombat 18y agoI think your point falls down because it appears to only apply to physical devices. In which case, the only shortcoming of software (all software) is that it's not physical... Can you come up with an example of an interface to a non-physical device (whether software or something else) that doesn't have such a "shortcoming"?
- stcredzero 18y agoSorry, you are just missing my point. Of course, software always involves abstractions. Another way to put it is: * Not all abstractions are created equal * Not all implementations of abstractions are equal * Not all presentations of abstractions are equal * All else equal, fewer abstractions are better (Your rebuttals seem to rest on the opposite being true.) Returning to my original post -- UIs are a fiction created for the user. The salient point here is that the range of possible fidelity is huge. You can write a piece of historical fiction that's very close to actual events, or you can totally butcher the facts. The range of freedom afforded programmers allows them to think they can get away with way more than they actually can.
- swombat 18y agoI get that, but your point was that "UI is only a fiction made up for the user by the programmers". Do you mean that this is true of any interface that doesn't physically link the user to a physical device? If so, the implications of this point to software seem a little thin, since software, being abstract, will always be non-physical...
- stcredzero 18y agoArrgh, the physical systems are only an analogy! With physical systems, you can have fidelity to something underlying, like physics. Layers of abstraction can degrade this fidelity. With completely software systems, there can still be something underlying with which you can represent with different levels of fidelity. There too, levels of abstraction can degrade this fidelity. Generalize, please. Don't mistake your not getting a general principle for it not being there. (If you are trying to prove the null hypothesis, you use different approaches. Trying the same one N times is missing the point.) "UI is only a fiction made up for the user by the programmers". Do you mean that this is true of any interface that doesn't physically link the user to a physical device? What I mean is that the worst sins possible in software aren't even limited by the laws of physics. Often in software, there is apparently nothing elegant underlying the UI like physical laws or mathematics. Sometimes there isn't even "common sense." Sometimes even basic psycholgical principles like Object Permanence are missing or inconsistent.