4 ms·
I was fascinated by electricity, chemistry, firecrackers, rockets and hotrods as a boy. It is a miracle I survived. My dad told me that God looks out for little
by WalterBright 2y ago
I was fascinated by electricity, chemistry, firecrackers, rockets and hotrods as a boy. It is a miracle I survived. My dad told me that God looks out for little boys, as otherwise they would not make it to adulthood.
- watwut 2y agoWhen a girl does that, she is seen as irresponsible and stupid.
- dang 2y ago(This comment was unfairly flagged and I turned off the flags on it.) What you say is often true and was even more often true in the past. If it was your experience, I'm sorry to hear it. A friend of mine, one of the more brilliant people I've met, told me that her parents built her brother a workshop because "a boy needs a workshop". When she said she needed a workshop too, she was told she didn't. My sister had similar experiences. At the time, this was taken to be obvious. Things have changed since then, but not completely, and not at the same rate everywhere.
- WalterBright 2y agoDare I say it, and I'm sure there are exceptions, but I've never in my life had a women show any interest in my various hotrods over the years. They sure attracted the attention of boys and men, though. They'd want to see the engine, want to know what modifications were done, etc. The women, would just turn away. I don't know any women who took a car apart to see how it worked. None who build electronic circuits for fun. None who filled trash bags with hydrogen gas. None who hung out in the machine shop and begged the shop foreman to show them how to use those machines. None with gas powered model airplanes. And so on. And yes, I'm sure there are exceptions. Nothing wrong with that. And nothing wrong with men and women having different interests. I'm sorry for what happened to your sister and friend. That was unfair.
- watwut 2y agoNote that my original comment was about difference in how doing something irresponsible is treated - in one situation it is a cool thing and in another proof of stupidity. And dang comment was literally about someone interested who was told no. I have never seen "she is cool because of risking blowup story" with a girl protagonist. It was always she is dumb. I was personally told that plane kids club is boys only. And like, it took courage to ask in the first place, because I did felt I will stick out. And I have seen boys being pushed into technical clubs whether they want it or not. None of that has anything to do with expectations on responsibility or how mistakes are treated.
- WalterBright 2y agoI was replying mainly to dang's comment. In reply to yours, boys doing stupid things are called out for being stupid. They aren't praised for doing things that could blow their hands off or burn the house down. The only ones impressed are their peers. They just do it anyway, and try to conceal it.
- watwut 2y ago> In reply to yours, boys doing stupid things are called out for being stupid. They aren't praised for doing things that could blow their hands off or burn the house down. The only ones impressed are their peers. I mean, this is not true and I have seen that both online and in reality. It is literally in peoples comments. Even in the comment I responded to you dont see them go "this was stupid" and moving to cut the occasion out. If whatever op did was not approved, he simply would not had access to materials. You can prevent a kid from doing dangerous things with "electricity, chemistry, firecrackers and rockets" easily - you just refuse to buy firecrackers if they refuse to deal with them responsibly. And parents frequently do - including boys parents. The fathers comment was affirming, the irresponsible act is not a proof you would be dumb, it is proof you are right kind of a boy.
- WalterBright 2y ago
- belorn 2y agoHonest question, whats the value to this topic in discussing generalizations of gender expectations and gender roles? For one woman in my family tree, her father explicitly give his daughter workshop skills because he viewed it as important skills to have, something she was very happy to receive and has continued to use through her 60 and ongoing life. A other woman in this tree decided early in life that her primary goal in life was to find a husband and raise children. She did it, and later when the children became more independent, the husband requested that she went and got a job, which resulted in her getting a depression since she absolutely did not want to do that. Two other anecdotes, in what would be equivalent to US middle/high school, my school let the students choose between woodwork and needlework. The result was ~30 girls + exactly 1 guy in needlework, and ~30 guys + exactly 1 girl in woodwork. Similar events happened at my next school when choosing between psychology and film study, with every student being of the same gender except for one (me personally being that odd one in that case). I do not see this changing with time, but rather seems to get worse. As the gender equality paradox illustrate, the tendency for stereotypical gender roles and cultural pressure to enforce gender roles tend to get stronger with more gender equality. More recent studies also points towards higher class status as being in a positive correlation in upholding stereotypical gender roles.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dang 2y agoIt's true that the subthread was a generic tangent and in that sense off-topic, but that arguably started with https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42997899 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42997899, not the reply. It's also true that the subthread got a bit testier and flamier as it went along, which was disappointing. I've detached it from the original root now (see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43017762 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43017762). If someone wants to talk about boys, it's fair for others to talk about girls. The reply (to me at least) seemed motivated by personal feeling and personal experience rather than ideological battle, so I thought the flags were unfair. People should be free to exchange their personal feelings and experiences here, as long as they don't attack others.
- guappa 2y agoLots of them don't make it to adulthood. I know 2 that didn't.
- dingnuts 2y agoDad needs to look up survivorship bias.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- boringg 2y agoThats a great line "My dad told me that God looks out for little boys" - I wish it were true but it sounds good.
- WalterBright 2y agoOne time my Cub Scout den mother showed us how to make an electric motor with large nails, copper wire, tin cut from a tin can, wood, and fasteners. Hooking it up to a dry cell caused it to spin merrily. I then wondered what would happen if I plugged it into the wall socket. It buzzed violently for a few seconds and then burst into flames. I learned what AC current was that day. I think I was 8 at the time. Yes, I have been shocked by 110VAC many times. (It's the basis of my superpowers.)
- dang 2y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42997093 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42997093.