3 ms·
As someone who owns a machine which gets reminders to update to Windows 11 despite not being allowed to, the whole thing is bizarre. There's no cited explanatio
by pjc50 2y ago
As someone who owns a machine which gets reminders to update to Windows 11 despite not being allowed to, the whole thing is bizarre. There's no cited explanation for the TPM "requirement", and it's obviously not a requirement since you can turn it off. It makes me very suspicious that there's some ulterior motive.
- wmf 2y agoTPM is used for BitLocker.
- dboreham 2y agoCan be used?
- Pooge 2y agoWhich not everybody uses or has even heard of.
- i80and 2y agoThere's a fun thing Windows has started doing where if you sign in with your Microsoft account (instead of an increasingly hard to create local account), Bitlocker is silently set up on your behalf and you don't know until something changes with your system configuration
- krupan 2y agoLol! Of course there's an ulterior motive here! It's Microsoft! (and Intel, the age old Wintel duopoly)
- superjan 2y agoOne explanation is that Microsoft is a collection of teams with different objectives. I suppose the security people would like something better than TPM to compete with Apple’s hardware security. OEM contacts will plead on behalf of their vendors to lower standards. And the sales people want to push end-users to buy a new PC that needs a new license. Ultimately everyone’s life at Microsoft will improve with users moving to Windows 11, to gain sales, improve the spying and to mitigate risks, and avoid bad publicity if problems arise with windows 10.
- johnea 2y agoAnother explanation is that there is some kind of giant back room payola between MS and h/w manufacturers...
- michaelmrose 2y agoOne of the goals of "trusted computing" was supposed to be remote attestation. This was to be a secure unfalsifiable attestation to server that the client computer was running a secure environment that didn't allow bypassing restrictions. EG in the best of all possible worlds for Microsoft your work, your bank, and Netflix would all refuse to run if you weren't running Microsoft. Realistically Mac is way to big to ignore but it would be awfully convenient if comparative small fries like Linux could be locked out especially if developers could be convinced that running Linux as a locked down service within windows was the only things they need. On a less suspicious note the TPM enables a convenient way to secure client machines that are owned by your company in such a way as to make it very difficult to access the data therein without manually managing keys.
- ginko 2y ago>EG in the best of all possible worlds for Microsoft your work, your bank, and Netflix would all refuse to run if you weren't running Microsoft That would be the worst of all possible worlds. It's literally evil.
- khedoros1 2y ago> for Microsoft Key point, there.
- michaelmrose 2y agoSee their previous attempt at making the web windows only. Even if you accept that its greed not malice it creates a single point of failure to be abused in case you know the US is ever taken over by fascists. Not that that you know could ever happen.