3 ms·
Who are these people and why should we trust their analysis?
by rbanffy 2y ago
Who are these people and why should we trust their analysis?
- defrost 2y agoGood question. Two observations: * there are good reasons why they'd be shy about direct identification, * "The analysis stems from CVR data Clark County posted on its website. This data is publicly available for download. Links and archived links are provided here, and listed in detail in the final section of this document." which means that any data wonks (there are a few on HN) can download the same raw data and look to see if this pattern is present (as claimed) and unusual wrt to other election data dumps from prior years, other counties, other countries, etc.
- drawkward 2y agoThats a good question, but the argument presented merits more analysis if the data is presented accurately.
- rbanffy 2y agoThat is true. By itself, the pattern doesn't seem to be an indication of fraud (as much as I would love to believe it, and see it proved in court) - it could just be that they processed first ballots for very heterogeneous regions and then moved to more polarized batches.
- drawkward 2y ago>it could just be that they processed first ballots for very heterogeneous regions and then moved to more polarized batches. Perhaps I misunderstand what you are trying to say here, but this analysis has nothing to do with the order of vote processing. The analysis is alleging that machines that tabulated more Early Voting votes were skewed towards Trump in ways that are consistent with vote fraud; the data supports that allegation, but does not prove it outright. In fact, in light of my next points, it would make sense to try to hide the vote manipulation in machines that have more votes tabulated. To me, what is more damning is the distribution of vote shares among these Early Votes. There is an obvious and huge discontinuity ("Russian Tails") in what is typically a fairly normal (in the statistical sense of the term "normal") distribution of vote shares. This article (https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3478593/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3478593/) from 2012 (well before the current Trump era, meaning there is no inherent anti-trump bias) is relevant in the appropriate statistical methodology. See especially Fig. 2.