3 ms·
There have been plenty of subsidies for solar. The government spent money researching it early on, such as for the space program. Then the government has out
by PaulHoule 2y ago
There have been plenty of subsidies for solar.
The government spent money researching it early on, such as for the space program. Then the government has outright subsidized solar installations on roofs, etc. Part of the solar miracle of the last 15 years have been huge demand-side subsidies by China because they want to corner the market.
- ajross 2y agoSo, sure, and you'd absolutely take those into consideration when deciding whether solar is cost-competetive, right? That said, recognize that there's an important difference here. Virtually all solar subsidies are on the demand side of the equation. They pay homeowners to buy solar, and act to increase the size of the market. They don't make solar cheaper to produce (except via second order effects due to the resulting scale). Nuclear wasn't like that in the 60's and 70's. The government was handing the checks to the reactor builders, not the consumers.
- PaulHoule 2y agoChina subsidizes supply, the US subsidizes demand. Communism in China and Russia was always about out-capitalizing the capitalists.
- ajross 2y agoYou keep moving goalposts. The US nuclear industry in its early decades was absolutely subsidized at the supply side, making reactors cheaper and creating the illusion that the technology was cost-competitive with fossil fuel generators, when it never was and almost certainly never will be. Solar doesn't have that property. Solar is in most areas reasonably competitive already, and the subsidies work towards increasing the size of its market.
- natmaka 2y ago> illusion that the technology was cost-competitive with fossil fuel generators The hope, then, was to quickly obtain an industrial breeder reactor in order to considerably reduce (or even suppress any) dependency towards uranium providers (there is no known similar trick for oil/methane). It failed, and it may be a major cause of the current nuclear demise.
- pfdietz 2y agoI don't see how this can be the major cause, since fuel is only a minor part of the cost of nuclear power.
- natmaka 2y agoIt is not about cost but about availability: without any breeder a reactor needs way more (at least x30, up to x100) uranium. "identified uranium reserves recoverable at US$130/kg ((...)) At the rate of consumption in 2017, these reserves are sufficient for slightly over 130 years of supply" Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uranium_mining#Peak_uranium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uranium_mining#Peak_uranium In other words the already precarious and degrading case of nuclear as a sound investment further degrades with each and every new reactor, up to the catastrophic "no more uranium for a reactor not yet amortized". Nuclear now produces, worldwide, about 10% of electricity which is less than 25% of final energy: nuclear produces about 2.5% if final energy. Build reactors to have it reach about 7% and there is not enough guaranteed uranium for all reactors to produce 100% of their theoretical output for about 40 years => from an investor's viewpoint it is moot. Exploration is a bet: the uranium bubble (2007) triggered an impressive exploration raise, which had very insufficient results (reserves: + ~15%). To reduce greenhouse gas emissions we have to electrify numerous applications and therefore will need at least 2x more electricity: those ~7% (of current electricity demand) will then be ~3%. Tripling the nuclear output this way means maintaining the (already old) fleet of reactors and building approx 600 more. Before 2050?! In the event of a nuclear 'renaissance', those limited uranium deposits will be subjugated by superpowers. In the event of a serious accident all hope to amortize may be instantaneously lost. No industrial breeder => game over.