4 ms·
It should be noted that what is needed for assembly line productivity is different than what is needed for complex cognitive tasks. The more demanding the cogn
by btilly 14y ago
It should be noted that what is needed for assembly line productivity is different than what is needed for complex cognitive tasks. The more demanding the cognitive task, the more important sleep and relaxation are. That is why in Steve McConnell's classic Rapid Development he advocates a 35 hour week.
And the real limit for a lot of people may be less. For instance read http://www.kalzumeus.com/2012/05/18/kalzumeus-podcast-ep-2-with-amy-hoy-pricing-products-and-passion/ http://www.kalzumeus.com/2012/05/18/kalzumeus-podcast-ep-2-w... to find out that patio11 thinks that he can only be productive 2-4 hours per day. This is a man who started a business on the side while working the insane hours of a Japanese salaryman. It isn't that he can't put in the hours, it is what he can do and be productive.
Greatly complicating all of this is are two simple facts. The first is that we can push ourselves and be productive for a short period, so over a couple of weeks we really can work insane hours and be productive. The second is that we have coping mechanisms to hide our own inability from us - so as our ability to function disappears down the drain, it is very hard for us to judge how impaired we are.
To that end, there was an interesting piece of research that I read about many years ago. The military was conducting research on sleep deprivation. One of their findings was that soldiers can be trained to operate on 6 hours of sleep, and will self-report that that they are functioning well and getting more done than they could if they slept longer. However the wives of those soldiers disagreed. And when ability to perform was judged on standard ability tests, the wives were right.
If you, personally, work long hours and consistently get little sleep, there is some food for thought. Could you be getting more done if you took care of yourself and put in more reasonable hours?
- kamaal 14y ago>>It should be noted that what is needed for assembly line productivity is different than what is needed for complex cognitive tasks. Not actually. Assembly line work might be less intellectually appealing to us, but for a lot of people it is a complex cognitive task. If you were to talk to a every day assembly worker of an iPhone, he would find assembling complex circuitry pretty intellectually challenging. Things become less intellectually challenging as your brain gets seasoned to it. Even coding for that matter these days has become pretty less intellectually challenging. Growth of modern day IDE's have rendered many programmers into kind of code assembly workers, autocomplete/intellisense does most of thinking these days. >> The more demanding the cognitive task, the more important sleep and relaxation are. My dad is a cab driver and he used to drive trucks before. I can tell you this is not true. You can easily argue driving is a repetitive task once learned. But you have no clue how tiring it becomes. In general a hobby is enjoyable, but any thing taken up full time as a profession is tiring. In the book Flow by Mihály Csíkszentmihályi, he explains how once you get into Flow enough number of times, any job becomes boring and you have to keep moving higher up the ladder of difficult tasks to experience Flow again. So its not that we programmers do jobs which are the center of the universe. What is true for others is generally true for us too.
- stcredzero 14y ago> Growth of modern day IDE's have rendered many programmers into kind of code assembly workers, autocomplete/intellisense does most of thinking these days. Please tell me that there is irony involved in this quote. Otherwise the term "thinking" has been diluted to the point of existential crisis. What IDEs do is remembering and accounting. That's cognitive activity, but it's not something that involves sentience or thoughtfulness. What separates the best programmers from the herd is thinking, and it's not embodied in an IDE.
- kamaal 14y ago>>What IDEs do is remembering and accounting. Nearly all creative work is delta improvements on remembering and accounting previous sources of knowledge. >>What separates the best programmers from the herd is thinking, and it's not embodied in an IDE. What makes you think there are hundreds and thousands of best programmers?
- stcredzero 14y ago> Nearly all creative work is delta improvements on remembering and accounting previous sources of knowledge. [Citation Needed] > What makes you think there are hundreds and thousands of best programmers? There must be hundreds of thousands very good to pretty good programmers out there. To some extent what they do involves real thinking, though not necessarily all of it. Only the dimmest programmers are replaceable by a monkey with an IDE. IDEs are to programmers as circular saws are to carpenters. The tools an automate a lot of work, but what distinguishes good from bad and the very best from the merely good is genuine skill and knowledge. Idiots will be quite capable of hurting themselves and incurring great expense to their employers.
- mweibel 14y ago> Things become less intellectually challenging as your brain gets seasoned to it. That's obviously true. >Even coding for that matter these days has become pretty less intellectually challenging. Growth of modern day IDE's have rendered many programmers into kind of code assembly workers, autocomplete/intellisense does most of thinking these days. I don't think this is true. Of course IDEs made certain things easier like looking up class/method/function names and their documentation but imho that's not the hardest part about programming. Besides that I agree with you. You can't make a general statement about what is tiring for someone. I think working as a craftsman is as tiring as working as a programmer - it's just different. A craftsman's body will be tired and a programmer's brain will be tired.
- wslh 14y ago> It should be noted that what is needed for assembly line productivity is different than what is needed for complex cognitive tasks. The more demanding the cognitive task, the more important sleep and relaxation are. That is why in Steve McConnell's classic Rapid Development he advocates a 35 hour week. In my personal experience this is 100% right. But the reason could be the level of pressure and the anxiety involved. On manual jobs I can work more than 8 hours a day with a good productivity and without feeling tired. In software development I can't. Probably this depends on the pressure. If you are in a manual jobs with higher productivity pressure (like assemble <n> units a day where the average is less than that) will have a similar effect. Also I find a difference between people who have an expertise in a more specific software development field (SQL databases) than on people who jump to different problems/languages/technologies in different computer fields all the time. You can maintain your productivity if you narrowed your areas of expertise.
- pasbesoin 14y agoI'll add to your comment just my observation of the necessity for good health. Some injuries without ready solutions disrupted my focus to the point where I simply couldn't perform at my prior level, no matter how much raw effort, willpower, caffeine, etc. I attempted. Guard your health!
- SatvikBeri 14y agoThe article mentions a very similar result: "In a study on the effects of sleep deprivation, investigators at the University of Pennsylvania found that subjects who slept four to six hours a night for fourteen consecutive nights showed significant deficits in cognitive performance equivalent to going without sleep for up to three days in a row. Yet these subjects reported feeling only slightly sleepy and were unaware of how impaired they were."