3 ms·
Yes amusing, since unsolicited polishing, but I sincerely doubt this was forced on our fine humorist. English to English editing or “translation” from snarky to
by robwwilliams 2y ago
Yes amusing, since unsolicited polishing, but I sincerely doubt this was forced on our fine humorist. English to English editing or “translation” from snarky to suave is straightforward to understand and fix.
But what about translation by professional human translators between languages? is it really any better at preserving the intent and sub-text?
Kundera has an amazing essay—- “The Sentence”—-in his collection of essays “Testaments Betrayed” on the woes of translation of, yes, a single sentence from Kafka’s “The Castle”.
As he (or his translator Linda Asher) say: The sentence “describes the coition of K. and Frieda”.
Under the bar too ;-)
Not a topic I tend to associate with Franz Kafka.
When AI systems can match Milan Kundera (translated from the French) then we will have definitely gotten to Pro level. “Write me a brilliant essay in the style of xxxx, on topic yyyy in French, and translate it into Mandarin for grins. I would be a wreck if I had to translate Kundera.