3 ms·
For some reason, with newer media, the simple principle of "no meddling in private communications/publishing" gets lost. You do realize that the same prin
by angersock 14y ago
For some reason, with newer media, the simple principle of
"no meddling in private communications/publishing" gets
lost.
You do realize that the same principle is hardly something that a free market would automatically support at reasonable price to the user, right?
It's working just fine without the FCC's enlightened
approach
You're not a Time Warner Cable customer, or Cox, or subject to throttling very much, are you?
- danielweber 14y agoI'm a Time Warner Cable customer. I haven't noticed any throttling ever on VoIP or Netflix or Skype. I am also in an area with competition, which probably plays a role.
- tptacek 14y agoWhat's a "reasonable price"? A penny taken off the monthly cost of Internet access by fiat is a penny subsidy granted to Internet service customers. In a competitive market for Internet service, providers can't gouge customers because they'd lose to competitors that didn't. You are making a stronger argument against local service cable, copper loop and RF monopolies than you are against the libertarian opposition to net neutrality.
- beernutz 14y agoThat is exactly the point though. Since there AREN'T enough competitors, the free market does not work. BEING a competitor means laying cable, getting right-of-ways, getting other permissions from local government, etc. It is not something where several competitors will spring up offering better service and/or better price when one bad actor decides to disallow skype on their network for instance. When the market fails to provide a fix, the government should step in to keep the public from being at the mercy of greedy monopolies.
- tptacek 14y agoIt's also very difficult to start a new car company. But we don't have "car neutrality".
- gojomo 14y agoNobody's owed anything "at a reasonable price to the user". The right to free speech isn't conditional on books/newspapers/pamphlets being cheap. The kind of meddling that's most dangerous is government meddling. Simply keeping FCC rules out of the Internet delivers that "no meddling" benefit, for free. And if things are a little expensive, a little limited by private contracts, a little abused by current providers? The march of consumer demand and technology will fix that in a few years. I've been a Time-Warner customer, and Comcast, and AT&T, and RCN, and Sonic.net. I've hit throttling -- typically for peak total usage, rather than specific applications. But so what? A regulation from the FCC can't make more bandwidth. It can't keep up with even a year or two's needs in flexible new policies to handle changing traffic/application mixes. A competitive market with differentiated services, new technology, and new entrants can keep up. Way too much defeatism is inherent in the idea that the cable-DSL duopoly is all we'll ever have. That defeatism can be a self-fulfilling prophesy: encumber the industry with national pricing & transit regulations, tell everyone "we've made it so these two safe government-approved choices are all you'll ever need", and you might make that so -- just as the FCC stagnated things for decades with its power-concentrating telephony and broadcast industry regulations. Twenty years ago, we didn't have a broadband duopoly. We had a zero-opoly. So even a duopoly is an improvement. And it won't last. It's too easy to incrementally string more wires or deploy new wireless technologies, to precisely those customers who chafe under any current limits. The same competition that got us this far is still working, and doesn't require a bossy Washington DC agency staffed by censors and political-party hack lawyers to save us from ourselves.
- bsphil 14y agoIt's actually harder to string more wires as a new company, because so much is already owned by a few very big players. So you have to buy access to the infrastructure from your competitors before you can even compete with them as an ISP. The opposite is true in the UK where the government owns the Tier 1 network (and possibly Tier 2, I forget). There, startup companies offering competitive services and prices don't have nearly the trouble flourishing as they do in the US. You seem to think that essentially any role the government has in a market economy is going to be negative for consumers overall, and that is patently false.
- rsanchez1 14y agoI am a Cox customer, and I will soon be switching providers. Free speech wins.