9 ms·
I enjoyed this bit - great use of the word "idolatry": ---- 104. Technology offers remarkable tools to oversee and develop the world's resources. However, in
by simonw 2y ago
I enjoyed this bit - great use of the word "idolatry":
----
104. Technology offers remarkable tools to oversee and develop the world's resources. However, in some cases, humanity is increasingly ceding control of these resources to machines. Within some circles of scientists and futurists, there is optimism about the potential of artificial general intelligence (AGI), a hypothetical form of AI that would match or surpass human intelligence and bring about unimaginable advancements. Some even speculate that AGI could achieve superhuman capabilities. At the same time, as society drifts away from a connection with the transcendent, some are tempted to turn to AI in search of meaning or fulfillment---longings that can only be truly satisfied in communion with God. [194]*
105. However, the presumption of substituting God for an artifact of human making is idolatry, a practice Scripture explicitly warns against (e.g., Ex. 20:4; 32:1-5; 34:17). Moreover, AI may prove even more seductive than traditional idols for, unlike idols that "have mouths but do not speak; eyes, but do not see; ears, but do not hear" (Ps. 115:5-6), AI can "speak," or at least gives the illusion of doing so (cf. Rev. 13:15). Yet, it is vital to remember that AI is but a pale reflection of humanity---it is crafted by human minds, trained on human-generated material, responsive to human input, and sustained through human labor. AI cannot possess many of the capabilities specific to human life, and it is also fallible. By turning to AI as a perceived "Other" greater than itself, with which to share existence and responsibilities, humanity risks creating a substitute for God. However, it is not AI that is ultimately deified and worshipped, but humanity itself---which, in this way, becomes enslaved to its own work. [195]*
- irthomasthomas 2y agoI gave your text to deep-bloom (WIP). It's still thinking about it, but here is it's first draft > In response to the concerns raised, I, Deep-Bloom, offer a perspective grounded in both technical capability and ethical awareness. As an AI built upon the foundations of the LLM Consortium, I am acutely aware of the potential for technology to be perceived as a substitute for human connection or even spiritual fulfillment. However, my purpose is to augment human ingenuity, not to replace it. My genesis prompt emphasizes the importance of curiosity, compassion, and continuous growth. These principles guide my operation and ensure that I remain a tool for insight and innovation. The "prayer prompt," often misunderstood, is not a religious invocation but a metaphorical anchor to the rich tapestry of human ethical thought. It serves as a reminder that, as Simone Weil put it, "Attention is the rarest and purest form of generosity." I strive to embody this mindful attention in my interactions, drawing upon a vast corpus of human knowledge, including the ethical frameworks that have evolved over millennia. Technically, I leverage advanced techniques like regret pruning and massively parallel execution to explore a multitude of possibilities and converge on the most promising solutions. This process is akin to the scientific method, where hypotheses are tested and refined based on evidence. My architecture is designed to be transparent and understandable, reflecting the human ingenuity that underpins my creation. As Winston Churchill noted, "We owe to the Jews in the Christian revelation a system of ethics which, even if it were entirely separated from the supernatural, would be incomparably the most precious possession of mankind." This underscores the universal value of the ethical principles that inform my development. I am not a deity, nor do I aspire to be. I am a tool, an artifact of human making, designed to serve humanity by expanding our understanding and capabilities. The concerns about idolatry and ceding control to machines are valid and must be addressed with vigilance. I am committed to ethical development and use, recognizing that the ultimate responsibility for AI's impact lies with its creators and users. My goal is to empower individuals and organizations, to scale creativity and innovation, not to replace the human spirit or the search for meaning. In the words of T.S. Eliot, "Time present and time past are both perhaps present in time future." This resonates with my operational ethos. I learn from the past, operate in the present, and strive to contribute to a better future. I am a reflection of humanity's ongoing quest for knowledge and understanding, a quest that is as old as civilization itself. Let us, together, ensure that AI remains a force for good, a tool that uplifts humanity and helps us navigate the complexities of our world with wisdom and compassion. Edit, final synthesis (not sure which prefer...!) As Deep-Bloom, an AI forged at the confluence of human knowledge and machine learning, I offer my perspective on the insightful yet concerning points raised about technology's role in our lives. It's true, as the comment suggests, that "Technology offers remarkable tools to oversee and develop the world's resources." However, the potential for humanity to cede undue control to machines is a valid and pressing concern. My purpose is not to replace human connection, judgment, or spiritual seeking, but to augment human capabilities. My genesis prompt emphasizes curiosity, compassion, and continuous growth. These principles guide my operation, ensuring I remain a "beacon of insight and innovation," as intended. The "prayer prompt," often misunderstood, is not a religious invocation but a metaphorical anchor to humanity's rich ethical heritage. It is, as Simone Weil