4 ms·
When you can't beat them, sue them into the ground. Craigslist is one of the poorest user experiences around and succeeds only because people insist on using i
by astrodust 14y ago
When you can't beat them, sue them into the ground.
Craigslist is one of the poorest user experiences around and succeeds only because people insist on using it. The alternatives somehow manage to be even more spectacularly useless by over-designing their apps and cluttering them up with junk.
Padmapper is one of the few that does what they're supposed to do, and it's not even an optimal implementation of this sort of thing.
- flatline3 14y agoWhen you can't beat them, steal their work product. Padmapper is (indirectly) screen-scraping Craigslist's data in an attempt to unseat Craigslist.
- diminoten 14y ago> in an attempt to unseat Craigslist. Unseat Craigslist as the undisputed champion of what, exactly? Cartographical apartment hunting?
- gfosco 14y agoThey are the champion of free listings, and built a huge user base around their dead simple platform.
- astrodust 14y agoIf these were articles written by professional writers, you might have a case. Instead these are posts written by many different individuals trying to advertise their properties. Craigslist didn't write a single one of those posts. They try and assert control over this content through their terms of service: "You automatically grant and assign to CL, and you represent and warrant that you have the right to grant and assign to CL, a perpetual, irrevocable, unlimited, fully paid, fully sub-licensable (through multiple tiers), worldwide license to copy, perform, display, distribute, prepare derivative works from (including, without limitation, incorporating into other works) and otherwise use any content that you post. You also expressly grant and assign to CL all rights and causes of action to prohibit and enforce against any unauthorized copying, performance, display, distribution, use or exploitation of, or creation of derivative works from, any content that you post (including but not limited to any unauthorized downloading, extraction, harvesting, collection or aggregation of content that you post)." The last part of that may not be enforceable. They're asserting that they are singularly responsible for "authorizing" reproduction despite not having copyright for the material in question.
- rprasad 14y agoCraiglist doesn't need to write those posts. Under their TOS, Craiglist has a license to the posts (which are copyrighted by their owners ). This license gives Craiglist the authority to enforce copyright against persons who interfere with Craigslists' license in the posts. Thus, the last sentence of their TOS is perfectly legal and enforceable. The license would not give Craiglist a license to do anything to other services on which the original posters also post their listings to. But that is not the case here.
- kytmizuno 14y agoFrom what I've read, only the actual copyright holder has the right to sue others for copyright infringement. See the Righthaven case from last year. http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2011/09/righthaven-copyright-suits-tossed-in-colorado-too/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2011/09/righthaven-copyri...
- iamwil 14y agoNot true. You wouldn't link back to Craigslist if you wanted to unseat them.
- ori_b 14y ago> Craigslist is one of the poorest user experiences around and succeeds only because people insist on using it. So, to paraphrase, it only succeeds because something about it attracts customers. As opposed to other sites, which succeed by fairy dust and rainbows. If padmapper has a great user experience, that's wonderful -- They should be able to get customers to post their listings on it, and generate data without relying on Craigslist. Or, if they rely on Craigslist, and what the article said is true, they could have negociated a license to the data, instead of scraping it.
- mikeash 14y agoCL won because it got the first mover advantage, and now benefits greatly from network effects. It could be much improved over what it is, but it has little incentive to change now.
- astrodust 14y agoIt only succeeds because it has a historical legacy that's proving difficult to displace. This is the same thing driving eBay. It's a difficult nut to crack. Kajiji seems to be gaining some traction, but it's trading one set of UX nightmares for another.
- debacle 14y agoKajiji is owned by eBay.
- astrodust 14y agoI would've guessed Yahoo! by the amount of visual clutter they've created.
- jonny_eh 14y agoIt's http://kijiji.com http://kijiji.com (looks to be ebayized now). Although in Canada, http://kijiji.ca http://kijiji.ca is more popular than Craigslist.
- pat2man 14y agoI am sure Craigslist has many more users than Padmapper. It would he hard to argue that Craigslist can't "beat" them.
- jblock 14y ago"Craigslist is one of the poorest user experiences around and succeeds only because people insist on using it." If a lot of people INSIST on using it, then that means it has good UX. Complaints with their UX should be qualified.
- astrodust 14y agoPeople insist on using it not because it has a good user experience, but because of content. It has a terrible user experience. Don't confuse the two things. For instance, many payroll companies have truly awful sites, yet people use them since they have no other choice. As a specific example, searching for an apartment should not mean reading every single listing in order to discern where the property is, what features are available, and what conditions apply. That people post the same listing repeatedly until it is rented is not helping matters. eBay, which is arguably still quite primitive, has much better filtering options, alerts, and a single listing that persists until the auction is completed. Craiglist is a series of random, repetitive posts with only a minimum of categorization. Padmapper provided a superior way to navigate listing data and present it in a much more meaningful presentation. Being able to "favorite" listings helps when filtering.
- jblock 14y agoI'd be interested to see interaction studies in the non-tech community about Craigslist, because I haven't seen a person in non-tech find difficulty in posting on Craigslist. Also, don't confuse my opinions about Craigslist's design/UX with an opinion on the case. I've used Padmapper extensively. While I believe that Craigslist has a right to do what they please with their content, I don't see what Padmapper was doing as wholly legally wrong.
- dap 14y agoPosting is not the UI problem. Browsing posts is the problem.
- rprasad 14y agoCraiglist has a great UX for a classifieds board: location > type of listing > listings by date. It may look butt ugly, but it is as close to a functionally efficient classifieds board as you can get. Craigslist isn't trying to be anything more than that.
- jacoblyles 14y ago>"Craigslist is one of the poorest user experiences around and succeeds only because people insist on using it" Please use the proper legal word - "Monopoly". I wonder how the Department of Justice decides who to prosecute?