6 ms·
How very Silicon Valley of the author to treat these numbers almost like they're profits, or any reasonable sort of "income" at all. The real question is: how m
by skrebbel 14y ago
How very Silicon Valley of the author to treat these numbers almost like they're profits, or any reasonable sort of "income" at all. The real question is: how much of that money has already been multiplied tenfold, through exits, IPOs or exorbitant profits?
- adambenayoun 14y agoRaising money isn't any indication for any success but is a nice accomplishment - money coupled with the mentoring and connection from ycombinator could significantly improve the companies odds to succeed. These numbers are vanity metrics but are still indicating a trend - companies going through ycombinator are more likely to raise money than others. I know I would go thru ycombinator - not because of the money I could raise easily but mostly because of the alumni network, connections and access to world class mentors. You could have a look at what companies raised money and what were the successful exits to date: http://www.crunchbase.com/company/y-combinator http://www.crunchbase.com/company/y-combinator
- jedc 14y agoPG originally made the comment in this thread http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4291075 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4291075 on Seed-DB. I launched Seed-DB earlier today (http://www.seed-db.com http://www.seed-db.com) where you can find these data points for all companies that have been through seed accelerators.
- hollerith 14y agoDid you try to compute (latest-round) valuations?
- mehulkar 14y agoAlso would like to see how much of that money went to the same founders. I hear that after the getting funding after the first "success" gets easier.
- pbreit 14y agoThe distinct minority since there are so few repeats and none that I can think of among the big fundraisers (Dropbox, airbnb).
- DanielRibeiro 14y agoIn Techcrunch's defense, they have published a very good article on these kind of numbers[1]. Actually, they have published a lot of articles on this[2]. What is more insteresting, is that Paul Graham reiterates the Power Law of Startups he talked to Peter Thiel recently[3]: Peter Thiel: Do Y-Combinator companies follow a power law distribution? Paul Graham: Yes. They’re very power law. [1] http://techcrunch.com/2011/07/30/vanity-metrics/ http://techcrunch.com/2011/07/30/vanity-metrics/ [2] http://techcrunch.com/search/vanity+metrics http://techcrunch.com/search/vanity+metrics [3] http://blakemasters.tumblr.com/post/21869934240/peter-thiels-cs183-startup-class-7-notes-essay http://blakemasters.tumblr.com/post/21869934240/peter-thiels...
- pbreit 14y agoWhy are HNers so dense when it comes to fundraising? No, the treatment doesn't come off at all sounding like profits or income. Yes, fundraising is definitely a point of success. Why do HNers have such a hard time with this? Money is an important resource for growing companies! Sheesh.
- brazzy 14y agoIf anyone is dense, it's you. It is certainly odd that the number of HN postings that follow the pattern "Company X raised $Y" far exceeds that of postings about revenue or profits, which are undeniably more important metrics for success. To some degree that can be explained by the fact that many incubated startups are legitimately in a phase where raising capital is important and revenue/profits not yet achievable. But why do we hear so little about later phases? IMO it's just as much a symptom of the dysfunctional aspects of the current startup scene that aims primarily towards acquisitions, where revenue, let alone profits, are ctively avoided because they're seen as an impediment to ridiculous acquisition valuations.
- pbreit 14y agoFor startups, to which HN is oriented, actual revenue is in fact not that important and profits are actually to be avoided.
- brazzy 14y agoIf you think that the goal of a startup is to get the highest possible hype-based acquisition valuation, sure. Call me naive, but I still believe that building an actual profitable business is a much better goal. It may not lead to crazy payouts, but it is also more honest and does not depend as much on timing a boom phase. I gather that this kind of thing is derisively called a "lifestyle business" in startup circles. I submit that at least it is actually a business, rather than a hand of hype poker.
- tomblomfield 14y agoYou do see posts about massive profits - from companies like PayPal & Google. These are the startups that made it.
- pg 14y agoWhat on earth did the author say that conflated fundraising with revenues? All he did was compute an average and list some individual amounts raised. Also, a 10x return is the sort of target a VC will have for a series A round. Investors in later stage rounds have lower expectations. And since later stage rounds are much bigger, that means most of the money invested in a successful startup is done with the expectations of way less than 10x returns. From what I know, I would guess that the investor of the median dollar of that billion is happy with the way things are going so far.
- skrebbel 14y agoEssentially, my complaint is exactly that: he just reported the numbers. In a more mainstream financial magazine, I would've expected the author to also do his best trying to find out what those investments are doing. Basically, what I find an interesting question is "Ok, so $1B has been invested in YC companies. How much are those worth now? Of those which exited, how much did they exit for?". Essentially: how healthy is the startup ecosystem economy? Why can't TechCrunch ask and answer questions like these? The impression I get from articles like these, which don't balance the equation but just say "investment, hooray!!", is that the common conception in Startupland is that you're already halfway done when you secured a large amount of funding. In other words, that getting investors implies success. Some other commenters in this thread called me bitter and even jealous for that, but I don't understand that. Sure, getting investment increases the chance for success. Admittedly, I'd go and share a few drinks if someone just gave me a few million dollars for me to spend on making my dream reality. But it's not success yet. I'm still very much in the red! Now, what I find really interesting is the last line of your comment. Do you have any numbers about that? How much is that $1B worth right now? (and, why didn't TechCrunch ask?) ps. I really believed that tenfold returns were expected in later rounds, too. Thanks for clearing that up.
- austenallred 14y agoCan't knock TC for releasing recently-updated numbers. Do they put too much emphasis on funding? Perhaps, but this post is not evidence of that.