3 ms·
> Many feel that the status quo represents wolves looting the taxpayers Many feel lots of things. If this is acceptable then the next Democrat who wins Preside
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> Many feel that the status quo represents wolves looting the taxpayers
Many feel lots of things. If this is acceptable then the next Democrat who wins Presidency should go in and delete federal leases they don't like. (More realistically: delete all the student loan records. I don't even think those touch state laws, so you'd be fully cleared with a pardon.)
> it would be reasonable to consider the possibility that the established media voices may be objecting to an entrenched network of corruption unwinding
Not really. Or maybe we see the problem with having a rando with read-write access to sensitive public infrastructure.
> Reasonable people should be able to debate these things without resorting to reducto-ad-hitlerum
You're the only one bringing up Hitler in this thread.
> none of the coverage presented by the sources has even considered the opposition's argument
Not everything needs to be both sided. This isn't a partisan issue. It's not even binary--plenty of people agree with DOGE having some access but not this.
> Previously an unnamed engineer appointed by an unelected bureaucrat also had access
An unnamed engineer hired by an unelected bureucrat. (After being screened by another group. Subject to conflicts and financial-disclosure rules to an agency.) Such bureaucrat eventually reporting to someone appointed by an elected and confirmed by other electeds.
The people in this chain who report to Bessent did not clear this access. Based on Bessent's statements, he didn't clear read-write access. Legally speaking, this man breached our payments system.
- palmfacehn 2y agoIn which a commentator references the Reichstag fire. Perhaps I am misreading this uncharitably? There has been quite a bit of this lately. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42929327 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42929327 EDIT: "Bessent tells lawmakers Musk’s DOGE does not control Treasury payments system " >POLITICO reported Saturday that Bessent signed off on a plan to give “read-only” access to the payment system to a team led by Tom Krause, the CEO of Cloud Software Group, who is now working for the Treasury Department and serves as a liaison to Musk’s DOGE group that operates out of the United States Digital Service. https://www.politico.com/news/2025/02/03/bessent-musk-doge-treasury-payments-00202278 https://www.politico.com/news/2025/02/03/bessent-musk-doge-t...
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoIf your argument requires picking apart the weakest ones made by someone else and then using that as evidence for your own, it isn't a strong argument. EDIT: Bessent's statement about Krause predates this story about Elez. Bessent doesn't know what he's talking about or Elez is acting illegally. Which one do you think Bessent is going to go with?
- palmfacehn 2y agoIf there is corruption, I hope they can root it out and expose it publicly. I'm also cautiously optimistic that the 3T deficit may be tackled. I've never seen a president come out so strong in his first weeks on these issues. When Trump campaigned on these issues, I assumed it was just more empty campaign promises. If Elon's allegations that media groups like Vox and others have been eating public funds via USAID are true, I doubt there will be much coverage here at HN. We will see. We're at the point where we must agree to disagree. I've stated that I believe the allegations should be considered at face value, if we are to continue in good faith.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> I hope they can root it out and expose it publicly I do too. We also know, now, that it will be almost impossible to prove the evidence hasn't been tampered with. Holding anyone accountable is going to be challenging. > cautiously optimistic that the 3T deficit may be tackled I'm not. The deficit has been blown out by every President since Clinton. We haven't even started counting the bills from the trade war [1]. (And we're still in the kiddie pool with Canada.) > If Elon's allegations that media groups like Vox and others have been eating public funds via USAID are true That will be something he could have learned through less-extreme means. For what it's worth, I don't think Elez was meant to have write access. I don't think he's changed any data. It was a fuckup. And fuckups have costs. Musk will need to settle political battles. (Trump making a public staement about Musk's power is telling [2].) Elez is fucked, legally, but let's be honest, nobody cares about him. The litigation being brought against DOGE's actions just got evidence administrative procedure isn't being followed; a likely and terrible endgame there is union and NGO lawyers getting de facto judgement power. This news should be broadly infuriating. If you hate DOGE, it's an illegal expansion of power. If you love DOGE, it's undermining its credibility. (Cleverly, Musk had Elez put his fingerprints down and Trump, in turn, can throw Musk under the bus when the next fuckup hurts someone.) [1] https://www.politico.com/news/2025/02/03/trump-trade-farm-aid-bailout-00002333 https://www.politico.com/news/2025/02/03/trump-trade-farm-ai... [2] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-02-03/trump-says-musk-sees-treasury-payments-but-can-t-stop-them-alone https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-02-03/trump-say...