4 ms·
At most it would be illicit copying. Though it's poetic justice that OpenAI is complaining about someone else playing fast and loose with copyright rules.
by eru 2y ago
At most it would be illicit copying.
Though it's poetic justice that OpenAI is complaining about someone else playing fast and loose with copyright rules.
- tomrod 2y agoStochastic decompression. Dass-it.
- downrightmike 2y agoThe First Amendment is not just about free speech, but also the right to read, the only question is if AI has that right.
- organsnyder 2y agoIf AI was just reading, there would be much less controversy. It would also be pretty useless. The issue is that AI is creating its own derivative content based on the content it ingests.
- boxcake 2y agoIsn't any answer to a question which hasn't been previously answered a derivative work? Or when a human write a parody of a song, or when a new type of music is influenced by something which came before.
- nrabulinski 2y agoThis argument is so bizarre to me. Humans create new, spontaneous thoughts. AI doesn’t have that. Even if someone’s comment is influenced by all the data they have ingested over their lives, their style is distinct and deliberate, to the point where people have been doxxed before/anonymous accounts have been uncovered because someone recognized the writing style. There’s no deliberation behind AI, just statistical probabilities. There’s no new or spontaneous thoughts, at most pseudorandomness introduced by the author of the model interface. Even if you give GenAI unlimited time, it will not develop its own writing/drawing/painting style or come up with a novel idea, because strictly by how it works it can only create „new” work by interpolating its dataset
- Ringz 2y ago> Humans create new, spontaneous thoughts. The compatibility of determinism and freedom of will is still controversially debated. There is a good chance that Humans don’t „create“. > There’s no deliberation behind AI, just statistical probabilities. There’s no new or spontaneous thoughts, at most pseudorandomness introduced by the author of the model interface. You can say exactly the same about deterministic humans since it is often argued that the randomness of thermodynamic or quantum mechanical processes is irrelevant to the question of whether free will is possible. This is justified by the fact that our concept of freedom means a decision that is self-determined by reasons and not a sequence of events determined by chance.
- eru 2y ago> The compatibility of determinism and freedom of will is still controversially debated. There is a good chance that Humans don’t „create“. Determinism and free will are pretty irrelevant here. Unless P=NP, there's no way for us to distinguish in general between eg pseudo random systems and truly random systems from the outside. Btw, I don't think determinism in humans/AI has anything to do with deliberation. The newest AI models are allowed to deliberate. At least by some meanings of the word. > This is justified by the fact that our concept of freedom means a decision that is self-determined by reasons and not a sequence of events determined by chance. Well, different people have different definitions here. None of them very satisfying.
- Ringz 2y ago> Determinism and free will are pretty irrelevant here. No. It’s the other way around. Free will is the basic for „creating something new“. > Btw, I don't think determinism in humans/AI has anything to do with deliberation. With determinism there is no deliberation.
- eru 2y ago> With determinism there is no deliberation. As far as we can tell, all the laws of the universe are completely deterministic. (And that includes quantum mechanics.) As far as we can tell, human beings obey the laws of physics. (To explain: quantum mechanics as a theory is completely deterministic and even linear. Some outdated interpretations of quantum mechanics, like Copenhagen, use randomisation. But interpretations don't make a difference to what the underlying theory actually is. And more widely accepted interpretations like 'Many Worlds' preserve the determinism of the underlying theory.) Btw, neural nets are typically sampled from, and you can use as good a random number generator (even a physical random number generator) as there is, if you want to. I don't think it'll change what we think neural nets are capable of.
- rig666 2y agoDoes my software have the right to read the contents of a DVD and sell my own MP4 of it then no. If a streamer plays a YouTube video on there channel is the content original then yes. When gpt3 was training people saw it as a positive. When people started asking chatgpt more things than searching sites it became a negative.
- eru 2y agoI'm not sure the US 'First Amendment' is relevant here? DeepSeek is in China.
- INGSOCIALITE 2y agokind of. the constitution as a whole, and the amendments, don't give you the right to do anything. you have the right to do whatever you want whenever you want. the constitution tells the government what it can and can not stop you from doing.
- antimatter15 2y agoIt's hardly even illicit- at least in the United States, the output of an AI isn't copyrightable.
- eru 2y agoWas that decided in courts, yet? In any case, copyright ain't the only thing that prevents copying.