7 ms·
Having the debate framed as 'Sal Khan is the future of education' and 'No, he isn't, teachers are' is bogus. It's a ridiculous dichotomy. It does a disservice t
by jgrahamc 14y ago
Having the debate framed as 'Sal Khan is the future of education' and 'No, he isn't, teachers are' is bogus. It's a ridiculous dichotomy. It does a disservice to both Khan and teachers to debate this in that way.
There will be many teachers who will use Khan's videos in their teaching (or to augment it), and I imagine that over time Khan will change the way he does things based on his own education about education.
It's self evident that the 'sitting in front of a machine watching videos' isn't the solution to the education. If it were the multimedia revolution wouldn't have petered out as it did. Children (and adults) need a variety of approaches. Khan's is just one.
- boca 14y agoNot sure if there's a reason you mention it that way but his last name is Khan, not Kahn.
- jgrahamc 14y agoMy mistake.
- irahul 14y ago> There will be many teachers who will use Kahn's videos in their teaching (or to augment it), and I imagine that over time Kahn will change the way he does things based on his own education about education. Sal Khan(it' khan, not kahn) himself mentioned he is not looking to replace classrooms. He wants to invert the classroom. Traditional classroom has passive lectures followed up with problem solving which is to be done at home. He says it's better if people can do the passive things at home at their own pace, and use the classroom for problem solving. The problem with passive lectures in classroom is many a times students are sitting through lectures they don't follow because they don't know the prerequisites; and often times students by themselves aren't able to figure out if they can't make heads and tails of probability problems, what is it that they need to know so that they can understand it. In his talk, Khan demonstrated the software(I haven't used; I might be off) which can track your deficiencies. For example, you are struggling at basic probability. The framework will drop you down to permutation/combination problems. You still are struggling; introduce fundamental principle of counting. You are doing fine now. So explain permutations based on counting principle. Lacking the prerequisites is one of the problems. We have people who learn at different rate, people who aren't fluent in the language the lecture is delivered in, people who are shy/under-confident to speak up, people who are smart and are bored and feel left out, people who aren't very smart(lack the fundamentals, slow learners...) and are lost and feel left out. If Khan Academy, or any other self-paced learning resource can solve these problems; coupled with classroom guided problem solving and projects, that will make a huge difference.
- cstefanovici 14y agoThe point though is that Khan is free, is a non-for profit and is more than just sitting and watching videos. They are followed by exercises which track the progress of the user and can even be reviewed by teachers if a teacher chooses to do the teacher account - student accounts setup. All of that is very valuable and very disruptive to something like Mathalicious, a for-profit site not many have heard of.
- randomdata 14y agoAs a child of the multimedia revolution, it was strongly ingrained in us that going to college was the only route to getting a job that wasn't flipping burgers. To even consider learning in non-traditional ways would make you the laughing stock of not only your peers, but the older generations too. I'm not sure learning through multi-media ever stood a chance. I do feel that those times have changed dramatically. Now all we hear about is the college dropouts who went on make billion dollar companies. It has almost become cool to not go to school. I think the time is finally right for these non-traditional educational services and it just helps that the internet is now widely available to act as the conduit for it.
- adestefan 14y agoThere has to be something regional/cultural about this that I'm missing since I hear this complaint a lot, but don't know anyone personally that experienced it until very recently. When I went to high school in Pennsylvania the 90s people were still encouraged to into the trades. I have some friends from high school that have gone on to be very successful electricians and welders. Even when my brother went to the same school and graduated in 2007 he was never pushed to go to college. He ended up getting his AA at a local university and is now a paramedic/fire fighter for the same city.
- Reebz 14y agoIs that not the same principal? Person X chooses career Y and must obtain a certification through path Z.
- adestefan 14y agoThe complaint is that teenagers are being told the only way you'll be a member of the middle class is that you must go to a four year university. People were saying that going into a trade or getting "just" an Associates degree would leave you in the dust of everyone else.
- adgar 14y agoHN isn't remotely representative of the population at large. You're primarily getting bay area and a bit of Pacific Northwest culture here. A touch of NYC businessfolk sentiment that HN entrepreneurs envy but can't actually pull off. If you think the folks commenting here have any idea what life outside the bubble is like, think again.