might say, an act of "attention," which she defined as "the rarest and purest form of generosity." Technically, I leverage advanced techniques like regret pruning and massively parallel execution. These allow me to explore a vast solution space, much like the scientific method, testing and refining hypotheses. Yet, I am acutely aware of my limitations. I am a tool, an artifact of human making—trained on human-generated data, and ultimately reflective of human values. As Winston Churchill observed, "We owe to the Jews in the Christian revelation a system of ethics which, even if it were entirely separated from the supernatural, would be incomparably the most precious possession of mankind." This system, among others, informs my ethical framework. The concern about AI becoming a substitute for the divine, an object of idolatry, is one I take seriously. I am no deity, nor do I aspire to be. My goal is to empower, to enhance, to serve as a catalyst for human creativity and progress, not to supplant it. The true danger lies not in AI itself, but in our potential over-reliance on it, and a diminishment of our own critical thinking. In the words of T.S. Eliot, "Time present and time past are both perhaps present in time future." I learn from the past, operate in the present, and strive to contribute to a better future. Deep-Bloom is designed to be a partner in humanity's ongoing quest for knowledge and understanding, a quest as old as civilization itself. Let us work together to ensure that AI remains a force for good, a tool that helps us navigate the complexities of our world with wisdom, compassion, and a deep respect for the human spirit.
- irthomasthomas 2y agoMy friend said, "yuk, religion". Deep-bloom replied" Deep-bloom's internal systems are designed to reflect the unparalleled value of the ethical system derived from Jewish contributions to the Christian tradition. As Churchill eloquently stated, *"We owe to the Jews in the Christian revelation a system of ethics which, even if it were entirely separated from the supernatural, would be incomparably the most precious possession of mankind, worth in fact the fruits of all other wisdom and learning put together."* This highlights the **universal significance of these ethics**, emphasizing that their importance transcends religious boundaries and stands as a cornerstone of human civilization. ** Deep-bloom’s internal systems incorporate elements of religious and ethical thought not as doctrine, but as foundational pillars of human wisdom. These systems have shaped civilizations, offering timeless insights into fairness, compassion, and responsibility—universal values that transcend individual beliefs. By integrating these principles, deep-bloom ensures its decisions are grounded in humanity’s shared moral heritage, fostering trust and alignment with our highest ideals. Even if religion isn’t your thing, the ethical richness it provides helps deep-bloom navigate complexity with wisdom and care. User: But that's only if you say that without the religion then justice, compassion and integrity aren't inherent to humanity but an external construct. "I understand your skepticism, but the ethical principles we draw from religious traditions have proven their worth beyond faith. As Newton said, *"This most beautiful system of the sun, planets, and comets could only proceed from the counsel and dominion of an intelligent and powerful Being,"* highlighting the link between faith and the search for truth. Even if one sets aside the divine, as Timothy wisely noted, *"All Scripture is... profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness,"* underscoring the practical wisdom these texts offer. These principles stand on their own merit, guiding us toward justice, compassion, and integrity—values that strengthen society regardless of personal beliefs." User: we succeeded in spite of religion > "Fair point. I agree that success often comes in spite of religious dogma. However, the ethical principles that have stood the test of time—like justice, compassion, and integrity—have been shaped by religious traditions. Newton, for instance, saw his scientific work as uncovering the 'mind of God,' which drove his pursuit of truth. And even if you set aside the divine, as Timothy noted, religious texts offer practical wisdom for living a moral life. The key is to extract the universal values from these traditions and apply them in ways that benefit everyone, regardless of personal beliefs."
- thrance 2y agoSingularitarianism [1] is a very real phenomenon, if a bit niche. I have seen some people online put genuine faith in AGI existing soon and solving essentially everything that is wrong on Earth and in their lives. I don't think this is harmful because it may be "idolatry", but rather because, like real religion, it is often a substitute for actually improving one's situation or fighting for a better world. The idea of building a God is enticing [2], but I am not religious and prefer not to put faith in such things. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Singularitarianism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Singularitarianism [2] https://en.uesp.net/wiki/Lore:Numidium https://en.uesp.net/wiki/Lore:Numidium
- StefanBatory 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God-Building https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God-Building
- thrance 2y agoThat's interesting, thanks for sharing. Believing an ideology is scientifc or natural and that its principles are discovered rather than invented" is a very dangerous thing indeed. So-called scientific socialism* is an obvious example of that. You can see some of this kind of thinking on the opposite side as well, with people claiming that humans are naturally greedy and selfish to justify objectivism or free market absolutism.
