2 ms·
I'd argue this is an argument against purely peer review, as her peers also weren't mathematicians. Some of us when learning calculus wonder if we'd been alive
by fragmede 2y ago
I'd argue this is an argument against purely peer review, as her peers also weren't mathematicians.
Some of us when learning calculus wonder if we'd been alive before it was invented, if we'd be smart enough to invent it. Dr. Tai provably was. (the trapezoid rule, anyway) So I choose to say xkcd 1053 to her,
rather than bullying her for not knowing advanced math.
- eru 2y ago> Dr. Tai provably was. No, we have no proof of that. We just know that she published a paper explaining the trapezoidal rule. (A) That approximation for 'nice' curves was known long before calculus. Calculus is about doing this in the limit (or with infinitesimals or whatever) and also wondering about mathematical niceties, and also some things about integration. (B) I'm fairly certain she would have had a bit of calculus at some point in her education, even if she remembered it badly enough to think she found something new.
- fragmede 2y agoI mean, it's possible she reinvented the wheel because what she really needed in her life is for the math department to laugh at her, but that seems far fetched to me.