3 ms·
It's an extraordinarily high sum for this kind of finding. Bounties are generally not a referendum on how clever the underlying work is. A full-chain iOS bug is
by tptacek 2y ago
It's an extraordinarily high sum for this kind of finding. Bounties are generally not a referendum on how clever the underlying work is. A full-chain iOS bug is worth hundreds of thousands of dollars because Apple competes with the grey market for it (and even then, it's an apples-oranges comparison and Apple pays substantially less than the rest of the market for structural reasons). Nobody competes for this bug; nobody is going to pay these people $10,001 for a bug that Google can end instantaneously the moment they figure out what's happening.
- ianhawes 2y agoYou’re significantly underestimating the value of dox-style exploits. Author could have partnered with a black hat vendor who would offer (for example) $25 per lookup. Or they could’ve done bulk scraping of YouTube channels to get emails and sold the dataset. It requires some legwork but they could’ve seen somewhere in the ballpark of 6 figures over 1 year if the exploit wasn’t patched. Oh, and if they had no ethics.
- tptacek 2y agoDoes that black-hat vendor already exist? Do they already sell the service of taking $25 to unmask Google users? What calculation does that vendor do about how many customers they'll get before Google notices? Does the exploit developer get a 50% cut? The black-hat vendor is taking all the risk; seems unlikely. Arranging this whole thing is work; finding the "black hat vendor" is work; not getting caught in the process is work; not getting screwed by your partner is work. You pencil out the numbers and this gets less and less plausible as a way to beat a $10,000 lump sum payment. I think the reality though is just that there's literally no buyer for this. You could sell the service yourself! I bet you could make a couple thousand bucks before you and your customers got indicted.
- blagie 2y ago> not getting caught in the process is work Caught for what? If someone sells information about a vulnerability, what law are they breaking? In most jurisdictions, unless you're dumb enough to ask questions about whom your selling to and have active knowledge you're assisting someone in breaking some law, selling to the black market is perfectly legal, at least so long as you pay your taxes. If you're doing grey market, it's even more legal. If a dictatorship wants to unmask a critic for assassination, and one is selling this information to a government security agency, it's legal by definition.
- tptacek 2y agoIf you sell information about a vulnerability to someone that you know specifically is going to use it to break the law, you are an accessory to that lawbreaking. Ask Stephen Watt how this plays out.
- blagie 2y agoPlease read my posts more carefully. Virtually every response is non-responsive to what I wrote: I wrote: "unless you're dumb enough to ask questions about whom your selling to and have active knowledge you're assisting someone in breaking some law, selling to the black market is perfectly legal" You wrote: "If you sell information about a vulnerability to someone that you know specifically is going to use it to break the law, you are an accessory to that lawbreaking" That's the exact same thing. You, likewise, didn't notice I was advocating for new statutes in a post above.
- scarface_74 2y agoSomeone gives you two kilos of cocaine, doesn’t tell you what’s in the box and tells you not to open it while you transport it across the border and when you get your the other side someone will pay you $20000. You get caught by the DEA. Do you think it’s a valid defense “I didn’t ask what was in the box”? Say the drug dealer you delivered it to got caught and then told authorities you delivered it to them, do you think you would have a valid defense?
- aqueueaqueue 2y agoIs that the right analogy? This sounds more like a free speech and free speech exceptions type of issue. (Commenters keep moving the goalposts making for a complex thread where each node in the tree litigates a very different hypothetical situation. Ah HN!) Similar to publishing say... the Anarchists Cookbook.
- scarface_74 2y ago
- iinnPP 2y agoJust because companies are paying X doesn't mean that X isn't a low sum. Calling 10k an "extraordinarily high sum" is accurate to some and inaccurate to others. I would bet the groups would differ by perceived personal cost more than the opinion of Google, Apple, and the like. These groups would also probably show distinction where people have been victimized by "identity theft." The opinions of those bearing the cost are more important here, in my opinion.
- blagie 2y agoMy commentary was precisely about the state-of-the-practice. That $10k is "an extraordinarily high sum for" what was likely weeks of work on this bug, and probably months of work poking in other places, reflects the very, very low focus on security industry-wide. This is why we need significant civil -- or possibly occasionally criminal -- liability. Civil if it's simple negligence, and criminal if it's gross negligence leading to harm. If Google were to pay me $200 if it leaked my data, that would: - Be worth much less than my privacy - Amount to damages of $400B worldwide if there were a compromise impacting all $2B users (although, realistically, damages would be lower in middle and low income countries) This would represent a 20% fall in Google's market cap, which feels about right. At that point, I expect the bug bounties would be set many orders of magnitude higher. Security bugs should be rare. They're common. This is a problem, and one created by our market incentive structures. You are correct that Apple is an exception, and seems to mind security.
- tptacek 2y agoGoogle pays a piece rate. They pay the rate the market will bear, unless you impress them, like these people did, and then they pay a bit more. They do not compensate you for your working hours. Google is not going to pay you $200 if they leak your email address. Google pays as much attention to security as Apple does. If you want a world in which these kinds of security bugs create multimillion-dollar liabilities, you can advocate for the new statutes that will create that world; just be aware that only companies like Google will be able to afford to operate in that world.
- blagie 2y agoI am very much advocating for new statutes. That's precisely what my post was doing. Companies should not be allowed to externalize costs of bad security on users. I disagree with the claim that "only companies like Google will be able to afford to operate in that world." That's not how markets work. 1) The impact would be that frameworks would develop with better security. This would result in a slowdown of software engineering. Perhaps it would start to look like any other engineering discipline, where things are analyzed for safety. 2) Every other industry shows that in situations like this, big players are disadvantaged. The analysis here is pretty basic: - If I'm running a small $10M startup making a little iPhone app for some obscure task, the risk of legal liability from this is among the smallest of my risks of going under, so I'm incentivized to ignore it. If I were faced with a $400B liability, I declare bankruptcy, so in effect, that's a $10M liability. The expected cost is 5% times 10M = $500k, so it makes sense to spend up to $500k to mitigate a 5% risk. - If Google has a team working on that same app, and doesn't manage security properly, the $400B liability stays a $400B liability. There is no ROI analysis where it makes sense to build a little app which has a 5% chance of leaking data. Do it right, or don't do it at all. The expected cost to Google here is 5% times $400B = $20B. This is why, in virtually every other industry, big players are (1) more trusted (2) more expensive, and phrases like "small, fly-by-night operation" exist (and make business sense to run).
- jorvi 2y agoInterestingly enough there is already a brute-force way exploiters have been doxxing YouTubers: bots comment random name combinations to a channel, check if it is posted, then immediately delete the comment. If the comment didn't appear, either of those names is on the blocklist and is probably the YouTuber's name or related to it. Same goes for addresses.