2 ms·
I think it’s a little early to call the end of the U.S. Constitution. There is a time component to the rule of law that can be frustrating in the moment but has
by snowwrestler 2y ago
I think it’s a little early to call the end of the U.S. Constitution. There is a time component to the rule of law that can be frustrating in the moment but has always been true.
The President is free to assert his desires. Other parts of the country are free to push back if they choose. This takes filing lawsuits, lobbying Congress, pursuing prosecutions, etc. all of which take time, money, and effort. Which in turn allows short-term disruption to happen as the legal process plays out. Which again, is frustrating.
Political mood is also more fickle than people usually believe at the beginning of a new administration. FDR, LBJ, W, Obama, and many other presidents passed through a time in which conventional wisdom held that they had changed the game and amassed too much power. In every case we can look back and see that while they each have left a legacy that endures, it’s smaller than expected at the time. The pendulum swung the other way later on.
My own opinion on this is that “don’t tell me what to do” is among the most popular political positions among Americans. So for example, to the extent DEI felt like being told what to do, it became unpopular. But now that anti-DEI is in power, I expect the bloom will come off pretty quickly. In part because of overreach by a new administration overestimating their mandate. (As most new administrations do.)
- sevensor 2y agoAgreed, I wouldn’t call it the end either. But it’s a problem for our system of government and I think it’s worth calling attention to.
- mywittyname 2y ago> I think it’s a little early to call the end I don't. This has been a long, gradual erosion of constitutional rights, and now the system has crumbled. It may appear to stand, but it's merely resting on the rubble. SCOTUS is going to rule with GOP doctrine, regardless of what the constitution says. The GOP may pursue legal avenues for their actions in an attempt to not make it so apparent that the country is now under single party, totalitarian rule. But they don't have to (see: news). It started with minor constitutional violations, like emoluments, and has ended with blatant ones, such as attacking birthright citizenship.
- ahmeneeroe-v2 2y agoInteresting and high-quality comment. >I think it’s a little early to call the end of the U.S. Constitution. I totally disagree with this though. It is several generations late to start crying about the end of the US Constitution. I basically agree with the rest of your comment though, especially the "don't tell me what to do" and the Presidential "honeymoon period".