3 ms·
> someone else had access to the system before the current changes. What's left to object to? Those people reported to someone elected, or hired by and confirm
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> someone else had access to the system before the current changes. What's left to object to?
Those people reported to someone elected, or hired by and confirmed by electeds. His age is irrelevant beyond his lack of government, payments or public financial experience.
(You're correct inasmuch as these systems should not have been built to allow such unauditable access.)
> it doesn't justify the persistent reducto-ad-hitlerum
Totally agree. Some people have been at Defcon 1 since 2016. They're now suffering the fate of the boy who called wolf. But let's remember: in the end, the wolf was real.
This time, the boy isn't guarding his personal flock. He's guarding ours. This kid in the Treasury is fucking with our government and our system of money.
We need to be hypervigilant, specifically, to ensuring we know what these people are looking at, where they're storing it, what they're changing and what they're deleting. If we learn there's fuckery afoot, that calls for breaking norms, conventions and possibly small laws to counter that. Given the political cards, that must happen at the state level. (This is too new. I have no suggestions.)
> the whole exercise seems like more partisan hyperbole
I don't think so. There are laws with teeth this man is violating. The Privacy Act and FISMA were mentioned. If he's accessing anything related to tax returns, that's super criminalised, potentially beyond the reach of a pardon since those records include state filings.
Potentially more problematically, it may not be possible for him to easily prove he didn't fuck with anything illegally. That shouldn't be enough to convict. But it's almost certainly enough to prosecute, if only to produce a public record showing there wasn't evidence that it happened.
- palmfacehn 2y agoMany feel that the status quo represents wolves looting the taxpayers. 3T in deficit spending is a bit much. Where was the "hypervigilance" before this? There was no public spotlight on the engineers appointed to manage these systems previously. If we are to be balanced in our consideration here, it would be reasonable to consider the possibility that the established media voices may be objecting to an entrenched network of corruption unwinding. These are the stated reasons for the audit. It is worth at least considering them at face value. Reasonable people should be able to debate these things without resorting to reducto-ad-hitlerum. Given that none of the coverage presented by the sources has even considered the opposition's argument, it isn't unreasonable to characterize it as unbalanced partisanship. Yes, a young engineer has access to this data. Previously an unnamed engineer appointed by an unelected bureaucrat also had access. Yet the partisans were not invoking crass analogies at that time. Nobody was raising the alarms about IRS agents or Treasury employees having access to the same data. Regardless of where we are on the partisan spectrum, we should be able to recognize this as hypocritical and more than a little bit suspicious. https://xcancel.com/elonmusk/status/1886301159398535632 https://xcancel.com/elonmusk/status/1886301159398535632 https://xcancel.com/ThomasEWoods/status/1886078877363327337 https://xcancel.com/ThomasEWoods/status/1886078877363327337
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Many feel that the status quo represents wolves looting the taxpayers Many feel lots of things. If this is acceptable then the next Democrat who wins Presidency should go in and delete federal leases they don't like. (More realistically: delete all the student loan records. I don't even think those touch state laws, so you'd be fully cleared with a pardon.) > it would be reasonable to consider the possibility that the established media voices may be objecting to an entrenched network of corruption unwinding Not really. Or maybe we see the problem with having a rando with read-write access to sensitive public infrastructure. > Reasonable people should be able to debate these things without resorting to reducto-ad-hitlerum You're the only one bringing up Hitler in this thread. > none of the coverage presented by the sources has even considered the opposition's argument Not everything needs to be both sided. This isn't a partisan issue. It's not even binary--plenty of people agree with DOGE having some access but not this. > Previously an unnamed engineer appointed by an unelected bureaucrat also had access An unnamed engineer hired by an unelected bureucrat. (After being screened by another group. Subject to conflicts and financial-disclosure rules to an agency.) Such bureaucrat eventually reporting to someone appointed by an elected and confirmed by other electeds. The people in this chain who report to Bessent did not clear this access. Based on Bessent's statements, he didn't clear read-write access. Legally speaking, this man breached our payments system.
- palmfacehn 2y agoIn which a commentator references the Reichstag fire. Perhaps I am misreading this uncharitably? There has been quite a bit of this lately. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42929327 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42929327 EDIT: "Bessent tells lawmakers Musk’s DOGE does not control Treasury payments system " >POLITICO reported Saturday that Bessent signed off on a plan to give “read-only” access to the payment system to a team led by Tom Krause, the CEO of Cloud Software Group, who is now working for the Treasury Department and serves as a liaison to Musk’s DOGE group that operates out of the United States Digital Service. https://www.politico.com/news/2025/02/03/bessent-musk-doge-treasury-payments-00202278 https://www.politico.com/news/2025/02/03/bessent-musk-doge-t...