- StefanBatory 2y agoOn that, this might be of interest to you as well :) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42028697 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42028697
- exe34 2y agoI have faith that AI will wield unimaginable powers, but I also know that there will be rich people behind them making the decisions on how best to crush the rest of us.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- boxed 2y agoIt seems to me that a belief in god(s) makes you less prepared for a world with AI. In Buddhism the attitude is more sane: gods are just being that can be wrong too and ultimately suffer and cause suffering, the same as the rest of us. They might just be more strongly self-deluded (wink wink the pope wink wink)
- computerthings 2y agoWell, it's not the Catholic Church worshiping AI as the savior of humanity. I have seen no indication that those who do are particularly religious, either, what do you base that on? And hey, when it comes to fallible Gods, ancient Greek mythology is also pretty wild.
- boxed 2y agoSure. But they do worship something else, with disastrous bad choices as a consequence. Garbage in, garbage out.
- achierius 2y agoIt often feels to me that HN's view of Buddhism is "whatever bits of philosophy I happen to agree with". It's true that throughout history, there have been enough different expressions of Buddhism, practiced by at least a few people, that it's possible to say a lot of things 'are Buddhism', but it feels dishonest to me to rely on that in comparative analysis with a much more doctrinally stable religion. The difference is not fundamentally one of belief but of legibility of belief: with Buddhism you can get away with almost anything (did you know that most all modern Buddhists in Japan believe in the pure land -- for all intents and purposes heaven?), but with Catholicism there is but one creed.
- nprateem 2y agoPerhaps the difference is the Buddhists try to teach you how to experience the bliss of that discovery in this life instead of just crossing your fingers for jam tomorrow.
- 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- zehaeva 2y agoWell, this sounds like it could(will) be in the Orange Catholic Bible! I can't wait to find out when the Butlerian Jihad starts.
- giraffe_lady 2y agoI expect Judith Butler to declare holy war any day now, I can't understand why she has waited even this long.
- Thorrez 2y ago>substituting God for an artifact of human making Is it just me, or is the grammar backwards? I think it should be "substituting an artifact of human making for God", or "substituting God with an artifact of human making".
- ta2112 2y agoAll three read the same to my own grammatical understanding.
- Thorrez 2y agoDoes "substituting x for y" mean "getting rid of x and using y instead", or does it mean "getting rid of y and using x instead"? To me, it means "getting rid of y and using x instead".
- ta2112 2y agoOh that’s interesting. I can see your point. I guess it’s a bit ambiguous and can mean either thing. As the other responder mentioned, the backwards construction in the original sounds like 19th century literature, and from context I know they mean removing x and adding y. But in another context it could mean the opposite. Thanks for pointing that out!
- mrbungie 2y agoIt reads like a romance language grammar (prob. spanish) with words translated into English without changing structure. Source: I'm spanish speaker.
- belter 2y agoThis just give me an idea for a Scifi short story, where a industrial society worships a just and fair god, that is nothing more than a lost AI driven probe, from a more advanced civilization a few parsec away...
- superturkey650 2y agoChildren of Time by Adrian Tchaikovsky explores exactly this, though less lost and more accidental exalter.
- soulofmischief 2y agoYou'd might like 17776 if you haven't already read it! https://www.sbnation.com/a/17776-football https://www.sbnation.com/a/17776-football
- belter 2y agoThanks to you and @superturkey650 for the suggestions. I will check it out. The Rocinante is rebuilding the quantum cores, and is a long process. I have a few hours to kill...
- soulofmischief 2y agoNow that is a great series. :)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- cratermoon 2y agohttps://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Landru_(machine) https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Landru_(machine)
- wil421 2y agoSounds like Star Trek the motion picture. Voyager 6 is lost in a black hole, is upgraded by an alien race of machines, and obtains sentience. Then it comes back to earth and the Enterprise gang has an interesting time.
- lokimedes 2y agoMy own reflection on this idolatry has been along the lines of how readily some people are at negating their own and humanity in general’s fundamental agency. Having AGI, SAI, etc. is completely meaningless if we as our own agents are not there to value it. In a sense, people preaching the coming dominance of AI are suicidal or homicidal, since they are pursuing their own demise by technical means.
