3 ms·
> I think it’s basically admitting that the right dictator, if they are there based on merit, can really perform better than someone who wins by their skill at
by furyofantares 2y ago
> I think it’s basically admitting that the right dictator, if they are there based on merit, can really perform better than someone who wins by their skill at campaigning.
Sure. But also there are big differences between companies and countries/government.
Companies compete in a market. There isn't much of a marketplace for country/government. This is a check on individual power, and forces the company to perform somewhat in alignment with what we want as a society. Concentration of power (monopoly) is still an issue in a market and so we regulate the market.
The "dictator" of a company answers to both the market and to regulators, making it less dangerous as a concentration of power than an actual dictator.
Related, it is totally okay for companies to fail, and they regularly do. We are a lot less okay with governments failing.
Companies can also serve a niche. Governments need to serve their entire population. Governments are tasked with all sorts of collective action problems for diverse groups with varying opinions; companies get to pick their market. It's unclear that CEOs tell us much about a dictator trying to serve a population with a range of opinions.
- lenerdenator 2y ago> The "dictator" of a company answers to both the market and to regulators, making it less dangerous as a concentration of power than an actual dictator. Well, kind of. On occasion they participate in regulatory capture making them really only accountable as they care to be given the circumstances. If you have a market cornered on AI-powered, autonomous, robotic leg-equipped chainsaws, and the regulatory environment is weak because you've lobbied for the right rules and the right enforcers of those rules, you could very possibly just have a bad quarter if those chainsaws' AI sees people as trees and starts chasing them around. Maybe not even that. Meta would be a good real-world example. It's just less interesting to imagine.