4 ms·
Exactly right. And if you want your data to be reposted on another site, then you should repost it. Craigslist is delivering exactly what it its users signed u
by eli 14y ago
Exactly right. And if you want your data to be reposted on another site, then you should repost it.
Craigslist is delivering exactly what it its users signed up for (no more no less). People posting ads on Craigslist do not necessarily want or intend for it to be reposted on other sites.
- mnicole 14y ago> And if you want your data to be reposted on another site, then you should repost it. I had to giggle a little bit at this in the grand scheme of the internet, sorry. When I posted something on Facebook Marketplace, I started getting emails and comments from other "market" sites that Facebook had cross-posted my listing to. While it was annoying to not know this up front, the fact that it was more visible and getting more bites because of it only helped me make the sale quicker. If a service wants to piggyback off of another to make my postings more buoyant, as a user and seller, I don't have a problem with it.
- hollerith 14y agoIn response to your "only helped": on one of the other Padmapper stories here on HN, someone wrote that after their item sold and they cancelled the Craigslist ad, they continued to get contacted about the item because third parties had scraped the ad and did not stop displaying their copy when the ad disappeared from Craigslist.
- mnicole 14y agoThis happened to me on the Facebook ad too, but I preferred it it over the lack of any response at all - it proved the services were used. Easy to ignore them or send a generic reply.
- eli 14y agoPersonally, I'd prefer if Facebook acted a little more like Craigslist with my data, not the other way around.
- wwweston 14y agoInterestingly, in both cases, the economic incentives for operators seem to be basically counter to likely user intent and expectations.
- pg 14y ago"People posting ads on Craigslist do not necessarily want or intend for it to be reposted on other sites." That argument appears to be invalidated by Craiglist's own terms of use, which say that when you upload a listing to Craigslist they can syndicate it wherever they want (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4287519 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4287519).
- res0nat0r 14y agoThe key point is that the TOS says that you grant Craigslist the right to redistribute your listing where ever they see fit, it doesn't say some third party entity has the right to do that.
- csallen 14y agoAs far as I'm aware, if you post information in a place where it will be publicly accessible, then you are tacitly agreeing that third parties will be able to access it and use it as they please. That's not a right that needs to be given to these third parties. It exists from the get-go, and must be explicitly taken away by something like copyright.
- res0nat0r 14y agoSo I can legally start amazon-copied-reviews.com and scrape every product review from amazon.com with my own referrer links to Walmart without fear of repercussion? Sweet.
- pg 14y agoYes it does: "fully sub-licensable (through multiple tiers)"
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoLicensing implies getting CL's authorisation
- malandrew 14y agoUh oh... Bye bye Google and all search engines.
- cft 14y agoGoogle obeys robots.txt file. Padmapper does not. That's a critical difference.
- malandrew 14y agoTrue, but that's irrelevant to the comment I was replying to. We are talking about user expectations with regard to content they posted being made available on other sites.
- operand 14y agoCL's robot.txt file does not 'disallow' crawling the real estate section. So Padmapper was likely as compliant as Google. http://www.craigslist.org/robots.txt http://www.craigslist.org/robots.txt
- eli 14y agoNo, this is just semantics. The point is Google respects publishers' desire not to be indexed. Padmapper does not. Robots.txt is simply a common method for conveying that message. It's not like Padmapper could argue they didn't know CL was unhappy; they got a certified letter! This is just semantics. Google respects publishers who do not want their sites listed.
- dschobel 14y agoGood luck explaining that to a judge. Would you gamble a company based on that distinction?
- wwweston 14y agoPadmapper's isn't "reposting" any given listing -- it displays an abbreviated digest of the listing in its search results, and then if the user clicks, it takes them to the original listing. If this is illegal or otherwise objectionable without an explicit agreement from each Craigslist poster, I'm not really sure how a search engine or even descriptive hyperlinking is kosher without explicit agreement from each website indexed or referred to.