5 ms·
Can somebody who understands Libertarianism help me with the following thought experiment? Suppose Libland is a libertarian state. The occupants of Libland st
by tome 18y ago
Can somebody who understands Libertarianism help me with the following thought experiment?
Suppose Libland is a libertarian state. The occupants of Libland stay alive by eating Food. Xia is another state. For whatever reason, they don't like Libland, and for whatever reason, they can produce Food much more cheaply than Libland.
Xia starts flooding the Libland market with cheap Food, so that it's is uneconomic for anyone in Libland to produce Food, and the Food industry disappears.
Suddenly Xia cuts of Libland's food supply, and invades several days later. Libland has no means of producing food in short order, and they cannot buy it from anyone else for some reason (for example Xia is the only other state, or it would take too long to open trading routes with other states).
How does Libertarianism cope with this situation?
[edit: please don't treat me as stupid or a troll. I genuinely want to understand libertarianism, and extreme counter-examples are a method of understanding that I find very helpful]
- gaius 18y agoOnce Xia initiates the use of force the gloves are off basically. Libertarianism doesn't permit initiation of force but does permit an overwhelming and decisive response. Xia would find itself "liberated" in short order.
- homme 18y agoOn empty stomachs versus well feed soldiers? Who might be conscripted and organized?
- tome 18y agoPrecisely. My point is that once the situation I described has been arrived at, there's no hope for Libland. Therefore, I presume, Libertarianism has a way to prevent the situation arising in the first place. What is it?
- cx01 18y agoIf the residents of Libland sense that they might be attacked, they would obviously keep food reserves or start buying only home-grown food in order to support their own industry.
- tome 18y agoIt's not in their interest to do that individually, but only as a matter of domestic policy.
- cx01 18y agoOf course it is. If there's a huge uncontrollable risk, people will insure themselves against it. If people know that they might be attacked and don't have enough food, they will hoard some.
- tome 18y agoMy point is that unless the nation collectively hoards food for the military then it's not worth doing. If they hoard individually it buys them a few more months of survival in dire circumstances. What's the point? They might as well spend their money to best enjoy their remaining time before invasion.
- gaius 18y agoIf everyone stockpiles individually for themselves and their families then you have a massive distributed cache that is more resilient that a centralized warehouse that can be bombed. You seem to think the responsibilities of "the state", "the military" and "individuals" are distinct. They're not. Some individuals like to pretend they are, and rely on the government to do X (and some governments play the same game and rely on individuals to do Y) but reality will always eventually assert itself, whatever system of government you prefer.
- tome 18y agoBut they won't stockpile individually, because it's in no one's individual interest to stockpile. (This is an example of the Prisoner's Dilemma). I agree with you that "reality will always assert itself" but I'm having a hard time understanding how anyone things that Libertarianism can be that reality.
- gaius 18y agoNow you're just being ridiculous. What country wouldn't have food reserves? Even tinned food in supermarkets, let alone military stockpiles. Unless Xia managed to perfectly conceal its dislike for its neighbour, that is. Perhaps they had MAGIC UNICORNS to help?
- tome 18y agoWhy would anyone in Libland be interested in the motives of its neighbour? Foreign policy and intelligence is normally the realm of a government. Who performs that role in Libland, and what is their incentive to do so?
- gaius 18y agoErr, the government does. Perhaps you ought to go to Wikipedia and look up the difference between Libertarianism and Anarchy?
- tome 18y agoForeign policy is not mentioned on the Wikipedia page for Libertarianism. How does a Libertarian system decide which roles (like researching the intentions of foreign states, and defending against them) a government should play, and which (like presumably researching the weather, and defending against natural disasters) it shouldn't?
- homme 18y agoMoreover, how does it morally confiscate wealth to finance programs from those inhabitants that don't want to pay for said activities?
- tome 18y agoSo Xia fights Libland until its food reserves are depleted.
