7 ms·
What the Black Hawk pilots could see, just before the crash
- bookofjoe 2y agoOriginal link is unpaywalled
- lobsterthief 2y agoIt requires you to sign into an account though.
- bookofjoe 2y agoThat's not true: you can read it — with 3D visualizations, which are blacked out in the archive version — without signing in to an account: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2025/02/05/us/dc-crash-helicopter-black-hawk-pilots.html?unlocked_article_code=1.wE4.E3Qm.Fu3gorL0b1_5&smid=url-share https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2025/02/05/us/dc-crash-h... Note "unlocked" in URL above. Try it!
- LaffertyDev 2y agoI did try. Still “sign in to read.” Your second link gives me an option to close the full screen modal (or the NYT gives second-try people a pass.)
- karaterobot 2y agoWorked for me. I got a little popup that I dismissed, then I saw the full article.
- jaygray0919 2y agoHow did you construct that link? For example, where do these bits come from: 1.wE4.E3Qm.Fu3gorL0b1_5
- bookofjoe 2y agoI didn't construct that link: It was the link that appeared when, as a New York Times subscriber, I clicked "Share this story."
- neonate 2y agohttps://archive.ph/6jchg https://archive.ph/6jchg
- spdgg 2y ago[flagged]
- ein0p 2y agoDoesn't matter what they could and could not see - the ceiling for helicopters there is 200 feet. They were flying at 300. Make whatever conclusions you like from that, I've made mine.
- fwipsy 2y agoExcerpts from the article: "(According to investigators, this altitude data was rounded to the nearest 100.)" [...] "At over 100 miles an hour, the helicopter could have risen to 300 feet from 200 in seconds, because of winds or other factors. Such anomalies are not unusual and can be quickly corrected." I read your comment as implying that you've concluded it's pilot error. I don't disagree, but a good system should be robust against human error. Perhaps the permitted flight paths were too close together? I'm not an expert, but a commercial jet making a landing approach 100 feet above a helicopter doesn't seem safe or normal to me.
- ein0p 2y ago[flagged]
- heelix 2y agoNTSB did release some follow up data. They have the bottom of the jet at 325', +/- 25'. Helicopters add a tough element to any airport operation and DIA is one of the more challenging airports with the extra restrictions on routing. (Never flown into that one as not an ATP. I'd never be able to get closer than College Park. Even that was a non-trivial exercise in paperwork.)
- stefan_ 2y agoWhat's complicated about it? Don't get within a mile. Some 250g drone can't, why should this thing?
- bilbo0s 2y agowhy should this thing? 'Cuz "National Security". End of discussion. /s You may laugh, but that's historically the argument in support of these practices. No one wants to go on record as questioning the practice. Maybe they will finally do something now? But it wouldn't surprise me if they don't.
- 1024core 2y ago> Black Hawk helicopters often fly these routes as a pair, doubling the number of eyes scanning the sky for a safe passage. But that night, there was only one. Its two pilots worked together to navigate ... So how many WERE there?!? Two, as in the first and third sentences, or just one, as in the second sentence? Who writes this drivel and does not even proofread it??
- stevenwoo 2y agoI had to read it twice, it could have used the addition of the word helicopter after the phrase "only one" to make it absolutely clear what was meant.
- bondarchuk 2y ago1 copter with 2 pilots
- scblock 2y agoOne helicopter with two pilots, as compared to two helicopters. Perhaps try checking yourself before yelling at others.
- kbf 2y agoThe sentence you highlighted holds the answer.
- cle 2y agoI had no trouble understanding, but perhaps it could be made slightly less ambiguous, like: > But that night, there was only one helicopter, and its pilot and co-pilot worked together to navigate...
- kube-system 2y agoTwo helicopters with two pilots = 8 eyes. One helicopter with two pilots = 4 eyes.
- cullenking 2y agoI think everyone here could be confused, here's my understanding. There were three people in the helicopter that night, two pilots and one crew member. They usually fly with two crew members for a total of 4 people in the helicopter. The two crew members usually sit one on each side of the helicopter, with the task of looking out the windows to enhance situational awareness. The minimum crew is 3, two pilots and one crew member. While not ideal, this is a regular occurrence for operational reasons, so it's part of regular training.
- Prbeek 2y ago[flagged]
- BurningFrog 2y agoBe warned: The article does not show what the pilots could see.
- buttercraft 2y agoYes it does? It shows how the other aircraft in the sky would have appeared from their position
- dave333 2y agoIt needs a lot of enhancements to be useful. Firstly it should be a real time video like the simulations in the movie about Capt Sully's water landing in the Hudson. The aircraft lights need to be modeled accurately as well as views both with and without night vision equipment.
- thecuntdaniel 2y ago[flagged]