4 ms·
> I'll just say that this definition of "militia" is completely incorrect in the historical context in which it was written. That's also true for the definitio
by ceejayoz 2y ago
> I'll just say that this definition of "militia" is completely incorrect in the historical context in which it was written.
That's also true for the definition of arms.
You can define "militia" as "all the of-age white males" if we get to define "arms" as "muskets". Fair trade!
- pc86 2y agoI'm happy to debate or discuss this in good faith but this isn't a good faith argument. "Arms" meant (means) state-of-the-art, military-level hardware. The muskets that civilians had in their homes were as good or better than what you'd be issued by the burgeoning American military, to the extent that you were issue anything and weren't just expected to bring your own. Throughout all of American history, perhaps with the exception of nuclear arms and vehicles like tanks and submarines, firearms research and development has occurred in private industry and made its way into the military later.
- ceejayoz 2y ago> The muskets that civilians had in their homes were as good or better than what you'd be issued by the burgeoning American military... Probably not cannons and grapeshot, though.
- pc86 2y agoTook me 10 seconds on Google: https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2020/jun/29/joe-biden/joe-bidens-dubious-claim-about-revolutionary-war-c/ https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2020/jun/29/joe-biden/... But the specifics are irrelevant, the spirit is clear. "The Constitution shall never be construed to prevent the people of the United States who are peaceable citizens from keeping their own arms." - Sam Adams, address to Massachusetts Ratifying Convention, 1788
- ceejayoz 2y ago> Took me 10 seconds on Google... Finding an article that says, essentially, ¯\_(ツ)_/¯, and then goes on to talk about government licensed privateers - akin to the modern setup of a security guard licensed to carry in a state that doesn't otherwise permit it. Is there evidence outside of that of personal home ownership of cannons? (Let alone of a widespread nature?) Do we think Sam Adams would advocate personal ownership of nuclear bombs, or do we think he'd perhaps see such things as a category slightly different than the muskets of his time?
- pc86 2y agoWe can hem and haw and guess about what we think the founders would think, or we can look at what they said and what the historical context of firearms ownership is. We don't have private ownership of nuclear arms now and pointing there is IMO another explicitly bad faith argument, in part because it's clear you don't particularly care what the founders' intentions were because there are thousands of pages of discussions and arguments showing that regular every-day people were allowed to - encouraged to, in cases required to - own weapons on par or better than military armaments of the day. And despite that, my guess is you have a problem with people owning or carrying AR-15s, or with people carrying handguns on them when they go to a restaurant, etc. I'm happy to be proven wrong though! The start of this little digression was private citizens carrying their personally owned handguns outside of their home as is plainly meant by the word "bear" in 2A. So rather than moving the goalposts to Sam Adams's opinion on private ownership of nuclear weapons or whatever other bad faith things you want to bring up, I'd rather focus on that.
- ceejayoz 2y ago> We can hem and haw and guess about what we think the founders would think, or we can look at what they said and what the historical context of firearms ownership is. "Nothing like machine guns exist, let alone in private hands, let alone widely so" is part of that historical context, yes. > We don't have private ownership of nuclear arms now... As the apocryphal Churchill quote about whores goes, "We've already established that [some arms don't fall under the 2nd]; we're merely haggling over [which]..."
- potato3732842 2y agoCannons and grapeshot were an essential part of marine commerce at the time and tons of them were privately owned. The only control on who could own what back then was wealth.
- ruined 2y agoCannon and grapeshot were legal then and are legal today. Though if it's not specifically a muzzle-loading black powder cannon, you need to pay a $200 tax.
- psunavy03 2y ago> You can define "militia" as "all the of-age white males" if we get to define "arms" as "muskets". Fair trade! Ah yes, the argument that was explicitly rejected by the Supreme Court as "bordering on the frivolous." I suppose the First Amendment is also limited to quill pens, parchment, and yelling to passersby from a literal soapbox?
- ceejayoz 2y agoSure. They also said home-grown marijuana exclusively for in-state personal use in California was "interstate commerce". > I suppose the First Amendment is also limited to quill pens and parchment? The First Amendment, as the Second, was fully intended to have common-sense exceptions. Shit, John Adams himself signed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alien_and_Sedition_Acts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alien_and_Sedition_Acts into law.
- int_19h 2y agoI don't think many people would consider the Alien and Sedition Acts an example of a "common-sense exception" to 1A.
- ceejayoz 2y agoI agree! But one of the more prominent Founding Fathers disagreed! This is why I find "but the Founding Fathers wanted everyone to be able to own an AR-15" uncompelling. It's fairly clear evidence they thought the First was way less comprehensive than we currently interpret it, yet people interpret the Second the opposite way.
- psunavy03 2y ago. . . so two wrongs make a right?
- ceejayoz 2y agoI'm not sure how you get that from my comment. If one is to cite what the Founding Fathers intended as justification for an absolute individual right to bear arms, one must confront the fact that they clearly didn't consider the fairly simply written First Amendment to be absolute. That points to an attitude of "well obviously we're not gonna be stupid about it" for other amendments introduced at the same time... like the Second. If they felt the Alien and Sedition Acts complied with the First Amendment, I think it's reasonable to believe they'd consider the assault weapons ban to comply with the Second.