3 ms·
> We have a constitutional problem where the Congress is unwilling or unable to legislate effectively and the executive gets to make policy unilaterally. This i
by pjc50 2y ago
> We have a constitutional problem where the Congress is unwilling or unable to legislate effectively and the executive gets to make policy unilaterally. This is not the balance of powers from the U.S. constitution
The Republican party controls both houses and the presidency, having already stacked the supreme court, so they get to do whatever they want and there is no balance of powers.
Inevitable consequence of a two-party system with first past the post voting.
- FredPret 2y agoThere is still a very clear balance of power. All Republicans and all Democrats don’t act and think as one. Take any collection of humans, of any size, and their opinions will be spread across a spectrum. There are, and always will be, some members in either house and of any party that find it’s in their political interest to debate and pull new laws left or right. This is especially true under FPTP because each member has to answer to an area, and different areas of a country have baked-in differences in their ideal political outcomes and points of view.
- noobermin 2y agoThis is a naive, context-free misunderstanding of the present moment based on supposedly intuitive truisms. The Republican party is Trump's party and has been for years now. Pretending there is that much variation that matters is ridiculous and can be remedied by reading any piece of news from the last few years.
- dboreham 2y agoIf that were true then we wouldn't be watching a collection of circus performers get confirmed by congress.
- coliveira 2y agoThe US is now a formal democracy, but it doesn't work as one. There is one guy making decisions, the remaining are either too feeble to do anything about or just fine with the status quo. Yes, there are formal avenues for responses, like the judiciary system, but they've been made toothless. The very fact that Trump is back in the WH is proof of this.
- sevensor 2y agoBalance of powers has nothing to do with party; it’s about the ability of one branch of government to operate without constraint by the other branches of government. It was instituted in the US by people who were trying to take lessons from history; both recent (the Intolerable Acts) and ancient (Appius Claudius, Octavian, Alexander, the Thirty), and it’s been forgotten by generations who’ve come to take its protections for granted.
- tastyfreeze 2y agoLooking at the past voting records, Democrats often vote as a block in both houses of Congress. The same can't be said about Republicans.
- contagiousflow 2y agoI feel like that's pretty disingenuous to say that. They have both been increasing party line voting for decades. https://rollcall.com/2021/03/03/no-quarter-for-centrists-in-house-2020-vote-studies/ https://rollcall.com/2021/03/03/no-quarter-for-centrists-in-...
- thrance 2y agoTrump has definitely purged the Republican party of its most moderate members, leaving him surrounded by only the most radical of sycophants. Why do you put so much trust into your institutions? Trump has promised that "we won't ever have to vote ever again", he has been made untouchable by the supreme court, and is now passing budgetary laws without congress. The opposition is powerless, his own party has become an echo chamber for fascist talking points.
- FredPret 2y agoI think fascism is about totalitarian dominance of the population by the government, no? Seems like cutting taxes and bureacracy does the opposite. Unless “fascist” and “nazi” means “people I don’t like”.
- thrance 2y agoYour definition of fascism is deeply flawed, it would include kingdoms which are not automatically fascists, for example. I go by this [1] definition of fascism, which the current republican party fits almost perfectly. Trump rules almost unopposed, and is further consolidating his power with each passing day. Neither court nor congress can harm him anymore. That you may still believe he is fighting for freedom, peace and democracy is baffling, with everthing that's been happening in the past 2 weeks. Indeed, I don't like fascists and nazis, sue me. [1] https://www.nybooks.com/articles/1995/06/22/ur-fascism/ https://www.nybooks.com/articles/1995/06/22/ur-fascism/
- tbrownaw 2y ago> The Republican party controls both houses and the presidency, having already stacked the supreme court, so they get to do whatever they want and there is no balance of powers. - No, the supreme court is the same size it's always been. - No, members of congress don't always vote the party line (although this has consistently gotten worse over time) - No, that's not what "balance of powers" means.
- hiddencost 2y agoPoint of order, the supreme court has changed size 6 times https://www.supremecourt.gov/about/institution.aspx#:~:text=The%20number%20of%20Justices%20on,an%20average%20of%2016%20years. https://www.supremecourt.gov/about/institution.aspx#:~:text=...
- whatshisface 2y agoA point of order means someone has violated congressional procedure.
- 15155 2y agoOr just Robert's Rules.
- whatshisface 2y agoRight, but disagreeing with something is just a point, not a point of order.
- dboreham 2y ago> - No, the supreme court is the same size it's always been. Stacked in the sense that more members were appointed by one party vs the other (including one by dubious means), and those people apparently are quite partisan.
- chomp 2y ago1.) non sequitur 2.) missing the point 3.) pedantic The point is that the current party in power has had multiple opportunities to reign in the current lawlessness and the current minority party has attempted to do so, to no result.
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 2y agoFPTP is a superior option to proportional representation. Belgium still lacks a federal government despite voting 5 months before the Americans and being just some 10 million people and we aren't going to get one either before they get their whole cabinet (minister equivalents) confirmed and installed. This is because there are 5 parties trying form a coalition raging from nationalist-separatist to socialist-rebranded-to-progressive across 2 languages. Brussels lacks its regional government too and is even further away from resolving the impasse. America would be well advised to avoid this. They'd immediately get a language divide between English and Spanish. The alleged "grand coalitions" of the Democrat and Republican parties would crumble. There might be some consensus in the center which might be large enough but then policies would never change regardless of who you vote for, just like in the times before Trump.