4 ms·
I wonder if Apple is stepping into some really muddy territory with their legal brouhaha. While Apple's patents center around their HW and SW design, from what
by hkmurakami 14y ago
I wonder if Apple is stepping into some really muddy territory with their legal brouhaha.
While Apple's patents center around their HW and SW design, from what I understand, Samsung, Motorola, et. al's patents include some fundamental WiFi and communication patents that could be a huge counterpunch towards Apple.
- _djo_ 14y agoBut they're almost all licensed under FRAND terms which in theory should prevent them being used the way Motorola & Samsung have decided to use them. There are many other discussions about that concept on HN.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoNokia's argument was that a "reasonable" term for FRAND was a patent cross-license. Apple disagreed, and a lawsuit ensued. Unfortunately, the judge agreed with Apple on that item. Everybody thinks that Nokia won their lawsuit since the judge awarded them a huge amount of damages. In my opinion, the whole industry lost. Cross-licenses were the standard way of dealing with the patent thicket before Apple decided to upset the cart. The cross-license racket effectively locked out smaller competitors, so it was far from fair, but it does seem saner than the current blood bath.
- _djo_ 14y agoApple refused to cross-licence because it was suing with design and function patents, not FRAND patents (of which Apple's were already fairly licensed), so it wasn't under the same obligations. It's the same logic underpinning their legal battles with Samsung and Motorola, where Apple is using design and function patents (some of them absurd) while the other two only have FRAND patents. Mind you the whole thing is a mess, I've said before that I hope this all leads to some very necessary reform of the system. For one, the whole idea of FRAND patents has clearly come apart.
- cube13 14y ago>Unfortunately, the judge agreed with Apple on that item. Everybody thinks that Nokia won their lawsuit since the judge awarded them a huge amount of damages. In my opinion, the whole industry lost. Cross-licenses were the standard way of dealing with the patent thicket before Apple decided to upset the cart. This is how this is supposed to work, though. Apple and Nokia attempted to negotiate for a while, and could not come to an agreement. That's what prompted the lawsuit. The judgement was over two things: 1. Whether or not Apple violated Nokia's patents(which they were found guilty of). 2. Whether or not Nokia's terms to apple were in-line with FRAND(which they were found not). Since the two could not come to an agreement, they had to use the courts to decide.
- josephlord 14y agoIt cannot be FRAND to insist on cross licence as the impact discriminates against those with patents. The ND part. It would imply that if I can get one essential patent into an important spec I can force you to licence hundreds of completely unrelated patents. That just can't be right.
- SODaniel 14y agoI think it might get REALLY interesting when the 'old players' in the hardware scene (IBM etc) pull out their books and start counter suing for tech they developed when Apple were still flogging their Apple 2s Remember, Apple as they sit today is a company with less then 10 years in the market.
- cube13 14y agoThe only patents that currently valid are ones filed after 1995(prior to June 1995, the standard patent term is 17 years after the first filing date). All of the patents from the 80's are now public domain.
- taligent 14y agoSorry but what on earth are you talking about ? Why would companies like IBM suddenly start suing Apple and for what possible gain ? And Apple is nearly 40 years old with patents that extend across a wide variety of areas given that they design their own software and hardware.
- fpgeek 14y agoI agree that IBM wouldn't see much profit in opening up the archives just to sue Apple. However, I suspect IBM has seen (and will continue to see) plenty of profit in opening up the archives in order to sell patents to companies more motivated to sue Apple.
- josephlord 14y agoEven if they have relevant patents they would be looking for money rather than legal costs and injunctions. I think it is likely that Apple would just pay some reasonable fees and move on. They might even view the development as positive if it cost Android manufacturers as much per unit as they typically have less margin so may have to raise their prices making the Apple products relatively more attractive.
- gscott 14y agoNot to mention that it is a distraction to Apple employees. They are going to want to follow the case and (being human) have personal feelings involved. Already Apple needed to have released a new phone but haven't. People are tired of waiting and buying Samsung instead.