4 ms·
> Do we use alpha male gorillas to explain the concept? We should use chimpanzees. The popular definition evolved pretty much indepdenently of the science, unf
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> Do we use alpha male gorillas to explain the concept?
We should use chimpanzees. The popular definition evolved pretty much indepdenently of the science, unfortunately [1].
Management texts have tried toning this down, particularly in the gender-equality years. At its nonsensical limit one wound up with alpha = leader, which is tautologically useless as a tool for explaining leadership.
The term probably belongs in a bin. There are deep social lessons we can learn from observing chimpanzees. (Or even wolves.) But they're not going to condense into a single term, certainly not one that's been through the 4chan and partisan ringers. Even among chimpanzees, we see a variety of tactics used to achieve dominance, including groups of chimps banding together to topple a leader.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alpha_and_beta_male https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alpha_and_beta_male
- kryogen1c 2y ago> 4chan and partisan I love the dialectical equivalency here, Feels exactly accurate. At least 4chan plays you laugh you lose, federal politics seems to omit the first half. > dominance, including groups of chimps Indeed one of the most fascinating lessons. "Alpha" by force is almost tautologically impossible; leadership is built on inspiration and willfullness.
- Anotheroneagain 2y ago>We should use chimpanzees Why should we use anything at all? Aren't we people ourselves, who, you know, behave like people, without being taught how?
- pixl97 2y ago>behave like people, without being taught how Ok, what does this mean when pretty much all people are taught to be people by the generations before them? We throw out a number of feral children and see how they grow up in the wilds? Doesn't sound very ethical.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Why should we use anything at all? Same reason we play with models: it’s easier to understand through analogy, with the familiar cast unfamiliarly.
- xbar 2y agoAre there management texts from some era where this was actually promoted as a model?
- enragedcacti 2y agoEven within apes the variance is wide enough that I question the value in drawing any conclusions about human nature, especially for laypeople. Why chimpanzees and not bonobos who are equally close relatives to humans but whose social structure is matriarchal, non-territorial, and considerably less violent? There is such myriad behavior in the animal kingdom that drawing insight into human social structure from it seems like it is more often a Rorschach test than it is a scientific exercise.