3 ms·
Youre very snide. This is the Internet, I am posting an opinion, and further I stated it could be for any number of reasons. This is a forum for discussion, an
by samstave 14y ago
Youre very snide. This is the Internet, I am posting an opinion, and further I stated it could be for any number of reasons.
This is a forum for discussion, and as such, speculation happens.
You appear to be more personally offended by whatever I said in a speculative comment than maybe you should be?
Whatever.
- tptacek 14y agoYou are posting nonsense about real people that you don't know and then getting indignant when people call you on it. If you don't like being called out, consider starting future comments with the words "I don't know what the fuck I'm talking about, but just for shits, here's a theory:".
- samstave 14y agoIt was a speculative comment, I'm happy to be wrong and free to admit it, thistle you no less snide, which is something I've seen from you in the past.
- tptacek 14y agoDo you know Alex? Do you know anyone who works at Simple? Do you have any other sources for what's going on at Simple? Alex is a real person. He is not an Xbox game. Internet or not: he is not up for your review. If you're going to "speculate" about his "performance" or "relationships", you should be ready to go to bat for what you said.
- Ralith 14y agoIf he doesn't want people to discuss his actions and motivations, he shouldn't write them up on a blog.
- tptacek 14y agoThat is about as convincing an argument as Stave's "it's the Internet, I'm allowed to speculate about anything" argument. If he hadn't written a blog post, HN would be all abuzz about his name vanishing from their web pages. There's no way to win this.
- samstave 14y agoAll I speculated in my post was that there could have been more reasons that were stated on the blog post. You're attacking me for not necessarily taking it for face value. Your language is belittling and confrontational and I'll just take it to mean you're probably an asshole, which, honestly is the only personality judgement I have made in this whole thread. You've acted like I made some sort of character attack on Alex... I've seen you do this before on HN, as I stated.
- tptacek 14y agoNo, you speculated that Alex's post was dishonest, since your "speculations" directly contradicted numerous things he actually said. I concluded a few months ago that writing like yours (not yours in particular; it's an annoying HN trope) is actually more rude than a similar comment that outright called the author a liar. You not only did that, but in such a way as to imply that he lies so often it's a casual affair. "Of course", the sentiment you're expressing goes, "there's more to the story than he's telling us. Why would he tell us anything but what makes him look good?" That's what you've communicated. Alex, I am 1000% sure, does not give a shit about what you (or I) think about his most recent career move. But comments like yours, as you can see, drive me up a fucking wall.
- samstave 14y agoThen for that, I apologize. I was not trying to say he was dishonest - but in my experience - I tend not to take every thing I read in the valley for face value (yes, I know they are in NYC). I am happy to be wrong, but given that I do not, as you pointed out, know Alex - or anyone at Simple, I have no option but to speculate on motives and things going on in the spaces I follow. What I was upset about is the level at which you attempted to censor me, call me indignant and berate me discussing this online. If we were in a room face to face and i disagreed with you in person would you have conducted yourself in the same manner? I doubt it, you probably would have been more polite in telling me how you disagreed with me. You're welcome to come over for dinner any time, BTW. Also - I'll teach you how to throw knives. Have a good night. (the dinner offer is still open)
- scott_s 14y agoI believe the motivation for the scorn is because you have no evidence for your speculation, and that speculation is tarnishing a person that we respect.
- samstave 14y agoI speculated on reasons for leaving, I was not talking about his character as a person.
- scott_s 14y agobut sounds like there were relationship issues as well. I wouldn't imagine his cut and run solely on "I cant program enough" -- He had to be either under performing or frustrated with the others' lack of leadership/performance/flexibility/ability to listen/you-name-it That's personal, and you have no basis for it.
- tptacek 14y agoStop doing that.