4 ms·
A rule that I learned a long time ago in tech is, "The commodity always wins." And it seems to work out that way most of the time. If there are two technologi
by btilly 14y ago
A rule that I learned a long time ago in tech is, "The commodity always wins."
And it seems to work out that way most of the time. If there are two technologies, and one manages to become a commodity that is installed all over, that's the technology that you see innovation coming from and the future coming out of. It is often the worse technology. But it wins.
I don't have a horse in the phone race. But when I see Apple folks talking about profit margins and Android folks talking about units sold, I'd lay my money on Android winning in the long run. It may be a worse market to be in now, it may make a lot less money. But where the users are is where the future tends to be.
This happens for a lot of reasons. Let me give just one. When teenage kids (who don't have a lot of money of their own) get a smart phone, they are going to be given Android devices because it is cheaper. When they play around with those phones and master them, they will be learning Android. Many will stick with Android. Others will learn Android, and their first programming experiences will be with it because that is what they have. And once they grow up they will be worth a lot more than $0, both as customers or developers. But they won't be imprinted on iOS.
- rimantas 14y agoPlease, everyone, when talking about "wins"—do specify, what is won. In this case—the race to the bottom?
- btilly 14y agoWhat I mean by win is that they will wind up becoming the dominant technology with the lion's share of the market, revenue, and other companies building on top of. The also ran technology may survive, but it becomes relatively insignificant. For example compare the Mac vs Microsoft Windows. The Mac was better, had better product margins, etc. Microsoft was the commodity and completely owned the market. For other historical examples compare VMS vs Unix, Lisp vs C, OSI protocols vs TCP/IP, Smalltalk vs Java, traditional client-server vs web apps, CORBA vs SOAP (vs JSON rpcs), Perl vs PHP, and so on. In many cases the losing technology was technically much nicer to work with. But the winning technology won. For a famous essay reflecting on why, see http://www.jwz.org/doc/worse-is-better.html http://www.jwz.org/doc/worse-is-better.html from the Lisp vs C war.
- rimantas 14y agoSo how your theory explains Apple's success in recent years? Comparing Mac to windows makes no sense, but still: just look at the sales trend of Mac's vs. other computers. Then see how much companies are making with Android: many adopted the OS but only a couple actually get profits from it.
- btilly 14y agoApple's recent success has come from recognizing and creating new markets. Even in traditional computers, a large part of their current success is that they pioneered the market for people who want physically attractive computers. This is unlikely to continue to succeed for them without Steve Jobs a the helm. As for Mac vs Windows, I'm referring to the old macs, OS 7, etc. That story ended with Apple almost dying before Steve Jobs came back and did what he did best - focused the company on creating new markets. Moving back to your focus on profits, I think you could benefit from reading The Innovator's Dilemma and its followup The Innovator's Solution. What you'll learn is how across many types of technologies (examples include ship design, steel production techniques, earth moving machines, disk drives, etc), across many decades, whenever two technologies compete head to head, the odds very, very strongly favor the one that is cheap and crappy. Throughout the competition, all of the revenue to be made is in the established, strong technology - until they suddenly have no market left. Given that history, there is no question what to expect in phones. The iPhone is clearly the superior option that makes more money. Android is clearly the cheap crappy option that ships more units. But both are going to improve faster than people's needs increase, and Android is going to win.
- ZeroGravitas 14y agoYes. Because the people who benefit from a "race to the bottom" are the customers. It's a basic tenet of free market capitalism and seems, more or less, to be working. Why the apple community feels the need to attack the concept of free market competition I have no idea, I think they just like the sound of the phrase, it's certainly become popular recently without any outward sign that most people who use it even know what it means.
- 2muchcoffeeman 14y agoThis assumes that Apple learned nothing from the success of the iPod. If you look at Apple's product line up right now, they are slowly but surely back filling their product line up just like the iPod. Look how that turned out for everyone else. It's too early to bet on either platform in the long term.
- btilly 14y agoRead item #5 in http://www.paulgraham.com/ambitious.html http://www.paulgraham.com/ambitious.html and you'll find out that the best inside information that Paul Graham could get says that Apple has what Steve Jobs left in its pipeline, and nothing else big coming. This tells me that the trend you are hoping for in Apple's product line should not be counted on.