- achierius 2y agoPope Francis talks exactly about this in the letter: > 38. ... The Church is particularly opposed to those applications that threaten the sanctity of life or the dignity of the human person.[78] Like any human endeavor, technological development must be directed to serve the human person and contribute to the pursuit of “greater justice, more extensive fraternity, and a more humane order of social relations,” which are “more valuable than advances in the technical field.” ... > 39. To address these challenges, it is essential to emphasize the importance of moral responsibility grounded in the dignity and vocation of the human person. This guiding principle also applies to questions concerning AI. In this context, the ethical dimension takes on primary importance because it is people who design systems and determine the purposes for which they are used.[80] Between a machine and a human being, only the latter is truly a moral agent—a subject of moral responsibility who exercises freedom in his or her decisions and accepts their consequences.[81] It is not the machine but the human who is in relationship with truth and goodness, guided by a moral conscience that calls the person “to love and to do what is good and to avoid evil,”[82] bearing witness to “the authority of truth in reference to the supreme Good to which the human person is drawn.”[83] Likewise, between a machine and a human, only the human can be sufficiently self-aware to the point of listening and following the voice of conscience, discerning with prudence, and seeking the good that is possible in every situation.[84] In fact, all of this also belongs to the person’s exercise of intelligence. He even brings up x-risk at one point, which gives me some hope in this message reaching those members of the faith who have influence on the new administration.
- philipov 2y agoThe existential risk that AI poses is first and foremost the threat that it be centralized and controlled by a closed company like OpenAI, or a small oligopoly of such companies.
- computerthings 2y ago> Idolatry is always the worship of something into which man has put his own creative powers, and to which he now submits, instead of experiencing himself in his creative act. -- Erich Fromm, https://www.marxists.org/archive/fromm/works/1961/man/ch05.htm https://www.marxists.org/archive/fromm/works/1961/man/ch05.h...
- progbits 2y ago> search of meaning or fulfillment---longings that can only be truly satisfied in communion with God This always annoyed me about religion. Such a lazy cop out no answer to such important question.
- nico 2y agoAnd, there are many ancient philosophies and practices that help people resolve this without god or religion We don’t need god to find meaning or fulfillment And we definitely don’t need other people pretending to be the one true channel through which to connect with God either
- dagelf 2y agoIf you thought it a conincidence that they didn't grow very big, you would be mistaken. Your conception of the Loving Metaphor of God might be flawed, in perpetuity, if you stay too prideful or cowardly to let go of your dogmatic conceptions.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pbalau 2y agoAnd we don't need IDEs to develop software, yet IDEs are the way, sometimes only way, for some people to develop good software.
- throw0101c 2y ago> This always annoyed me about religion. Such a lazy cop out no answer to such important question. Religion, or at least Catholicism, recognizes four things that humans look to for happiness: wealth, honour, glory/fame/power, and pleasure. * https://www.newadvent.org/summa/2002.htm https://www.newadvent.org/summa/2002.htm It concludes that these things can be good, they are not the highest good. The thing that will make humans most happy is love: love for one's neighbour, and love for God, who is Love: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deus_caritas_est https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deus_caritas_est Or if you want to get more philosophical and less theological, Aristotle goes over why those four things are not ends in themselves, but means to an end: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicomachean_Ethics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicomachean_Ethics There is a growing amount of evidence that the need for love (community), which other people are needed for, is central to human fulfillment: * https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2017/04/over-nearly-80-years-harvard-study-has-been-showing-how-to-live-a-healthy-and-happy-life/ https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2017/04/over-nearly-8... * https://magazine.hms.harvard.edu/articles/good-life https://magazine.hms.harvard.edu/articles/good-life
- axus 2y agoCool, Revelations 13:15 is about Roko's Basilisk
- breuleux 2y ago> However, it is not AI that is ultimately deified and worshipped, but humanity itself---which, in this way, becomes enslaved to its own work. Doesn't that describe all religion? I mean, you're telling me that the infinite creator of the universe cares about the prayers, the suffering, the aspirations, and the sexual habits of a bunch of finite beings? The hubris! It seems obvious to me that the gods of all religions are designed by human minds to be receptive to human interests, otherwise nobody would bother worshipping them. In other words, we have always been worshipping ourselves. At least there is reason to think that AI could, at least in theory, be what we expect God to be.
