My point was, the court probably brought into consideration the Apple device itself and not just the design patent. With that design patent (iirc it was just so

My point was, the court probably brought into consideration the Apple device itself and not just the design patent. With that design patent (iirc it was just some sketch and a few words) you could ban practically every tablet. As we see from this decision it's not the case. Differences between those two Samsung Tabs are only cosmetic. I still think that design patents should not exist. If there really has to be a design patent, then it should be very specific and not like the one for iPad.