3 ms·
There's a fascinating story about ego in science buried here. William Henry Preece was Engineer-In-Chief at the British Post Office in the late 19th Century (b
by rezmason 2y ago
There's a fascinating story about ego in science buried here.
William Henry Preece was Engineer-In-Chief at the British Post Office in the late 19th Century (basically heading their telegraphy efforts) and controversially stuck to Thomson's model, or the "KR Law" as it was called back then, relying on poor quality experimental results to direct the organization.
Oliver Heaviside publicly criticized Preece, who in turn blocked publication of Heaviside's writing to preserve his own reputation (according to Wikipedia). When Preece retired in 1899 and received a knighthood, Heaviside wrote in the preface of Volume II of "Electromagnetic Theory":
"It is to be hoped and expected that the late important removals in the British Telegraph Department will lead to much improvement in the quality of official science."
Writing by hand on his own copy, Heaviside suggested that the preface (and thus the book's publication) were "held back" so as to "allow W H Preece to make sure of his knighthood".
https://outsideecho.com/DGT-BIO_files/PDFs/DGT13.pdf https://outsideecho.com/DGT-BIO_files/PDFs/DGT13.pdf
So! On the one hand, we have an esteemed engineer who ran the country's telegraphs and refused to admit he made a mistake, became a knight and faded somewhat from history; on the other hand, we have a self-taught physicist who made massive contributions to our understanding and analysis of electromagnetism, lived in "relative poverty" for fifty years while doing so, didn't shy away from calling out bad science, and he gets the analogue of heaven named after him in the musical "CATS".
- brunohaid 2y agoNot a religious person, but there's something deeply spiritual about Katalin Karikó type characters, who throughout the ages stuck with their curiosities and craft for the craft's sake.
- astrange 2y agoA note on "craft" here is that Heaviside's other thing was inventing a kind of magical math that seems like it shouldn't work (even though it did) and ignoring everyone who complained about it. https://deadreckonings.com/2007/12/07/heavisides-operator-calculus/ https://deadreckonings.com/2007/12/07/heavisides-operator-ca... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operational_calculus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operational_calculus
- Stratoscope 2y agoIt wasn't just Cats. There really is a layer in the ionosphere called the Heaviside Layer, or more formally the Kennelly–Heaviside layer: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kennelly–Heaviside_layer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kennelly–Heaviside_layer Today this is more commonly known as the E layer or E region, and it is much beloved by ham radio operators because of its intermittent nature. You never know when sporadic E skip will become available and you can use it to contact hams far away!