5 ms·
Why are HNers so dense when it comes to fundraising? No, the treatment doesn't come off at all sounding like profits or income. Yes, fundraising is definitely a
by pbreit 14y ago
Why are HNers so dense when it comes to fundraising? No, the treatment doesn't come off at all sounding like profits or income. Yes, fundraising is definitely a point of success. Why do HNers have such a hard time with this? Money is an important resource for growing companies! Sheesh.
- brazzy 14y agoIf anyone is dense, it's you. It is certainly odd that the number of HN postings that follow the pattern "Company X raised $Y" far exceeds that of postings about revenue or profits, which are undeniably more important metrics for success. To some degree that can be explained by the fact that many incubated startups are legitimately in a phase where raising capital is important and revenue/profits not yet achievable. But why do we hear so little about later phases? IMO it's just as much a symptom of the dysfunctional aspects of the current startup scene that aims primarily towards acquisitions, where revenue, let alone profits, are ctively avoided because they're seen as an impediment to ridiculous acquisition valuations.
- pbreit 14y agoFor startups, to which HN is oriented, actual revenue is in fact not that important and profits are actually to be avoided.
- brazzy 14y agoIf you think that the goal of a startup is to get the highest possible hype-based acquisition valuation, sure. Call me naive, but I still believe that building an actual profitable business is a much better goal. It may not lead to crazy payouts, but it is also more honest and does not depend as much on timing a boom phase. I gather that this kind of thing is derisively called a "lifestyle business" in startup circles. I submit that at least it is actually a business, rather than a hand of hype poker.
- tomblomfield 14y agoYou do see posts about massive profits - from companies like PayPal & Google. These are the startups that made it.
- robryan 14y agoOne way to look at it is success, another way to look at it is redefining the value the company will need to create to be considered a success.
- pg 14y agoI think they're not so much dense as bitter. There's a subset of HN readers who regard startups as a whole as a sort of con game, and are angry that the participants get so much attention. There may not be that many of them, but their anger makes them disproportionately active as commenters and voters.
- thaumaturgy 14y agoI probably belong to that subset. "Bitter" is an uncomfortable term, but probably accurate. Personally, it's not that I think startups are a con game (and certainly not YC); it's that YC represents a tremendous amount of support and resources and influence that aren't available to people like me who are working just as hard, and are just as skilled, but aren't a good fit for YC. It's tough in practice to not get a little envious of that support when you don't have it. I still think it's good manners to keep my jealousy to myself though. This is a YCombinator forum after all; bringing bile here just because we're not alums is not cool.
- vidar 14y agoDefinitely good manners to keep the jealousy to oneself, but more important to get rid of the jealousy altogether. Resenting others for their success/progress is a huge energy waste (been there, done that).
- thaumaturgy 14y agoI don't resent anybody for their success or progress. That's not what I said, and I'd hate for anybody to misinterpret me that way.
- larrys 14y agoYou went to Harvard. While it would be nice to think that the people accepted at Harvard are the most and only qualified people to go to Harvard we all know that is not the case. Harvard can only accept so many people and many people who could do well there, and aren't accepted, will fail to get in because the decision process isn't perfect in who gets accepted and who doesn't (and I am not even speaking of people who get in for reasons such as family or some other advantage). There are only so many slots. Substitute Harvard for anything where the amount of qualified people greatly exceed the number of slots available and the decision process isn't a lottery and the decision is made by humans. So it would be natural for people to be jealous and maybe bitter if they see someone of equal ability to themselves get into Harvard. Especially if it was in their face everyday. (But it's not, at least with Harvard, the jealous person is probably on another campus. With YC, if you are a HN reader and enjoy it it is in your face every day.)
- tatsuke95 14y ago>"Yes, fundraising is definitely a point of success." Really? When your bank gives you a mortgage, do you deem that a "success"? The fact that there are people who see raising funds as a sort of "end game" is a problem, at least in my opinion. Pets.com, Kozmo.com and Webvan all raised lots of money. So did Enron and Worldcom, in a different way. Success occurss when you produce net economic gains to society.
- debacle 14y agoActually, for most people, the bank giving them a mortgage is deemed a success. It means that the bank believes that you, as a person, are responsible enough to pay back a massive loan. It is a huge personal validation for a lot of people. In the same way, obtaining VC means that a fund believes that your team and your idea are strong enough to return on their investment, and anyone who isn't pissing their pants with joy about receiving an offer, even if they're not going to accept it, has a seriously deficiency in their Oh Shit Is This Really Happening receptors.
- tatsuke95 14y ago>"and anyone who isn't pissing their pants with joy about receiving an offer, even if they're not going to accept it, has a seriously deficiency in their Oh Shit Is This Really Happening receptors." Of course you piss your pants with joy. But its more of a, "no matter what happens we're going to be okay" thing. There are many examples of that investment vaporizing, either in the startup stage or when they unleash the business on the public. It's happening with Zynga as we speak. So, I can understand being happy about it, but calling it a business "success" is a stretch.
- pbreit 14y ago> When your bank gives you a mortgage, do you deem that a "success"? Whithout a doubt! No one is saying it's an end game! It's a milestone on the road to large scale success. Enron and Worldcom were wildly profitable. Is that your point? Your sentiment is exactly what I'm talking about. If you're going to follow startups or have an interest in business-building, at least learn the basics that funding is necessary and raising it is an accomplishment.