4 ms·
X also isn't wrking for some. If you care about tearing for instance x doesn't work.
by bluGill 2y ago
X also isn't wrking for some. If you care about tearing for instance x doesn't work.
- yjftsjthsd-h 2y agoTrue; also various scaling problems, and its security situation. We're in an unfortunate situation where no option has everything. If you want to say "Wayland is better for what I need", or "Xorg is better for what I need", or even "Arcan is better for what I need", then that is 100% legitimate. I'm also cool with "the current problems with (X|Wayland|Arcan) are..." because that's constructive and useful for trying to improve them. It's only pretending that one doesn't have faults or insulting its users/proponents that I mind.
- Ballas 2y agoI haven't seen any tearing in X in at least 5 years - with nvidia, nouveau and intel drivers. I don't think I'm doing anything special to achieve this, so your comment seems like a strange assertion to me? I agree that X11 has some faults, and I really want Wayland to work, but everytime I try it, something ends up being broken.
- usr1106 2y agoI do see heavy tearing when watching videos under i3 on Ubuntu LTS and a 60 Hz monitor. So what? I just don't care. Tearing in videos does not hinder me from getting my work done. Watching videos is just wasting time most of the cases anyway.
- yjftsjthsd-h 2y ago> So what? I just don't care. Tearing in videos does not hinder me from getting my work done. Watching videos is just wasting time most of the cases anyway. It's fine for you to not care about that usecase, but other people do care and that's also valid. There even exist devices that mostly exist to watch video and we'd really like Linux and some standard graphics stack to work on them.
- usr1106 2y agoSure, I have no problem with people wanting to fix it. My datapoint was just in reply to someone writing that tearing under X has not occurred for 5 years.
- bandrami 2y agoFrom my standpoint as a software packager I have trouble believing that upending the entire video ecosystem on Linux was worth fixing this alleged "tearing" problem which is the main thing people bring up as the reason we all spent a decade doing this. (Along with some honestly fantastical worries about screen scraping -- the answer for that is open source.) Honestly Wim did this right on the audio side. If it was so important to bring what Wayland has brought someone should have written a display server that talked to display clients just like the old server did and upgraded gracefully if the client had the new capabilities. You didn't even have to recompile software to use pipewire, let alone rewrite it.
- LtWorf 2y agoThe real reason wayland was done is to put proprietary applications on the desktop. That's it.
- bandrami 2y agoWhich is ironic since it's the proprietary stuff I have to use that is least likely to work on Wayland at this point...
- yjftsjthsd-h 2y agoHow so? Proprietary apps work fine on X. Or do you mean the security angle where flatpak wants to be able to isolate untrusted (including proprietary) apps?
- LtWorf 2y agountrusted are only the proprietary apps… if you can review the code they aren't untrusted :)
- yjftsjthsd-h 2y agoI generally trust FOSS to not be malicious. I don't trust it to be bug free when processing untrusted input. So no, I really do want to sandbox plenty of apps regardless.
- eadmund 2y agoTiling window managers don’t tear.
- talldayo 2y agoTiling window managers tend to tear more than any other desktop out there. Especially on x11, where you're expected to composite your own desktop without any (!!!) synchronization primitives, it's extremely common to get halfscan output from your windows or status bar. dwm, awesome and i3wm will all tear by default because there is no dispatcher, internal clock or even adaptive sync support. Now, you might not notice the tearing if you've got V-sync properly configured. But V-Sync doesn't stop screen tearing, it just drops torn frames and decreases your refresh rate until your system can keep up with demand. It's an ugly hack on laptop hardware and an even uglier one on the desktop.
- eadmund 2y agoWell, I guess ‘window tearing’ doesn’t mean what I thought it did — or rather that it’s more than I thought. I always thought that it meant the artifact when dragging a changing window, which of course doesn’t happen if one doesn’t drag. I don’t believe that I’ve ever noticed or been bothered by static tearing, but maybe I’m just used to it because I’m old and displays have always had it?
- account42 2y agoNo tearing on my X.Org-based desktop for literally a decade.