3 ms·
> There isn't an oil rig near me. I don't even know where those are. Trades don't pay as much as people claim Move. You’re describing a local disequilibrium.
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> There isn't an oil rig near me. I don't even know where those are. Trades don't pay as much as people claim
Move. You’re describing a local disequilibrium.
(We need subsidised economic mobility vouchers for citizens in America.)
- metalcrow 2y agoMoving really is just the objectively correct answer. People can't always live in the big city, there are a number of places where you can very comfortably live for not much at all.
- yellowapple 2y agoMoving is also both financially and socially disruptive, which is why "just move" is more often than not the precise opposite of the objectively correct answer for people who are already financially stressed and therefore likely dependent on their social connections to minimize various living expenses (e.g. moving in with friends/family, and/or having friends/family watch your kids while you're at work). Yes, plenty of people do end up moving, but almost always as a last resort, and almost always with a preference toward places where they already know people. I ended up moving cities after high school because nobody in my hometown was willing to hire me (this being the years immediately after the '08 recession; even McDonald's was flooded with college-graduate applicants). That was only possible because I already had a job lined up in a town close enough to where my grandparents lived that I could live with them until I had my own apartment. Not everyone is as fortunate as I am.
- zeroCalories 2y agoIf you're not willing to move sounds like your economic situation isn't that bad.
- yellowapple 2y agoOr, as I just explained above, your economic situation is so bad that you outright can't afford it unless you're desperate enough to walk however many hundreds of miles required.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> your economic situation is so bad that you outright can't afford it unless you're desperate enough to walk however many hundreds of miles required The answer to someone who can't or won't move, and has no economic use where they are, is subsidy. (Well, I guess or letting them starve.) If someone insists on staying where they are and not upskilling, either because they can't or won't, they're implicitly demanding a subsidy.
- yellowapple 2y agoA subsidy would indeed be a huge help, and I'm all for it.
- zeroCalories 2y agoI could be a million dollars in debt, disabled, with kids, and still find a way to move. Sorry but I don't buy it that you're ever too poor to move. I think people just don't want to make the sacrifices necessary for it.
- ty6853 2y agoCan be tough if parenting is shared. You'll probably have to see a judge and if the other parent won't agree they'll just award them custody and now there is a warrant for your arrest because you missed payments while hitchhiking to some far away place with jobs. Otherwise yeah easy problem to solve, there is always a train or car you can ride on.
- alwa 2y agoRelated: Yoni Applebaum’s feature today in the Atlantic, recounting the decline of Americans’ geographical mobility: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2025/03/american-geographic-social-mobility/681439/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2025/03/america...
- yellowapple 2y ago"How Progressives Froze the American Dream" Yeah, if you're gonna lead with that sort of blatant victim-blaming, then I'd expect a coherent explanation of one's reasoning in the very first paragraph. It ain't progressives who are gouging renters. It ain't progressives who are jacking up food prices. It ain't progressives who are buying up entire neighborhoods as investments. It ain't progressives who are jacking up medical costs, and it ain't progressives who are denying insurance coverage for said costs.
- alwa 2y agoI felt that the headline was poorly chosen. He’s digging much further back—to the second half of the 19th century, when apparently 30% of Americans would move house in any given year. The “progressives” in this equation were those of decades ago—although he does trace a line through to the modern state of affairs—but the headline feels like a poor editorial choice. It’s a serious and considered piece of research, opinionated but not as combustible as the headline suggests.
- soganess 2y agoI count my lucky stars that I'm fortunate enough to not have to make such a choice. But you're suggesting this person move away from their friends and family (not to mention taking a spouse and kids) to an inhospitable place to work on an oil rig? You know, to do a (famously) astronomically taxing job (when you'd most need that love, comradery, and support)...alone? I've got those city-slicker wanderlust glasses on, and could, for a time, probably enjoy working on an oil rig. But alone? I'd honestly rather live in my parent's/friend's basement and be a walmart greeter.
- tennisflyi 2y agoThere are no entry-level oil rig jobs. They're out in the ocean. They’re dangerous. They want somewhat confident/trained/non-green people