- gravitycop 18y agoWhat country wouldn't have food reserves? The United States does not have food reserves (other than grain stored in grain elevators, which grain Tome implied Libland would instead be importing just-in-time). Here is what the United States has to look forward to in a national disaster: http://www.google.com/search?q=you+will+survive+nuclear http://www.google.com/search?q=you+will+survive+nuclear You are a survivor. Doomsday has occurred and you are a survivor. While you are waiting for the spouse and kids to get home maybe you should do something practical. Like go down to the supermarket and lay in a bit of an extra stock. You may notice that the little corner store has closed. If he has believed the rumor, he wants to save his stock. And besides, your money may not be worth anything tomorrow. You thought you had seen rapid inflation before but this is like from zero to a million in sixty seconds. At the supermarket, if you are early enough, you will find pandemonium. If not, you will find practically nothing. Maybe a large bag of dog food (take it) and some cans of floor wax (forget it). The rest of the stuff was all in those carts that you met come flying up the walk as you came running down. There won't be any girls at the cash registers, (they have done their shopping and gone). Besides, the cash registers aren't working anyhow, with no power. It may have taken the hired manager a little longer to figure out that he should grab what he can and head home to his family, but he has probably gone now. The only cops you will see are the one's grabbing stuff themselves.
- TravisLS 18y agoGiven this situation (two and only two competing states), libertarianism is probably less viable. In the real world, however, you have a greater number of players. If Libland has positive economic relations with other states (as most free people seem to prefer), it would theoretically have alternative sources of food from those allies. In addition, unless Libland's government had irrationally incited Xia's actions (theoretically, an unlikely choice for a free society), other states would see this a flagrant attack on Libland and come to its aid. The example is certainly viable for a case where one state (out of over 200 in the real world) has a monopoly on producing any essential good, or where Xia's military is more powerful than the combined strength of all potential opposing states. I don't think the example extends beyond those corner cases, however.
- tome 18y agoMy hypothesis is extreme and doesn't necessarily correspond with the real world, but proposing it and modifying it as others come up with criticisms is one pedagogical tool I would like to apply in this situation. To answer your points: * yes, Libland could buy Food from alternative sources. To extend the discussion I would need to adjust my hypothesis. * no, the other states would not come to Libland's aid. If they were libertarian, they would not get involved in other states' disputes, and in any case they would know Libland would never come to their aid, so why should they reciprocate?
- gaius 18y agoBut the other states don't matter! If Libertarian country A is in trouble (from an aggressor, not of its own doing) and free citizens from Libertarian country B want to get involved, they are free to do so. It's none of B's government's business! It would not even occur to a Libertarian that he or she might require the government's permission. Tho' given that the Libertarian value is long-term freedom, it's unlikely for a Libertarian nation (not the same thing as s state) to be caught napping. A Libertarian country is likely to have a well-trained and well-armed militia, but not much equipment or experience or inclination for expeditionary warfare.
- 18y ago
- cmac 18y agoThis is an interesting example but I think it's not very really helpful in understanding Libertarianism. First let me answer your question directly: in this example, Libland is undoubtedly screwed because Xia has a monopoly on the food supply. The people of Libland would not be able to cope with this situation and they'd most likely be overrun. Sure, there will be pockets or resistance with guerrillas doggedly fighting on for years or decades, but as a state, Libland would no longer exist. Nevertheless, I think that the example isn't helpful because of two positions: 1) The unexplained reason why Xia can produce food so cheaply. 2) That it would be uneconomical for anyone other than Xia to produce food. In the real-world, there would be a competitor for Xia to supply food. Even if Xia started off as the only supplier, someone would realise that they could enter the market supplying food that's a little cheaper, higher quality or just a little more different. The people of Libland, knowing the dangers of relying on only one source, would then also start purchasing from the competitor _in_addition_ to Xia. I therefore think that your hypothetical scenario wouldn't exist outside of the 'thought laboratory'.
- gravitycop 18y agothe example isn't helpful because of [...] 1) The unexplained reason why Xia can produce food so cheaply. No explanation is needed. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Absolute_advantage http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Absolute_advantage http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparative_advantage http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparative_advantage
- cmac 18y agoWell, I think an explanation in real-world terms is needed, not theoretical definitions. For example: 1) Does Xia have better climatic conditions? If so, why wouldn't neighbouring countries have similar conditions to become a viable competitor? 2) Do the have better packing and transportation technology? If so, why can't another country develop/buy/steal the technology? 3) Etc, etc. Hence, my point is that the imposed constraints may not normally exist.
- gravitycop 18y ago