3 ms·
This article was submitted earlier [0] but flagged and dead without a single comment disagreeing with its contents. I vouched for it and it was dead again befor
by martin-t 2y ago
This article was submitted earlier [0] but flagged and dead without a single comment disagreeing with its contents. I vouched for it and it was dead again before I managed to comment.
- Anonymous voting does not work. People who have a belief that is not defensible (they are in fact often unable to articulate it) can use anonymous voting to shape (silence) discourse.
- Discussion should be allowed to continue for dead posts, there's no valid reason to block it.
- I don't know the exact mechanism of flagging and vouching but if reputable users vouch for a post, it should not be allowed to be automatically flagged again. It is clearly a contentious topic but there is clearly an attempt to suppress it.
[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42956473 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42956473