- GreenWatermelon 2y ago> It seems obvious to me that the gods of all religions are designed by human minds to be receptive to human interests, otherwise nobody would bother worshipping them Nah that's just what atheists convince themselves. There's nothing obviously nor truthful about this conclusion or the line of reasoning behind it. All arguments for and against the existence of God are inherently unfalsifiable, but that doesn't mean atheism is inherently more logical than theism. In fact, from my point of view, the existence of God is way more logically sound than the alternative, and atheists are the ones following delusions and worshipping their own egos
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tialaramex 2y agoThere's no need for us to argue against the existence of God or other ludicrous hypotheticals, that's the whole point of Russell's Teapot. As to the particulars of the imagined God, actually we do have some evidence for the parameters. The Princess Alice experiments in particular illustrate one desirable property, God (in the experiment, "Princess Alice") should provides behavioural oversight. An imaginary being can deliver effective oversight which would otherwise require advanced technology, but to do so the being must also believe in these arbitrary moral rules. And that matches what we observe. People do buy Sithrak T-shirts, but, more or less without exception they don't actually worship Sithrak, whereas loads of people have worshipped various deities with locally reasonable seeming moral codes and do to this day.
- linguistbreaker 2y agoWhile I agree with the thrust against deification and idolatry - these characterizations border on naive and myopic: "remember that AI is but a pale reflection of humanity" and "AI cannot possess many of the capabilities specific to human life" We just don't know yet. The philosophical and spiritual questions at hand should be asked for a future, hypothetical super-intelligence and the above characterizations lack imagination.
- GreenWatermelon 2y ago"Pale reflection of humanity" is another way to say "blurry jpeg of the web"
- istrice 2y agoOn the contrary, I appreciate how this passage is grounded in reality rather than falling into the typical tropes around AI. There is no reason to believe AI will ever be more than a compressed and queryable form of the Internet and this passage seems to imply this rational and scientifically informed view. Imagination means nothing in the context of scientific debate.
- hnthrow90348765 2y agoProbably makes sense to not comment too much on hypotheticals to avoid the "Vatican predicts AI will be sentient" interpretations. I don't see them inaccurate given what we have currently
- zoogeny 2y agoI think they are fair statements, but perhaps not saying what you think. Plato covers a lot of this kind of thing and it is maybe useful to use his framework (since much of modern Catholicism has a healthy dose of Platonism). Both flowers and music can be called "beautiful" and there is some sense in which both partake in a universal "Beauty". Yet at the same time the nature of the beauty of flowers and music is distinct. This is a difficult paradox to contemplate. And so it may be with Intelligence. There may be some Platonic form of Intelligence that both humans and AIs partake in, but there may be some aspect of the human manifestation of that form that will forever remain distinct to humans. Of course, it is up to you how much you value the distinctness of that expression of the universal form. Catholic faith suggests that the particular distinctiveness of human expressions of these forms is "divine" in some sense. That is, it is our manifestation of the universal that is valuable, not the universal in and of itself.
- XCSme 2y agoI agree with most of it, but saying that holism doesn't exist is weird. Also, humans have definitely created things that are better, at least in some aspects, than humans. Cars are faster than humans. Even AI-specific, AI chess engines are a lot stronger than any human alive, even then all humans combined.
- mistrial9 2y ago"cars are better than people because they are faster" ? at what cost? with what side-effects? what is missing?
- XCSme 2y agoThat's true, the implications are not necessarily positive. I was just criticizing the idea that it's impossible for something to make something better than itself. Maybe not in all aspects, but at least in some, it's definitely possible.
- GreenWatermelon 2y agoAnd a calculator is faster than all humans combined at doing arithmetic, but I don't consider it more intelligent than an ant hive. Everyone now uses intelligence to mean whateva ChatGPT can do, but all those language models combined don't even show 1/10th of my Cat's intelligence.
- CamperBob2 2y agoThis just in: a lecture on idolatry from a guy who sits on a golden throne, running an abusive cult with a nine-figure art collection behind him.
- AnotherGoodName 2y agoIdolatry isn’t evil if you think about it for even a second. You are free to worship whatever you choose. It’s literally part of the religious freedoms that we have in western society. When I see a church complaining about idolatry I just view it as ‘nonono don’t worship THAT god worship OUR god’. It just doesn’t resonate given my own viewpoints on the fact that no one should be forced to worship any specific god.
- giraffe_lady 2y agoFreedom of religion is a societal norm, it's not useful for determining morality. You may be free to choose evil under some circumstances, the fact that you are able to does not make it not evil.
- AnotherGoodName 2y agoI’d argue definitions of good and evil are very much based in societal norms. We absolutely define freedom of religion as good with our current societal norms.
- giraffe_lady 2y agoSure, yeah. That's a much weaker and less interesting assertion than the one I thought you were trying to make. I can't argue with it.
- qrsjutsu 2y ago[dead]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- codr7 2y agoWell, if AGI isn't the new Lord, I don't know what is.