3 ms·
I think you took something different from the article than I did. They provide a critique, strongly worded at times, but not totally bashing Khan Academy or the
by Jtsummers 14y ago
I think you took something different from the article than I did. They provide a critique, strongly worded at times, but not totally bashing Khan Academy or the general approach. They specify their concerns, and even offer suggestions on ways it can be improved (specifically, examining existing pedagogy and coordinating with some of the top math and science teachers to generate better content).
One of the authors is a current teacher, working with real students. He gets feedback from them either directly (by questions, comments, curses) or indirectly (homework, tests, quizzes) to gauge his effectiveness as an educator. Khan (until they added problems to the site) didn't have this feedback.
Their criticism boils down to a few main points.
1. He uses an inconsistent presentation of algebra and arithmetic work and notation, which could lead to students becoming confused when he suddenly changes it.
2. He uses a poor selection of examples, without offering more or better examples students may develop a mathematical toolset based on a flawed understanding, which will lead to problems further down the line.
3. The problems available to students are insufficient to provide proper mathematical practice and ensure that some of the common misunderstandings are shown to be wrong.
- crusso 14y agoSo an article on the Washington Post site based upon a for-profit founder's nit-picking of Khan's materials is representative of the right way to go about improving what Khan himself says is an effort to supplement other educational methods? There's a difference between constructive criticism that's effectively administered vs a publicly-rendered smear attempt that tries to hide behind pedantry.
- Jtsummers 14y agoMy comment was in reply to delinka's TL;DR. And you seem to be using a similar one. I don't know that it's "representative of the right way" to put criticisms like this in such a public forum, but it's not exactly new either. The first article is (is that the for-profit founder you're referring to?) definitely not constructive criticism. This article is in response to Khan's rebuttal, and at least offers a claim of more substantial research into Khan Academy's offerings before they provide their criticism.