3 ms·
If a "humanoid" from this planet visited Earth with 1/6 of their normal gravity, would they be a super athlete, or barely functional?
by dylan604 2y ago
If a "humanoid" from this planet visited Earth with 1/6 of their normal gravity, would they be a super athlete, or barely functional?
- ceejayoz 2y agoEver pick up what you thought was gonna be a really heavy box and it turned out to be empty, and got briefly thrown off-balance? I'd imagine that, but for everything.
- dylan604 2y agoOh good, so it's not just me that happened to!
- tokai 2y agoThe moons gravity is 1/6 of the Earths. So looking at our moon visitors performance, a super earth visitor would probably be great at high jump but pretty shaky at anything else.
- gpm 2y agoI wonder if jumping even makes sense at 6x gravity... maybe they would never have learned how to jump at all and always keep some limbs in contact with the ground. Or if "humanoid" even makes sense. Something snake like that can spread out the pressure along a longer surface might be better. Or at least something with more than two legs.
- josefx 2y agoWhat body shape would creatures living at six times the gravity even have? Would they be able to jump? Would they have a skeleton as we know it? I would almost go looking at deep sea creatures that have to deal with extreme pressures on earth.
- short_sells_poo 2y agoThey might have to be entirely aquatic at that point or perhaps have some very exotic skeletal structure that can support their weight. Perhaps ball shaped beings who roll around instead of any sort of walking? I'm unsure how would they deal with a small incline. Weight lifters are able to lift 6x their body weights, but it's not a sort of load that we could profitably exist under long term. We'd need to have extremely thick limbs and at some point that won't help either because of the cross-section vs. weight scaling law. It's also a sort of weight where any kind of leverage against a joint will generate massive forces. E.g. try catching a 50kg falling weight, you are likely to dislocate your joints and/or break some bones. And yet 1/6 of that is entirely manageable.
- upghost 2y agoI asked a physicist friend about this. At 6x mass, it would only be 6x the gravity if it was the same size as Earth. Depending on the density, the gravity could actually be weaker than Earth!
- dylan604 2y agoYeah, not having the radius/diameter of the planet mentioned really hurts understanding the effect of that mass. However, I doubt it is like Saturn where it could float in water.
- UltraSane 2y agoIf intelligent life exists on a superearth it would be trapped there because rockets wouldn't be able to reach orbit. In fact 1.4g seems to be the max that chemical rockets can escape. Maybe they could built an electromagnetic launcher on top of a absolutely huge ramp.
- shepardrtc 2y agoOr they would be forced to figure out technology that we would consider science-fiction, assuming it's possible. To consider our tech as the pinnacle is the wrong approach, I think. Perhaps we've had it too easy here - moderate climate, oil as an easy fuel source, and gravity that isn't too oppressive. I wonder what technology would arise in a more difficult environment, such as this superearth.
- messe 2y agoNuclear thermal rockets would also be an option.
- MagicMoonlight 2y agoIronically I think you’d be more likely to go to space on such a planet. Imagine being barely able to jump, let alone fly. You would want to leave more than anything. It would be like a space race, against the universe. I’m imagining some sort of mega cannon or railgun as a propulsion method to fling them off the planet.