3 ms·
It sounds like it's a naming issue. It's not "shuffle mode" - there's a shuffle action.
by dllthomas 14y ago
It sounds like it's a naming issue. It's not "shuffle mode" - there's a shuffle action.
- cwe 14y agoThis is the best, simplest way to describe what's going on. Well said. Personally, I think this is the ideal behavior. I want a random playlist, but want to play through the whole thing as time goes on. Pure shuffle would give me a new playlist every time I went to a podcast or some other random song, whereas shuffling a playlist means I can go back to where I was in that random list, and not worry about hearing the same stuff again.
- kennon 14y agoIf that's the case, then there's also a bit of a UI issue. The current shuffle button is a toggle, not a "click once each time you want to shuffle" button.
- dllthomas 14y agoYes, for sure. My speculation (from vague recollections of ancient Slashdot posts I didn't read closely at the time - never having used iAnything for music myself - so take it with a grain of salt) is that shuffle started out randomly picking the next song, but people complained that IT WASN'T RANDOM because they kept hearing the same songs - but of course if it is random, there's no protection against precisely that, and the people for whom it has happened to be well distributed probably arent' going online searching for "itunes shuffle randomness problem" or whatnot. So there may or may not have been a bug in the randomness, but randomness isn't really what people wanted anyway, and upon realizing that they changed it to the way it works now - where you shuffle it like a deck of cards, and then run through that deck repeatedly. Now, shuffle is an action where before it was a mode - and they forgot to change the UI to match.
- farnsworth 14y agoYes, but you still need to be able to "unshuffle", so they kept it as a toggle. not the most natural ui, but it works.
- dllthomas 14y ago"unshuffle" is a sort action
- farnsworth 14y agoFor a playlist, it's "sort by the original arbitrary order that the user put it in" so you can't rely on the usual sort methods - e.g. clicking the column header.
- dllthomas 14y agoRight, but it's still an action - "put it in some specific order"